There's lots of reasons for the renaissance in "newsletters" (what we used to call moderated mailing lists), but top of the list was the realization by all kinds of companies, organizations and individuals that trusting Google or Facebook was a very bad bet.

Google delivered the first warning shot when it started shuttering its social networking tools based on inscrutable business logic.

1/

But FB showed us the worst endgame when it deployed algorithms that located vibrant "fan pages" and dialed down their ability to reach subscribers who'd asked to see updates; then approached those neutered page owners with offers to "boost their reach" for pay.

Allowing a Big Tech company to hold your customers hostage was obviously a losing bet. But thankfully, there's one major, federated platform left online, the original one: email.

2/

By switching to email to communicate, businesses, orgs and individuals could insulate themselves from the arbitrary decisions of Big Tech execs whose indifference or greed had destroyed so many successful, hard-built lists.

And what's more, a raft of companies - Mailchimp and its competitors - sprang up to help these companies run their lists. But these companies leave a lot to be desired, starting with their widespread deployment of "read receipts" and other privacy-invading tricks.

3/

And then there's their role in enabling a bunch of toxic behavior (I've unsubscribed from hundreds of Mailchimp lists, but I never signed up for any of them, and the company won't tell me which other lists I'm on and let me unsubscribe from them, too).

But running a moderated mailing-list isn't rocket science. If you operate your own mail-server, you can set up a free/open list-management tool like Mailman in minutes.

4/

Email is federated, right? So you don't need to pay Big Tech or a spying, spammy mailing list company.

Well...

Email is much more federated in practice than it is in reality.

Most of us get our email from one of a few giant email providers - Google, Apple, or our ISPs, like AT&T and its myriad subsidiaries - as well as secret rules for selecting blocking or passing email means that sending mail from your own mailserver is harder than it's ever been.

5/

@pluralistic I agree with where your going here, but just a nit-pick on language.

You seem to be confusing the word "federated" with "decentralized"... Large centralized email servers that hold a monopoly are just as federated as lots of small ones, they are however not decentralized.

@freemo No, I'm using the term advisedly; federation implies mutual agreements about exchanging messages ("speak this protocol and you can interoperate"); centralization has broken that social contract for most of the parties.

Follow

@pluralistic In what way does centralization break the promise that the propocol can interoperate.

A google mail server runs the same protocol as a one person server and is just as capable of interoperation with other servers.. It has the same feature of federation as any other server.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.