@hansw @Gargron @rgx @joaopinheiro @freemo I think of fedi as email more cause federation so edit in place seems unreasonable and open to malicious intent.
unreasonable in what sense, unreasonable to whom exactly.
As for malicious intent, that is easily mitigated in my eyes by simply preserving the edit history and showing which revision a specific person comments on.
This would, in my eyes, both address any legitimate concerns you have and still provide the feature for those who want it.
In the way I described editing there is no access given to a remote instance of any kind. The edit would take place locally on your own instance and published as an amendment to your earlier post. The remote instance would not need to provide any access to accomplisht hat.
Now that you've clarified I suspect the issue may not be that we disagree at all but rather that you misunderstand my proposal, or at least, how such a feature would be implemented (if I were to implement it anyway).
@freemo @Gargron @rgx @joaopinheiro @hansw well we already have seen how your constant edits litter threads on instances that dont federated deletes, I also suspect those same instances wouldnt be too into federating small amendments.
Apples and oranges. The current system of delete and edit **is** broken (and you just cited one example of why).
My proposed technical solution however would be of an entirely different nature and wouldn't have those pitfalls and would be perfectly compatible with all current instances.
You cant just cite the current problem and use that as an example as to why you think a solution to that problem wouldnt work, expecially before even asking how the solution fixes the problem, which you did not ask.
My solution would essentially be nothing more than replies to a persons original post with a diff or similar format as its content. Since it would no longer be a delete and redraft but just formated as a reply existing instances would have no issue rendering it.
However compatible instances that wish to render it more cleanly can do so as an edit history.
@freemo @Gargron @rgx @joaopinheiro @hansw I guess. Just seems like too much. Feel like the focus should just be pushing messages. But it’s already gone kitchen sink so not like it matters. I mean. You do you and use the features you want.
Just seems like too much. Feel like the focus should just be pushing messages.
Different people, different cultures, languages and aspirations. Real life is like that. And that makes it richer.
The same applies here too. I can perfectly ignore the one liner cryptic SMS style "posts". As people can chose to ignore my long form ones.
Allowing people to express themselves is a goal.
Artificial limits coming from a pre-historic era (Tweets being 144 chars, because --> sent over SMS) doesn't make sense.
To force a style and size of post simply for UI rendering style? There are better ways.
People are quite competent programmers and administrators.
Part of the richness that attracts me to the Fediverse is that there are options, alternatives, find your favourite niches. And still communicate as you see fit.
@rgx @Gargron @joaopinheiro @freemo @hansw ya I basically what I keep saying, just saying i disagree. It is nice to be able to host your own instance and all that’s why i host mine. But i wouldnt lie and say I’m competent or talented. Rather just take it.
@freemo @Gargron @rgx @joaopinheiro @hansw the remote instance