As for the larger issue about indexing in a fedeerated environment, I agree its a tricky one.
Consider this, if this were a manual blog you might make some post about something or another and label it as no-index.. sure that seems great.
But me as a blogger who does have an indexed site might wish to quote you in my reply, perhaps I disagree with you. so now part of your content, and a link to it will be on my indexes site. Your content got indexed by proxy.
Whose fault is this, the search engine? or the blog software, or the blogger? Whats the solution, do we have one?