Holy crap, google is apparently taking down all/most fediverse apps from google play on the grounds that that some servers in the fediverse engage in hate speech. At least three apps I know of anyway and I'd imagine the others will follow soon under the exact same reasoning.} Seems to be the case with Husky, Fedilab, and "subway" tooter.

this is a scary precedent if google play is going to ban any apps that can in any way be used to access content with hate speech. So what about a forum client, do they take that down just because there is a forum somewhere on the internet posting hate speech?

This is particularly worrisome because for most people Google Play is the only way they understand to install apps at all.

Picture attached of one of the notices received by fedilab.

toot.fedilab.app/@fedilab/1047

mastodon.social/@Gargron/10476

@fedilab @tateisu

@freemo

Anyone who puts qualifiers on free speech doesn't understand it, and doesn't support it.

No one supports free speech. Free speech is always selective. Communists enjoy free speech while nazis do not.
Free speech is an unrealistic, autistic, unattainable fantasy. Power structures are unavoidable and will capitulate to the inevitable demands by the powerful to silence those without power. This is immutable human nature and cannot be altered. Free speech has never existed and will never exist, except for those brief twinklings where it is inaugerated from above by the powerful, until they die and power accedes to the next generation.

@AtlasFreeman @freemo

@CreamSeparatist

Well depends on how you define or apply free speech.. some people use it to mean you can say anything at anytime with no consequences.. strictly the definition of it is that you are free to voice any opinions specifically, but not neccesarly the right to say anything you want (which could exclude a lot of hate speech and still meet the definition).

It also means very different things if we talk about it as a legal principle as opposed to a personal ethical principle.

@AtlasFreeman

And there you go. You believe in the existence of "hate speech" which amounts to saying that if you hurt someone's feelings with mean words your right to free speech no longer exists.
QED no one actually supports free speech. A total load of pigshine.

@freemo @AtlasFreeman
Follow

@CreamSeparatist

I said nothing about what I believe in. I am only saying that is one such interpretation.

I think its pretty obvious hateful speech exists. Whether it is protected by free speech or not depends entierly on the definition of free speech employed is all. The definition I use when i am in a position to protect free speech is another matter entierly.

@AtlasFreeman

Hurt feelings do not trump free speech.
Or rather, they do trump it, because free speech is a myth and democracy should be annihilated as a horrendous scam. No one who thinks hurt feelings can be a valid argument against speech should be considered even 1/10th my civic value, let alone my equal. Democracy and the lie of liberty must be abolished and replaced.

@freemo @AtlasFreeman

@CreamSeparatist

I tend to agree, but again depends on what is defined as free speech. If the line is drawn at hurt feelings, for example, then you may find it acceptable to suppress speech which causes physical or financial harm, such as yelling "Fire!" in a crowded theater, or libel/slander.

@AtlasFreeman

Free speech can have no limitations. There is no gray area. There either is free speech for everyone or there is free speech for no one.

No line can be drawn at hurt feelings or shouting fire in a crowded theatre; an argument which was, in fact, being used in a judgment passed down against political activists distributing fliers urging those who were drafted to resist their involuntary enslavement.

Just more proof of the lie of liberty and the bankrupt nature of these cynical appeals to inexistent freedoms.

@freemo @AtlasFreeman
image.png

@CreamSeparatist

so if im under oath in a court case I can lie and say I saw you murder the guy and I am completely protected because of free speech even if it can be shown I intentionally lied?

Sorry but in the case where free speech has no line of any kind in even the most extreme examples we have a situation where the harm quickly outweighs the benefit of free speech.

@AtlasFreeman

It clearly can't. Free speech either authorizes the violations of liberty which have been endemic from its outset, or it has been powerless to protect those who were victimized for their legitimate political speech.

The internal contradictions of your nonsensical liberal beliefs in inexistent freedoms is a problem for you to wrestle with, not me. I am for the abolishment of all liberal institutions such as free speech and democracy, so I don't have to wrestle with it.

You can't give Julian Assange the last 10 years of his life back with handwringing about "where we should draw the line" of free speech.

Fuck liberalism, libertarianism, and so on. Hashtag not my society.

@freemo @AtlasFreeman
Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.