@realcaseyrollins Obviously as someone who believes in christianity I would not expect you to find them equal.. its a circular argument in a way as each of those categories already define for you how you should view the others, as such anyones opinion of their equality or differences is already dictated by their very adherence to the principles of each.
It would be a bit like asking "How are the democrats and republicans different"... you already know pretty much exactly the answer your going to get if you ask a democrat or republican that question, because their party already tells them what to think in that regard.
@FailForward That would, change their credit rating yes, but two things either:
1) it is not successful as a tactic in improving the rate of growth of their GDP, in which case my original formulation holds true all the same, they will ultimately default or brought closer to default should the loan cost more money than it produces
2) it is a successful tactic in improving the rate of growth of their GDP. In which case the equation still holds true but you simply adjust it to include the new rate of growth figures for the GDP to reflect this change.
Point being no matter what changes they might make it doesnt change the fact that if a loan is not more profitable than what you spend the loan on, then that decision will drive you closer to default, not farther away.
The example you give of changing of delegating some control to the EU is something you can do regardless of the loan or not, so it would be an independent variable not dependent on the effect from the loan itself with regards to defaulting, so doesnt really get around the root problem.
@realcaseyrollins They would be to someone who perceives all of those things as equally fictitious. However if someone found one more credible than the other, then no.
@cwebber I love the idea of Guix and I came really close to using it. Honestly though when I heard that none foss orijects would be strictly forbidden from inclusion from their package manager, however, I dropped the whole idea. I do recognize that 3rd parties can of course maintain their own repositories for that, but it concerns me as I doubt the tools will be there to make that easy and I highly doubt there will be well maintained repositories of that type.
I still love the idea of Guix though and maybe ill get lucky and someone will fork it who is a bit more liberal in those regards.
I also think its a good reason not to include a guix file, as it locks you into an ecosystem that is committed to certain limitations up front.
@FailForward No worries, if it was not the intention then no offense assumed. I am sorry I accused you of potentially meaning it that way. I take you at your word that it was me who was misinterpreting. Ignore any such concerns, I wont give it another thought .
It can sometimes be hard to convey tone through the internet, it happens, and the fault was mine.
@dankmaximus Oh no, what were the riots over?
> Thanks for the lecture
This seems like an antagonstic or atleast negative choice of words, am I misreading this?
> Finances (and thus debt) of individuals lives in a fixed context (from their perspective). A country of certain size and standing is, however, well capable to change, or at least significantly influence the context: e.g, by printing money by mechanisms like QE,
Agreed, though that does not change the answer, in fact I tried to point out those factors are simply incorperated into the equation.
Take for example when I said:
> as well as the virtual loss of money (or gain) through inflation that occured that reduced the nominal income
This factor points out exactly what you just stated, printing of money devalues you money, thus reducing its nominal value and thus would be considered as an expense on the GDP, which itself is measured nominally.
> changing legal and political framework around its debt
This one doesnt seem particularly relevant unless I mistunderstand what you mean. What would a countries internal laws or political framework have to do with the agreement they have with other countries regarding their debt. Whatever their agreement is, it exists outside the internal legal frameworks of each respective country.
> use its trade or military gross tonnage to effectively blackmail its creditors, etc.
This one makes some sense in general of course but not exactly what you were asking. You were asking when they default, obviously if you go and start a war over not paying your loan then you've already defaulted, the war just means that you may not be able to be strong-armed into paying it if you have the superior military might. Which is a fair thing to consider but a different question then "when do we default.
> Individuals have none of that.
No they don't but as we covered they are easily incorporated into the equation as each one is still measurable in similar terms as an individual.
> That is why I am interested in serious literature on the topic, rather than contrived technical arguments (I have myself a full bag of those). Do you perhaps have any pointers?
The points I made are not my own, nor are they "contrived technical arguments", they are mostly me just repeating what the already established studies and literature on the topic mostly agree on. I am somewhat surprised the original author, whoever they are, had such a hard time finding such studies. As someone who has worked closely as a professional on economic data and models, including along side other economists, I am merely providing the perspective of experts in the field.
Honestly your tone lately has been surprisingly confrontational and bordering on rude, though i continue to give you the benefit of the doubt that perhaps im misreading you, I do hope that is still the case.
As for actual literature, sure like I said there are TONS. Here are a dozen that I know of off hand, could easily provide a dozen more:
Manasse, Paolo, Nouriel Roubini, and Axel Schimmelpfennig. "Predicting sovereign debt crises." (2003): 1-41.
Kulatilaka, Nalin, and Alan J. Marcus. "A model of strategic default of sovereign debt." Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 11.4 (1987): 483-498.
Tomz, Michael, and Mark LJ Wright. "Empirical research on sovereign debt and default." Annu. Rev. Econ. 5.1 (2013): 247-272.
Feder, Gershon, and Richard E. Just. "A study of debt servicing capacity applying logit analysis." Journal of Development Economics 4.1 (1977): 25-38.
Eaton, Jonathan, and Mark Gersovitz. "Debt with potential repudiation: Theoretical and empirical analysis." The Review of Economic Studies 48.2 (1981): 289-309.
Chaibi, Hasna, and Zied Ftiti. "Credit risk determinants: Evidence from a cross-country study." Research in international business and finance 33 (2015): 1-16.
Balkan, Erol M. "Political instability, country risk and probability of default." Applied Economics 24.9 (1992): 999-1008.
Sachs, Jeffrey D. "Conditionality, debt relief, and the developing country debt crisis." Developing Country Debt and Economic Performance, Volume 1: The International Financial System. University of Chicago Press, 1989. 255-296.
Yue, Vivian Z. "Sovereign default and debt renegotiation." Journal of international Economics 80.2 (2010): 176-187.
Ali, Asghar, and Kevin Daly. "Macroeconomic determinants of credit risk: Recent evidence from a cross country study." International Review of Financial Analysis 19.3 (2010): 165-171.
Tomz, Michael, and Mark LJ Wright. "Do countries default in “bad times”?." Journal of the European Economic association 5.2-3 (2007): 352-360.
Reinhart, Carmen M. This time is different chartbook: country histories on debt, default, and financial crises. No. w15815. National Bureau of Economic Research, 2010.
@FailForward I would argue that this is actually a much easier thing to reason than you might realize and that aside from a few quirks the same rules as a business borrowing for growth applies, or entity.
> How much debt/GDP can Italy afford?
The first point though is that the criterion for measurement is incorrect here. The ratio of debt to GDP is not an effective or useful measure, the reasoning is simple when you consider the case of entities in general.
If you have 0 income as either a company or a country, and more expenses than income, borrowing can, and often is, the best option for you, presuming that money is used properly. Many companies start out with no income or even product, make a loan from a bank, and use that money to grow and become profitable, eventually paying off the loan and being in the positive. Obviously this in no way guarantees default.
So the real question becomes, what is the critereon for evaluating appropriate debt. The answer to that would be that the interest rate on the total outstanding loans need to always be less than the ratio between the growth rate of the GDP and the discretionary income of the country in question applied to the amount by which the discretionary income would grow as a result of the loan.
A country, like any individual has some discretionary income, that is, the money it collected from taxes after all its fundemental and unavoidable expenses are met. So for example it is their tax income minus their foreign debt burden (minimum payments on foreign debt), the payout on government bonds that were issues that expire that year, as well as the virtual loss of money (or gain) through inflation that occured that reduced the nominal income.. what is left over is their discretionary income.
Next one would look at how well a government is spending that discretionary income in order to fuel future growth. If we see that 100B DI tends to result in a 5% GDP growth over time then we can safely say the way that country spends that 100B has a 5% GDP growth rate.
So the question becomes is the additional income that is gained by the increase in GDP (factored over the entire life of the loan) **more** than the total cost of the loan.
So say the overall effect on GDP throughout the life of the loan (once the loan is paid back) is 10% and this represents a 50B in the GDP, and presuming that without the loan their discretionary income would have resulted in only a 5% GDP increase, and thus represents a 25B overall gain over the same lifetime of that loan. If the total cost of the loan after interest is more than 25B then the loan cost you more than you gained from it, therefore it has pushed you farther to default.
As long as you are making more money from your loans than the loan is costing you then no matter how big the loan is, its a good idea.
I'm not sure the fact taht things have gotten so bad that we will need CO2 capture to repair it is a justification to just keep spewing CO2.. the more we spew the more CO2 capture we will need to advert the worst case scenario and the less likely we will be able to provide those levels of capture.
So regardless of any need for CO2 capture it is still in our best interest to reduce CO2 emissions.
@ArturoGoosnargh They are, but less so than other sources. The number of trucks on the road hauling crude oil is enough to produce 10 million tons of CO2 a year in the USA alone. So clearly it is economical enough.
@ArturoGoosnargh Yea I get that, the point I am disagreeing with is that they will burn it, they wont.
What happens is they just stockpile it as they invest in trucks to haul it. Generally they quickly have more than enough trucks to be able to haul it away at a greater rate than it is produced. It almost never gets to the point where it sits around for very long.
@ArturoGoosnargh I doubt anyone would just burn off oil, they will just find ways to transport it by buying trucks (which is what the data shows they do).. if they truely were ever forced to just burn oil why dont they just stop pumping it instead?
@ArturoGoosnargh Well presumably if there were an actually effective regulation that reduced oil consumption (this isnt one of them) then it would in turn reduce the amount of natural gas burned.
Likewise it could be addressed through regulation by investing more infrastructure in natural gas pipelines (which many eco-conscious people do tend to promote for many reasons).
@realcaseyrollins The same as the difference between christianity and superstition, witchcraft and charismatic theology, presuming you are a person who does not believe in any of them.
@freemo First, let me say that this is my last response in this conversation. I see little point in continuing it, I said most of what I felt was useful, apparently it does not make sense to you and I do not care enough to change that - to me that pipeline decision is like Uzbekistan deciding to change their default timezone. I was just seeking some little sparring on Sunday evening, which I got. Thanks for that.
> Again since the axiom is still incorrect everything that follows it is likewise incorrect.
Well, now, when we together derived falsity, obviously I am banished into the void hell of inconsistency among all the other low beings (99% of humankind?) and shall never ever crawl back again to the daylight where the pure logic resides. What a lovely way to tell the conversation partner they are an idiot. 🙂
To question others is a great start. But it is just that. To teach ourselves (outside of technical fields, so politics etc.), it is vital to listen and deeply understand why other human beings think what they do, while assuming all along that they are at least as smart as we are (in this case Biden's administration, not me).
>Well, now, when we together derived falsity, obviously I am banished into the void hell of inconsistency among all the other low beings (99% of humankind?) and shall never ever crawl back again to the daylight where the pure logic resides. What a lovely way to tell the conversation partner they are an idiot. 🙂
That is purely your own interpretation and neither my intent nor what my words suggested.
The fact is if your going to make an argument that leads from one logical point to the next if you do not make an argument that convinces me of your axiom (your first point) then any arguments you make that rely on that axiom/assumption cant be considered.
It has nothing to do with your character or your argument.. What it means is, you either need to do a better job at arguing your axioms before you continue on, at least if you want me to be convinced, or you can abandon the conversation (as you did)
> To question others is a great start. But it is just that. To teach ourselves (outside of technical fields, so politics etc.), it is vital to listen and deeply understand why other human beings think what they do, while assuming all along that they are at least as smart as we are (in this case Biden's administration, not me).
Biden is a family friend, he has been over my family home, even spent the night and had dinner with us. My mom likes the guy but neither me nor my dad like him, he is very fake and a slimeballl in ever respect IMO.
More importantly I never said he was an idiot, what I said was:
> But Joe is either not smart enough to understand that or cares more about his image than doing good.
I gave two options, and honestly the answer is not that he is an idiot, it is that he doesnt care about right or wrong and he only cares about how he is perceived... Listening to others is great, but you need to make sure you listen to people who have demonstrated they bring value to the conversation in the first place. Otherwise your just wasting everyones time.
my kids convinced me to make a mashup of Go and Tetris in #tic80 this morning; welcome to a completely normal weekend here in my house
@GrandiaIV Coulda swore this was a Tokamak Reactor before I zoomed in.
@Electronics
This is either a 250kW Automatic Tuner, or they take their Irish Whiskey production very seriously.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE