Show newer

@alexa@fedi.absturztau.be The issue is as it stands right now there is incentive to ban every instance you come along that someone else bans.. instances are banning other instances simple for not banning instances. This has led to pressure to either ban instances or get yourself ejected from the fediverse.

We need a system of cooperation that applies the same pressures in reverse. A system that ensures that if you do not ban people you will have a voice but if you do ban instances that dont violate the rules, then you would suffer by a global ban and thus be discouraged from such behavior.

@alexa@fedi.absturztau.be Gab does not enforce ban evasion policy. As such Gab would be eligible to join the federation in the first place. If Gab agreed to follow the rules of the federation then no one int he federation would be allowed to block gab at an instance level. But since gab is unlikely to ever take a stance against ban evasion they are unlikely to ever be allowed into such a federation.

@inditoot I was thinking of using technology rather than humans to do that. A plugin which each site int eh federation runs that ensures the rules i mentioned are enforced and if they arent all members of the federation would know it.

@alexa@fedi.absturztau.be

Agreed, violence is not an exclusive feature of either side.

@jack @nerthos

@nerthos

We are actually arguing on a bit of a tangent. I originally thought youw ere proposing to respond with violence. Which is what we are discussing now. I do recognize that was a misunderstanding and you were proposing something else instead. But we are already lost on this tangent :)

@jack

@jack

Quite simply because virtually all of the popularity of the left hings on the narrative that the right incites violence and hate. This in its current form has generated a huge amount of support for the left. Some people, those int he middle, dismiss it because they personally might feel they havent seen such violence and it isnt justified.

If your response is to actually be violent, now youve turned an accusation with little reality to it into truth. Not only will the embolden the current supporters but will also prove their message to be true. Anyone ont he fence about the issue will now be polarized to the left in response to your violence and ensured your own loss.

@nerthos

@violet

A few do, this is almost entierly, however, due to our policy to not block other instances. As you know there is a growing group of instances that block any instance which doesnt themselves block a known free speech instance. This sometimes gets us blocked.

Regardless I'd challenge you to find any racism or hate speech anywhere on our timeline. If you do and report it it will certainly quickly get any such user a ban.

@alayna @Breakfast

@jack

No what I claimed is if you take specifically the tactic he suggested (you inciting violence through the use of violence) you will loose.

My argument implies that if you yourself are peaceful and the other side largely more violent than the peaceful side will win presuming the numbers are mostly equal.

So hidden in my argument is the exact opposite of what you saw.

@nerthos

@alayna

We take a VERY serious approach to racism and hate speech. We have and do actively block anyone who has expressed hate speech.

Our rules also explicitly state this.

Do you have any examples of something one of our users have posted that you feel should have been moderated? If so please just make a report we can and will take any such reports seriously.

@Breakfast

@alexa@fedi.absturztau.be

We are also moderated and will and do ban anyone who expresses hate speech or a nazi sympathizer. Our rules clearly define racism and hate speech as a ban worthy offense.

@Breakfast @alayna

@nerthos Nah, they just pretend its racially defined. I am partly NAtive American and that has in no way made me immune from their attacks.

@nerthos Im not sure that would work either. People are, mostly, sheep. they support whatever side they perceive to be more powerful. By pretending to be weaker than you are you would only result in more people favoring the other side as well.

I dont think manipulative tactics really work too well here.

@nerthos They will, if you behave in a way intending to incite violence out them, like you claim, you will bolster their numbers and support and ultimately ensure they will, in fact win.

Since you were encouraging violence I'd argue they **should** win against any who encourage violence by the very nature of violence.

@Gargron Yea I certainly wouldnt want you to implement a feature you didnt personally want. I was thinking more along the lines of if its a low priority and there is a donator perhaps it might move to a top priority. Right now I'd just like to relay an answer.

Obviously any features you dont want to do I am happy to add myself to our own fork (though I'd still welcome your feedback). But anything you are willing to add id rather you get the money and do it if your interested.

@nerthos The problem is by taking this tactic and opinion the only result is ensuring your own extermination, that isnt victory.

Deep Learning for Estimating Synaptic Health of Primary Neuronal Cell Culture. (arXiv:1908.11399v1 [eess.IV]) arxiv.org/abs/1908.11399

@nerthos can't imagine that helping matters honestly. violence is never the answer.

@nerthos

The end result of such a policy is to quickly accelerate their growth and power, not diminish it. Particularly since its a metaphor for words and not a literal proposal of violence.

@RevilerD @mk

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.