@kmic (cc @freemo)
Thank you, my opinion exactly. While my ancestors didn't sign a form permitting me to speak for them, I think that having guns would have prevented neither of them to get murdered by a fascist state system that enjoyed popular support.

School shootings and mass shootings that seem to be monthly occurances in the US are an extreme atrocity here that luckily doesn't form part of our daily lives. And is a direct consequence of different gun policies. So thank you, no.

@thilosophus

You didnt have allies respecting alliances, you didnt have armies helping another army. You also wanted hitler to never take power.. guess what, you dont always get what you want. Which is exactly why if you had guns you could have protected yourelves, because no one was going to.

Notice america never managed to get invaded during ww2 though. We had guns.

@kmic

@freemo @kmic Whom are you referring to as "You"? I think you're mixing up an entire continent where you need to first differentiate in excruciating detail before making hypothetical statements about what would have happened if the entire continent was not only armed to the teeth with its militaries but also with its citizens on an individual level.

America not being invaded because citizens were individually armed made me laugh, thank you for that comedic relief :)

@thilosophus
European people at thr time of ww2 is who "you" is in that context

Funny.. you guys have two world wars under your belt, we have 0 in that same time. Sorry but going to have to go with america as clearly the greater expert on not getting invaded

@kmic

@freemo @kmic *sigh*
1) The Nazi party was elected democratically. People very much wanted Hitler to take power. And he did.
2) If who had guns who could have protected themselves against whom? This statement is too general to make for any proper argument.
3) Now you're just using random facts ("America never got invaded") to back up your claim that that is because of loose gun policies? Please present me with a coherent, logically valid argument or stop trolling, thank you. :)

Follow

@thilosophus

Stop acting like a child in the midst of a trantrum. Adults have discussions, if your going to call a persons opinions and explanations "comic releif" and "trolling" simply for disagreeing with you you are going to look like a petulant child and invalidate any change you have of someone taking you seriously.

1) You seem to lack a basic understanding of history here. No he was not fairly and democraticly elected. He got elected through a two step process. First he created a false flag operation called the Reichstag Fire amd ,amaged to blame this on communists and used this to pass the Reich Stag Fire Decree, a piece of legislation which allowed him to arrest anyone he deemed a communist. He then used this to eliminate all of his political oppnents to ensure there were no popular parties actually left one could even vote for.

For the record when he went around arresting people, he used guns, which meant no one was able to fight back even when they knew what he was doing.

So in a sense he came into power partly because he had guns with which to arrest his opposition

2) The guns would have protected against the Nazis, obviously. If you are going to be absurd enough to try to claim a group of people without guns has the same chance of success as one with guns when fighting against another group with guns, well I dont know what to tell you. I cant teach you obvious common sense.

3) As for how the right to bear arms helps prevent against invasion, again this should be obvious. Its the same reason why the vast majority of a military force is armed Infantry with exactly the same guns.. because it works!

Obviously trying to invade a country with tanks, plans, and missiles plus infantry and 100 million armed civilians is going to many orders of magnitude harder than invading one with 100 million less armed citizens. Infantry is effective and when you arm the masses you have a much **much** larger force to go against.

Now lets see if **you** can play with the big boys, act like an adult, and come up with a half-respectable response that doesnt look like trolling or you having a temper tantrum.. take your time.

@kmic

@freemo Thank you! Now you're actually presenting me with arguments that I can disagree with instead of generalist assumptions. It took you a few toots.

1) Thank you for explaining my history to me and attacking me personally. I really needed that and it really helped the civility of the discussion. Despite his methods, Hitler got into power by popular support, and you cannot deny that unless you suddenly had proof that all election ballots were rigged.

@thilosophus Well glad I'm providing you with actual points, obvious ones I'll be it you should have known already, but I guess everyone needs to learn something new...

Sadly I cant say the same for you. You have yet to defend your own points with any actual facts or logic. But thats ok, i guess your trolling and insults are just as good huh?

@freemo Jesus, just let me write my points one by one, I only have 500 characters per toot. Calm down. Thank you.

@thilosophus to your "counter-point".. no he didnt.. when you are not the most popular person ont he ballot and you simply use guns and illegal means to eliminate all the people on the ballot more popular than you, that does **not** equate to getting in on popularity.

People were scared and quickly arrested if they didnt support him, labeled as a "communist".. To claim he just won because he was popular when he was arresting anyone who disagreed with him is a level of naivity that tells me its time to exit the conversation entirely.

You're at the point where you didnt just engage in initiating insults and attacks but also now pulling things out of your ass anyone with some common sense should know better.

So its really not in my best interest to waste my time engaging further unless you manage to break free of yoru emotional tantrum that seems to be guiding your responses.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.