@icedquinn It makes no sense to me, shorting makes stock prices go down not up normally. so I have to wonder why the reverse is happening here.
@icedquinn yea im aware of the story a bit (didnt really look into it too much).. but what you just describe would be them long-ing the stocks (buying) not shorting.
It seems contrary to how brokers are reacting then.. brokers are allowing the long buys on the stocks right now but have only blocked shorting the stocks. If it is as you say the brokers and bank shorting and getting mad their getting screwed then I would have expected the brokers not to block shorts and still permit longs (which is what is hurting the banks/brokers).
I need more info to judge, but freezing in the face of high volatility isnt a crime its standard.. but it seems there is more to it i need to know before i excuse it.
well yea to a point, but thats just robin hood then, fuck them, never liked them anyway.
Ahh then yea i can see why that could be a problem.. though as I said seems on my end of the three borkers I used they only froze short selling and none of them froze anything else (you could still exist shorts, buy long, and sell long)... So really not sure what any of that would accomplish, those who went short would make a killing by just waiting.
yea they have mostly either restricted short sells, or put the maintenance margin at 100%, but of the three brokers I use none of them had a complete freeze.
@icedquinn @georgia @freemo I've been buying NOK shares all day just to test this and it's not the case on TD Ameritrade at least.
I'm not entierly convinced who is corrupt here yet, still catching up.. sounds like the accusation is both sides are doing their own version of a pump-and-dump scheme which would be illegal on both sides if true.
Generally when stock prices go above a certain volatility it is common for them to be frozen as well, so regardless of if everyone is acting legally or not, the effect of both/eitehr sidemeans a very high volatility and freezing short sales (and sometimes even long buys) is very common and standard when that happens.
@icedquinn ahh ok, that makes sense then
I envy the people short selling honestly. If shorts werent frozen i would be short selling like mad.. they are going to make a FORTUNE and all from the pockets of whoever thingks buying overpriced stocks is going to do something... the longer they keep it up the more the cashout on the short at the end will be.
In fact I wouldnt be suprisised if the hedge funds are playing the redditors like fools and were the ones who started the trend and got everyone buying shit up in the first place just so they could make a fortune off their shorts.
the truth is the best way to be screwed on the stock market is to be predictable en masse. Having everyone agree to artificially inflate the price by buying like crazy has predictable market results and that means anyone can bet against them and make a fortune at their expense long-run.
In fact the only reason brokers are stopping short-sales at all is because if they let other people sell short then thre is less stock for **them** to sell short. I have no doubt that while all of us are blocked from short sales every broker and hedge fun out there is probably going short on every single stock they can get, most of which are probably shorting the very stocks these people are buying to inflate prices.
Its basically just hundreds of thousands of people just handign piles of money to brokers at this point out of "spite" and thinking they won something.
@freemo @icedquinn The problem is that they have to buy the stocks to exit their position (since the idea behind shorting is that they sold stocks they don't have, that would normally increase the supply and decrease the price.)
Because they shorted more shares then actually exist they have to buy them back up at crazy high prices or hold their position open.
Yea but waiting it out doesnt sound like a big issue, they can just wait it out and make even more of a fortune..
If everyone is buying to inflate the price so they cant exit their short position the logical thing to do is **not** to exit their short position but rather buy **more** short positions.. eventually people will run out of interest, time, or money and stop buying and the artificial inflation will drop back down.. Everyone who bought would have lost a ton, and everyone who held their shorts (and especially those who entered into even more shorts) would have made an absolute fortune..
So no need to artificially block teh markets at all, the "tactic" used by others to buy stocks would only help(significantly so) those who were shorting in the long run.
@freemo @icedquinn It works like a high interest rate loan though.
So yes in theory you could hold a short position forever but in practice there's the time value of money and you want to close it quickly. This is why shorting usually requires pretty precise timing and most people don't recommend taking a bearish position that way.
@icedquinn @freemo OMG lol that's great.
FR though I'm not long GME. I don't think that's a responsible position. I'm playing with the derivatives though.
doubtful they would have to buy more and more over time to keep the price high.. I doubt people could maintain that for weeks on end, and the longer they maintain it the more money the people shorting will make when it stops... so it really makes no sense as a tactic your basically just handing them your money in the long run
@icedquinn which one specifically, cant find any in the news.
Ok so they didnt go bankrupt at all then (I just checked no news they went bankrupt)
Not at all.. I usually have 100K + in shorts all the time. There is interest on it, but its actually very low, not super high like you suggest at all. a few percentage points in a whole year at most.
@freemo @icedquinn Hmm, maybe you're right. I don't short sell ever because it freaks me out so you probably know better than me.
Short selling is the best way to make sure you minimize drawdown on any strategy. Its important not to avoid it.
If you are scared of shortselling then buy up leveraged short ETFs, its technically a long buy for you but effectively the same as a short, the shorting is just handled by the security and not by you.
which caused the value to rocket, and when the margins were called in a hedge fun was KO'd.