Show newer

@cowanon Yea well thats how the left is with their politics. They twist words around to whatever is catchiest, they go for the "gotcha" bs rather than dealing with the full intricacy of the issues

@DissidentKitty I have an internet connected computer so I'm entitled to an opinion.

Let's begin with a definition of theft, I will then consider another one.

Theft is when you private someone from a resource that they obtained through voluntary exchange or through working on (possibly raw, natural) resources.

From this definition piracy is not theft. You are simply copying, not denying the artist from the original one. The artist still has the drawing on a paper they did.

You may argue that the artist will not gain what they would have gained if they had monopoly over the copying rights. That's very possibly true, but it will only be theft if they obtained said monopoly from a voluntary exchange with everyone else.

Of course this argument doesn't consider governments, under which the definition of theft can be broadened to include other things that not only voluntary exchange and working on resources.

So lets do that.

Theft is when you private someone from a resource that they obtained through voluntary exchange, through working on (possibly raw, natural) resources or through rights given to them by a government.

Under this definition, if there is a law that gives the artist copying monopoly, and you break said monopoly, you are committing theft.
(Here I'm not making judgements of whether something is good or bad, just pointing what follows from the definition of theft.)

Fortunately most of us here (I hope) still live in a democracy and not in the Kingdom of Zuckerberg, so we are entitled to discussing whether we think the government should institute such copying monopolies.

Originally, copy rights were created in England, after the invention of the Gutenberg press because the government thought that if everyone could say whatever they wanted, their days of governing would be over. They were very much correct, see the French revolution that brought the raise of individualistic and democratic ideals.

Modern copy right laws exist for a different reason. The argument behind it is that if people have the monopoly of copy of their creation for say, 10 years, then they are much more likely to create, which benefits society.

The crucial part is "which benefits society", meaning that we get to decide if there is such benefit and whether we want it. Note that the vote of artists counts very little here because they are a small part of the population, monopoly of copy of art is usually not considered a basic right and they would obviously vote for "unlimited monopoly forever". Therefore, in the end, most of the weight goes to whether the laws benefit society as a whole.

To decide if we do want copy right laws we need to consider two things:
1 - What we get;
2 - What we pay.

If we only get Vox Media articles and BuzzFeed quizez then it's obviously not worth it.
If we have to pay with the souls of kittens then it's also not worth it.

This brings us to the final and most productive part of this very high IQ post, considerations on what we get and how much we pay.

What we get:

What everyone will point out right away is that in modern times we are getting A LOT of Vox Media articles and A LOT of BuzzFeed Quizes. In absolute numbers we are getting much more sensationalist journalism than ever before.

But I would also like to point out that in modern times we are getting a lot of quality niche content that would be virtually impossible before and a lack of copy monopoly could render some of that content impossible. This niche quality content DOES NOT include most netflix series btw.

What we pay:

It's very easy to make copies of anything. You only need a computer with internet, not a massive rolling press. Therefore, in practice, the copy monopoly will be enforced through either DRM(proprietary malaware) or surveillance and lawsuits/DMCA notices.

Both of those have massive downsides. DRM is the least bad, it is more or less voluntary, a person can just not buy DRM stuff. But not without downsides, proprietary software can be used as spyware and if the copy monopoly is allowed a lot of people will end up using DRM, increasing the chances of people that don't actually use DRM to also be spied on.

I don't think I have to explain why mass surveillance is bad. But some considerations can still me made. At the moment the main piracy software is torrent, which is usually not used over anonymizing networks. There is no real hard reason for that. It could easily be used through i2p or tor(preferably with speed improvements) in which case the enforcement of the law would require state-actor level surveillance, not just tracker watching.

I do have a opinion on the matter but I'm not picking sides here. Instead I would like to provide framework for a more productive discussion, from which I hope to learn something.

Thanks for reading my blog post. I'm very smart, I know.

#productivity
I think I've figured it out! You just have to have multiple side-projects so you can procrastinate by working on another side-project.

@conatus Not a horrible idea actually, though the details of how that is implemented is important

@KatGoesWoof We have been considering hostin a write freely instance. However at the moment I need to work on the server a bit before I add more services. Right now the drive confguration is a bit off so the servers need to be restarted every few weeks (they are docker images so restart takes like a minute)

@conatus I am a huge supporter of open-source. But by choice not force. As for public domain. I'd be fine with decreasing it to something like "up to the authors death" but that has issues since the author could be a corperation that doesnt die.

@eldaking Public libraries that use tax money in order to buy the rights to books from authors and then share it for free with the public **is** hugely beneficial. It also doesnt violate intellectual property rights in any way.

@snow clips, specifically with regards to commentary is actually legal and falls under fair-use.

The only people who claim Intellectual Property isn't real or shouldn't be respected also tend to be the same people who cant support themselves off of intellectual pursuits.

Why is it always the second someone doesnt personally benefit from a right, any right, is the moment they think that right should be abolished?

Working on my own Cryptocurrency from scratch is very challenging. But it doesnt feel like math as much as I'd like. I'm missing the math...

@chuculate

Very true you do, however posting on the fediverse gives implied consent to redistribute as I stated.

I have decided to exit this conversation so please dont include me or tag me if you wish to continue the thread, thanks.

@papush@niu.moe

@papush@niu.moe

Thanks for the correction. Everyone has had the chance to say their final remarks. Now last time I will ask, do not tag me in this thread again, I will do the same. Thanks. Was nice talking.

@fristi

@fristi

You're points are nothing new. I've considered it myself many times. You assume you are right, as most people do, and that because I disagree with you that I must be stiff or unwilling to consider your point. You seem to fail to consider that I did contemplate your point and simply found it weak and invalid.

I started my career in piracy, I helped define the laws on piracy in the early days of the internet because I was the creator of one of the earliest piracy software out there with millions of users and had to defend it against a lawsuit with major corperations (like SEGA).

Trust me when I say I have spent a LOT of time considering my stance. I used to think and feel as you do, but i learned that I was wrong and change my views (further proving my mentality is far from ridgid or unwilling to consider other points).

Sometimes your just wrong, sometimes your right and people consider your views and make the wrong call. Either way you clearly feel you have some superior opinion and anyone who doesnt agree with you must be dysfunctional in their ability to consider your view. Sorry the world isnt that simple.

I've heard your rebuttal, now please do not tag me again on this topic, thank you.

@papush@niu.moe

@papush@niu.moe

Ok, I've heard your points. Nice chatting with you. Have a good day.

@fristi

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.