Show newer

@mk

The goal is **not** to get all instances to join.

The goal is to ensure that instances that dont give other instances a voice wont have a voice of their own. It is also to encourage those that do give other instances a voice will stand together in a united front when other instances try to defame them.

@alex

@nerthos

So are you more worried about how to respond to pre-crime of what they may one day maybe possibly do.. or are you asking me how to address something they are currently actively doing? The response to each is different.

If your concern is about how they might behave int he future, then there is time, and your goal is to ensure you defuse that future as much as possible. If you are agressive, ugly, and hostile then all your doing is giving strength to their movement. You are giving them a valid face of the enemy. You are ensuring the very future you wish to prevent (just as they are ensuring the same future with their own actions). So with that intention it is a very flawed tactic.

@RevilerD @mk

@mk

In my proposal there would be no political conditions on it whatsoever. Just dont ban people, and dont circumvent bans. Otherwise both liberal and conservative instances will both be welcomed. An instance cant be rejected for personal reasons.

@alex

@nerthos

Depends on which way they are "out for your life", the response would be very situational.

@RevilerD @mk

@nerthos

If you respond to savagery with savagery the end result is just more savagery, not less.

@RevilerD @mk

@RevilerD

Thats sad they drove you to that. My advice would be to be the bigger man and not succumb to it.

@mk

@freemo We've actually been thinking of a similar idea! Check out @alex's post from a couple days ago:

spinster.xyz/@alex/posts/10269

I feel like there's a LOT of implementation/drama questions but... overall I think this is something worth pursuing. I imagine there even being multiple such cooperatives in time, perhaps with overlapping membership, and each cooperative could develop some form of shared resources/tech support network which would make joining that one in particular attractive.

@mk

I am a software coder. Presuming this idea is something that gains support and momentum I'd even be willing to modify the mastodon source code to ensure it can be executed effectively through technical means.

@alex

I posted this as a main post here, going to repeat it here because it is relevant:

qoto.org/@freemo/1027206200298

I had an idea and a proposal for an anti-censorship cooperative among the free speech instances. It is just an idea, not sure if i support it yet. but would be curious to hear any feedback.. the idea goes something like this.

Any instance can get into the cooperative so long as they pledge to a few rules

1) personal suspensions and silencing is permitted.

2) Ban circumvention will not be allowed and enforced. If a person from one instance blocks someone and makes it clear they do not wish to be contacted, and a user creates another account to circumvent this personal block then that user will be banned.

3) no instance is allowed to suspend any other instance within the cooperative.

4) any server that suspends/blocks any instance inside the cooperative must be blocked/suspended by all other members of the cooperative in response.

5) any instance not following these rules will be kicked out of the cooperative.

The purpose here would be to ensure that any instance which has a policy of frivolously blocking other instances without due process or cause will be punished by loosing their voice throughout the larger federated community.

Show thread

I had an idea and a proposal for an anti-censorship cooperative among the free speech instances. It is just an idea, not sure if i support it yet. but would be curious to hear any feedback.. the idea goes something like this.

Any instance can get into the cooperative so long as they pledge to a few rules

1) personal suspensions and silencing is permitted.

2) Ban circumvention will not be allowed and enforced. If a person from one instance blocks someone and makes it clear they do not wish to be contacted, and a user creates another account to circumvent this personal block then that user will be banned.

3) no instance is allowed to suspend any other instance within the cooperative.

4) any server that suspends/blocks any instance inside the cooperative must be blocked/suspended by all other members of the cooperative in response.

5) any instance not following these rules will be kicked out of the cooperative.

The purpose here would be to ensure that any instance which has a policy of frivilously blocking other instances without due process or cause will be punished by loosing their voice throughout the larger federated community.

multiple instance block recommendations 

@BillShortening

Agreed it is a problem which ideally should be fixed. But due to the nature of federation it is impossible. Generally who you block or dont block is kept secret to prevent people who block others from facing repercussions. As such this information is likely intentionally obscured and not something you will find gets a fix anytime soon.

@mirzaba@cybre.space @p

@homer77

QOTO Admin here. We take a VERY strict stance against NAzi's or hate speech. If you find any on our server please just report them, as our rules explicitly state hate speech will get anyone ban here.

By the way we dont appear to have any reports from you regarding nazis. So seems a leap to call for a ban on our instance when you havent even given our admins a chance to act on any issues you perceive.

@reinhard_codes@chaos.social

@Johnny_of_the_swamp

Who the person calling for the ban? Yea the issue is that it is common behavior these days in the fediverse.

@Alonealastalovedalongthe

Shortly after posting this I had this pop up in my feed on an unrelated thread. Fitting!

Show thread

@Alonealastalovedalongthe Here is an example of such extremism from blue instances (since you said you were unaware of it happening). In this case a blue instance is calling for a ban on any instance which has anyone from that instance even following someone from another instance. Nothing to do with opinions or even politics. Just being able to hear what someone else says is enough to warrant a ban these days.

So apparently if some user from 2 years ago signed up and followed someone from that domain, then stopped using that account, it means our entire domain should be blocked...

It is shocking to me that with this pattern being as pervasive as it is that you dont see it.

cybre.space/@mirzaba/102719771

@realcaseyrollins Cool we used to have one up but no one used it. I'll bring it back up for you sometime this week. Keep in mind it is locked down so you can only use it on qoto accounts and cant use it for other instances.

@Alonealastalovedalongthe As for making a case, I agree, it might be useful. But I have limited time. I am a Research scientist with more than enough papers in my quota already.

Moreover I would suspect it will fall on deaf ears. The blue instances guilty of the behavior arent likely to be receptive to such evidence. In fact they would likely twist it into evidence of me being right leaning (which i am not) and even go so far as to use it against me as is their MO.

@Alonealastalovedalongthe I never said it was true of the left overall. Only of blue instances in the fediverse. I'd also go so far as to say its true of most of te left from america (but america is known for its extremism).

I live in the Netherlands, I'm dutch, the left here do NOT appear to be the sort of extremists we see here from blue instances in the fediverse.

I'd discourage you from generalizing what I say to the left outside of the areas I specifically addressed. I know **many** left leaning people who are very rational. They just tend to avoid blue instances on the fediverse is all.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.