@mur2501 I love how they answer yes or no with their tail :)
Open Letter in Support of Richard Stallman https://sandfox.me/misc/support-stallman.html
@icedquinn No worries, I have no objection to you having split the thread.
@LennyGandolphini Cant say i disagree.. I see no reason there needs to be equality of service so long as the system ensures everyone can afford all the options.. If i want less coverage and keep more of my money I should have that right. Why should I be forced to have coverage I dont want in some notion of equality.. Thats like forcing everyone to eat vanilla icecream and telling a diabetic they cant abstain just because its more "equal"
@icedquinn Since this was split off the main thread ill repeat my response here:
To me that doesnt solve any of the problems we have with either a free-market system or universal healthcare.
The problems as i see it is universal healthcare takes away choice on multiple levels, both of if you pay for insurance, and which insurance you get, as well as the effects of that (such as selection of medications which wound up being bound to what insurance covers and thus certain medications wont be on the market if not covered), as well as quality of insurance and care which comes from being able to select different insurance, or none at all, if you dont feel you get value. Basically it lacks the competitiveness to bring quality.
Now the problem with free market is cost, there is a greed and profit angle that the owners of insurance companies want to make as much money as they can at the expense of others. Normally supply and demand strikes a balance in other areas but when it comes to health insurance demand is infinite because a dying person will pay anything to live in a healthy state for just a few more days. So with supply and demand equations broken you dont have a healthy free market.
Any solution need to address both of these concerns without compromise. The answer to this is simply in my mind.. freemarket, co-op only insurance with strong welfare to assist those too poor to buy into it with "healthcare stamps" similar to food stamps one can spend on healthcare.
In a co-op system the owners of an insurance company are the people who have policies at that insurance company, and everyone is an equal owner. So the greed aspect is wholly eliminated. Any extra money the company makes goes right back into the policy owners pockets. So the issues with free-market are resolved. Since the system is free market based it also resolves the issue with universal healthcare, that is, there is selection pressure that ensures quality care is given as people can always switch to the insurance companies that provide the best quality of coverage, and has the best doctors within its network.
To me that doesnt solve any of the problems we have with either a free-market system or universal healthcare.
The problems as i see it is universal healthcare takes away choice on multiple levels, both of if you pay for insurance, and which insurance you get, as well as the effects of that (such as selection of medications which wound up being bound to what insurance covers and thus certain medications wont be on the market if not covered), as well as quality of insurance and care which comes from being able to select different insurance, or none at all, if you dont feel you get value. Basically it lacks the competitiveness to bring quality.
Now the problem with free market is cost, there is a greed and profit angle that the owners of insurance companies want to make as much money as they can at the expense of others. Normally supply and demand strikes a balance in other areas but when it comes to health insurance demand is infinite because a dying person will pay anything to live in a healthy state for just a few more days. So with supply and demand equations broken you dont have a healthy free market.
Any solution need to address both of these concerns without compromise. The answer to this is simply in my mind.. freemarket, co-op only insurance with strong welfare to assist those too poor to buy into it with "healthcare stamps" similar to foodstamps one can spend on healthcare.
In a co-op system the owners of an insurance company are the people who have policies at that insurance company, and everyone is an equal owner. So the greed aspect is wholly eliminated. Any extra money the company makes goes right back into the policy owners pockets. So the issues with free-market are resolved. Since the system is free market based it also resolves the issue with universal healthcare, that is, there is selection pressure that ensures quality care is given as people can always switch to the insurance companies that provide the best quality of coverage, and has the best doctors within its network.
@LennyGandolphini It sounds like you are using universal coverage to mean something more specific than what you really mean.. Universal coverage implies everyone is forced, beyond their own choices, to have insurance, and typically what constitutes insurance is strictly defined or worse yet a specific insurance is forced upon them, usually by tax money...
But your anecdotes about family without coverage suggests to me you mean something else that doesnt equate, necessarily to universal coverage. Correct me if I'm wrong but what you really support is that everyone has access to coverage, should they want it (which is not universal coverage). That is, if you are too poor to afford it it should be free, if you can afford it good quality affordable coverage should be available to you.
If that is correct, then your almost fooling yourself, as you arent asking for universal coverage at all, and thus alternatives are very much an option so long as they accomplish that goal no?
@valleyforge For starters, I dont think he is those things they accuse him of. But if he was, it does make some sense to limit his contribution.
Misogynistic leaders, for example, will propose misogynistic policies. As leaders they have a lot of sway to get support than a mere contributor. So it might make sense they wouldn't want him, or at least someone with those qualities, in a leadership position, which is inevitable given his status really.
After All dont we pick the people in any community for any position based on the types of policies and ideology they support?
@LennyGandolphini It sounds to me like both universal healthcare and private healthcare sucks where your at, and I personally would agree with this as a general statement.
So why be all for tax-paid universal healthcare at all, why feel you have to choose one or the other? Why not consider or suggest alternative systems that are neither of these two but address the concerns of both?
@pthenq1 long story short you are proposing a law that forces a situation where 100% of people with a mental disorder is forced to hide it for as long as they can (on the order of decades potentially) and go without treatment. Causing 100% of people to go untreated in the hopes of catching the 0.01% of them that might kill
Worse idea ever.. if anything all youll do is make way more of them murderers because they are now all untreated and you just turned that 0.01% into a much larger number.
@pthenq1 and yet for him it never was.. decadesof hiding and he was never exposed. Only reason i found out is because he actively sought help on his own. If he knew seeking help would mean he would be considered a subhuman with limmited rights for the rest of his life he would have went on going untreated for another 20+ years...
So your proposing people hide it to keep their rights and go for many decades and **maybe** get caught eventually.. still a dumbass suggestion as Id rather see someone get treated than be forced to hide it for decades on end.
@pthenq1 and i said he hid it for 20+ years with no one ever realizing it, so clearly that is false
How did the fool my friend, you think they got one of her friends, a little kid, pretend to get shot in front of her and then proceed to play dead for some time with somehow faking a hole for a bullet wound. Someone she knew well and was friends with before getting shot?
Ok psycho... like i said believe whatever dumbass shit you want just dont involve me.
Whatever crazy tifoil hat shit you want to tell yourself. I know someone who was there when it happened. So yea im not going to listen to this tinfoil hat shit, sorry.
@pthenq1 You said they dont seek help on their own and cant hide it.. you were wrong on both counts.
Not into the conspiracy theory nonsense. Just dont like words being misused.
@pthenq1 No there was no break. He went to the psychiatrist on his own as he wasnt happy hiding it. No one knew until he came out and sought help on his own.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE