@zeccano Let me know if you need help reasoning it later, as long as your open to it being true
@zeccano You are the one claiming light has no momentum contrary to everything else in the universe, so the obligaligation is on you to show it doesnt.
@zeccano So even if the shape of the equations resembled the blot of gravity (it actually doesnt and has a different shape) that wouldnt explain why you'd get exactly 420 ns as an answer out of the equation for a certain input rather than some other number...
Thats not how equations work. I think your own lack of math knowledge is really blinding you to what would be a simple problem to understand otherwise.
I can teach you if you want.
A regulation demanding drug companies must include the chemical formulae with the drugs they sell is absolutely a regulation which creates safety.
@zeccano you measure the sme beam of light from two perspectives one moving faster than the other, thats what is meant.
@zeccano No i said pretty much the exact opposite of that. We know how a light beam shoots out of a moving laser (and its not the nonsense you suggested in your video).. your arguing absurdities at this point.
I think you've just invested SO much time on this lie and your so old that you cant change your mind now, no matter how much proof there is your wrong.. I dunno, looked like you might be getting it for a bit there.
I guess i need to exit the conversation now.
If you want to try to learn some of the basic math let me know we should try the basic thought experiments, the math, and even some experiments yourself sometime, its really easy stuff you can understand if you try i think.
@zeccano That makes no sense, why would one an equation simple for being non-linear be expected to approcimate exactly the time difference expected.
The equations tell a specific number of seconds that is expected to be off by.
@sda Was this meant for me?
@zeccano What?
It was measured from two different frames of reference (relative speed) thats all you have to do to prove the paradox.
Man you really dont even understand the basics of what I'm saying it looks like.
Why are you still acting like it is in doubt when you couldnt explain away the gravity clocks?
At this point you have enough information to know the theory is experimentally proven (unless you have can come up with an explanation for the experiment which you cant).. So if you still are going to act like it isnt proven then I'm pretty much doneith you because you arent trying to really learn or change your assumptions at all.
I dont want to be rude but you said your 61 and its too late to learn math, apparently its too late for you to change your mind on relativity too.. But I want to just leave you with this, do your eally want to be that 61 year old that is too old to learn? Because personally I beleive you arent too old, but for that to be true it will take a change in the way you think, so its up to you.
@zeccano it doesnt matter how recent the claim is, thats just nonsense and makes no sense. It is a claim that is experimentally proven thats all that matters.
In every place where it is predicted we would need special relativity equations, we do, and when we apply them it gives the correct answer. There are countless examples of that.
You can say its wrong all you want but you cant get around the fact that it works, and is needed to make a ton of technology work at all, something that is tested every day in practical ways around the world and proven.
You can say its all wrong all you want but considering it is experimentally proven in countless ways you cant really gripe.
Still waiting on your explanation for the gravity clocks, you havent had one you notice that is acceptable.
@zeccano bullshit, again i have measured the speed of light in my own lab (and it isnt hard...
Or are you going to assume it is again just "coincidence" that the results prove that the speed of light is a constant?
Man you are really just pulling stuff out of your ass now.
You are missing the point, A soft drink, or other food is not something of a nature you would want to patent, a drug is, these are apples and oranges.
A drug asa a matter of safety must give away its chemical formula whether it is patented or not, so they dont have the option of secrecy as coca-cola might (which never patented the formula). So when we talk medication patents are really the only way they have to protect Intellectual Property in the first place.
I'm familiar with the pattern, and for some things it actually works. It stems from the fact that in order to patent something you must make the details on how to make it public knowledge. That means people have a time to experiment with it and once the patent lapses release their own formulation using your idea as a starting point.
For this reason patents arent always a good choice.
However sometimes they are, it really depends on the details of what you are patenting. When it comes to medication parents are your only real option because you have to make the chemical formula anyway because, well, its a drug, as a matter of safety the molecular formular need to be shared with the community to verify its safety. Could you imagine if drug companies started to have the right not to tell you the chemical formula of the drugs you took, I shudder at the thought.
@zeccano The idea that a quanta of light has no mass is incorrect. There are two types of mass every object has one is called rest mass, the other is called inertial mass or relativistic mass. Usually if we talk about mass it is the relativistic mass.
The mass of light is therefore relative to its frequency, higher frequency light has more energy and since energy is equivelant to mass, has more mass.
moreover, again, experiments demonstrate all this. So while I can understand that you **think** it is wrong, and you **think** you can disprove it, becaiuse all experiments prove it to be true we know you are wrong. So instead of wasting time on an idea proven to be wrong its far better to try to understand how it must be true.
@zeccano direct being the keyword, there are many indirect ones. and those indirect ways further confirm the equations.
Again if you want to say SR is wrong you need to replace it with something that explains thr behavior of light, what is that something then?
@zeccano Im not saying something is wrong with the teachers in the sense that their information was wrong.
What I am saying is those teachers didnt explain things in a way that was clear to you. They clearly werent teaching you in a way that was uiseful, but this may be because you yourself didnt have the ability to ask them questions to understand
@zeccano No, that was a problem that was solved by GR, but not the fundementally observable principle that gave rise to the need or idea.
Ill give you the answer, but pay attention closely to my words because a lot of people dont really get what is being said here and i think it may be where you went wrong.
The fundemental paradox that gave rise to relativity was this simple fact: the speed of light is a constant
That means a bit more than you probably realize it means..
If i shoot a laser down a road and me, as someone holding the laser and standing still measure it, the speed of the light will be about 300 million kilometers per second, or C.
However that isnt the weird part.
The weird part is if someone else is running along the road next to the laser beam at half the speed of light, C, if they measure that same light beam one would expect him to measure the speed of light as half of C (that would be the case if we were talking about a bullet at least right?)... but amazing that isnt what we see, instead the measured speed would also be C!.
It is this apparent paradox that needed to be solved, and solving that paradox is exactly what special relativity does.
If you dont think special relativity is real, then how would you solve this paradox otherwise?
@zeccano So watched your video, the fundemental problem in the video is you assume that if the laser is stationary when it is fired, and then accelates and start moving after that this would be the same as firing a laser while under constant motion.. it wouldnt. You cant just ignore the velocity when it is fires and then account for it once the photon is in motion, it doesnt work that way.
To understand why replace the mirror with two children sitting across an aisle on a bus and photon with a ball. If the bus is going really fast down a high way and one kid throws a ball to the other, how will the ball move? will it miss the other kid completely because of the velocity of the bus or will it hit its target? Obviously it would hit its target, as long as the bus isnt accelerating.
A photon is no different in this regard and thus why your video is debunked.
@zeccano Maybe you had bad teachers, maybe you misunderstood those lectures. But the thing is, they are **not** theory first.
They take real observable things we didnt understand, explain them using simple thought experiments, apply the math based on those thought experiments, and find it to be correct.
Since we have tested it and know it to be correct, then if you dont understand it, then it is a failure somewhere in that process of understanding. At least until you can think of a way to do an exoeriment to contradict it.
I will watch the video, but I think your just missing some understanding.
Let me start with a simple question: What is the physical observation about the universe we saw, that was unexplained at the time, that einstein was able to explain with his theory? (if you dont know I will explain, but i think this may be the part you are missing).
Keep in mind this can be tricky even for people who are math students.
@zeccano If your really serious about learning this stuff here is what I recommend: Follow through the einstein thought experiments, the same one he used to derive his experiments.
I know since you dont know math this may seem overwhelming, but youd be surprised. For special relativity the math to understand it is actually **really** simple math beleive it or not. The thought experiment is also pretty simple to understand.
I think I see why this all may seem unreliable to you, you think it all came from just math, it didnt, it came from real world observable things, the math came later from simple thought experiments.
How would you feel about taking a go at understanding this for real, from the ground up? I promise it isnt too hard.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE