Show newer

@Weedle

"It certainly wasnt the way he was holding him down"... both autopsy reports and several doctors all disagree with you there.

Quote from one autopsy examiner:

"died as a result of mechanical asphyxiation"

Quote from the other autopsy examiner:

"cardiopulmonary arrest complicating law enforcement subdual, restraint and neck compression."

@realcaseyrollins@counter.fedi.live @ChristiJunior @buttered_poasties @sickburnbro @coolboymew @realcaseyrollins@social.teci.world

@Weedle

When did I say he had no hand in his death, you just pulled that out of thin air.. You asked me if he got off him when his heart stopped if he should still be guilty, I said no.. I said nothing about if he had a hand in his death or not.

@realcaseyrollins@counter.fedi.live @ChristiJunior @buttered_poasties @sickburnbro @coolboymew @realcaseyrollins@social.teci.world

re: uspol, acab 

@noelle I am not sure that is the proper interpritation.. just because he doesnt have a consitutional obligation to protect can not be used to infer he had no obligation to protect under the eyes of the law. The law can be hard to follow and the wording often seems to say one thing when it is really saying another, I think that is the case here.

An officer who doesnt protect someone isnt violating the constitution, as Scalia points out, that doesnt mean he is innocent (as the constitution is not the end of the law). There are legal tests for Negligence, and an officer who does not protect would assuredly violate the legal test for negligence and be held accountable on those grounds. In fact for the 3rd degree manslaughter part of the Chauvin case this is exactly the test they applied to show his guilt.

Point being, Scalias write up is entierly correct, but it doesnt have the consequence that police dont have to protect.

@Weedle

Because when we talk about things like murder, especially 2nd degree murder, intent matters.

The case was not about if he caused the death, it is about if he intended to cause death or if death was due to negligence on his part. If he caused the death and that deathw as neither due to negligence or intent then he wasnt guilty of the charges at hand.

@realcaseyrollins@counter.fedi.live @ChristiJunior @buttered_poasties @sickburnbro @coolboymew @realcaseyrollins@social.teci.world

uspol, acab 

@noelle What clause of the constitution do you feel obligates them to protect the citizens in their jurisdiction?

While I would say they have duty to protect the citizens in their jurisdiction based on their oath that is not something encoded in the constitution as far as I know.

@Weedle

I did answer in my very first response and very first sentence, then I went on to explain my answer.

@ChristiJunior @buttered_poasties @sickburnbro @coolboymew

@sickburnbro

Seen quit a few. I have not objected to anything they did while he was alive and resisting arrest (even though he never took a swing or attacked the officers I still gave them the benefit of the doubt). But again once your told a man's heart has stopped there is no excuse for his actions.

@realcaseyrollins@counter.fedi.live @ChristiJunior @buttered_poasties @Weedle @coolboymew @realcaseyrollins@social.teci.world

@realcaseyrollins@counter.fedi.live

Yes, and not sure how you can be scared of someone whose heart isnt beating. That excuse only holds any water up until his heart stopped, after that it ceases to be a valid excuse.

@ChristiJunior @buttered_poasties @sickburnbro @Weedle @coolboymew @realcaseyrollins@social.teci.world

@realcaseyrollins@counter.fedi.live

If that were true then why didnt he take the 5 seconds it takes to put leg and hand cuffs on him then get off? That would alleviate all his feas of a dead guy coming ack to life and running away, and being unconscious would have been trivial to do.

So considering he coud have easily addressed all those concerns your argument basically boils dow to "He was scared he might come back to life"... in other words, wanted him dead and to stay dead.

@ChristiJunior @buttered_poasties @sickburnbro @Weedle @coolboymew @realcaseyrollins@social.teci.world

@Nudhul

Source that she didnt have ID?

And yes the intent was to get him on his back to give cpr.. did you not watch the trials?

@Bubbul @ChristiJunior @Godcast @job384 @coolboymew

@Nudhul

1) your wikipedia quote doesnt disagree with what I said. The point of cpr is to restore bloodflow from a heart **that is not beating**, this sustains life until the EMT arrives or can sometimes start the heart itself.

As for surrendering to bystandards, not sure what your on about, his partner urged him to get off so he could perform CPR and cauvin refused to.

@Bubbul @ChristiJunior @Godcast @job384 @coolboymew

@realcaseyrollins@counter.fedi.live

I never said hold him down was wrong.. I said once he was informed by someone trained in taking a pulse and giving CPR that the man's heart stopped then there was no justification of any kind fo rhim sitting on the man and refusing a fllow cop from delivering CPR.

What do you feel justifies sitting on a mans chest that doesnt have a heart beat and blocking others from giving CPR?

@ChristiJunior @buttered_poasties @sickburnbro @Weedle @coolboymew @realcaseyrollins@social.teci.world

@Nudhul

God you are a dumbass.. No if you feel a pulse you are suppose to stop compressions. The only time you do compressions is when the heart is stopped, first rule of CPR (I am cpr certified btw).

@Bubbul @ChristiJunior @Godcast @job384 @coolboymew

@wishgranter14

No that was not Chauvin or his partner. The other cops on the scene before chauvin arrived call the EMT. Chauvin wasnt even aware the EMT had been called till much later

@ChristiJunior @coolboymew

@Nudhul

Are you nuts. The point of CPR is literally to get someone whose heart has stopped to start again. That is literally the entire point of CPR.

@Bubbul @ChristiJunior @Godcast @job384 @coolboymew

@realcaseyrollins@social.teci.world

I never claimed why he died, it isnt relevant, I said he was strangled, not that he died due to be strangled... Even if he died because of the medications, that fact that cauvin continued to strangle him 3 minutes after his fellow officer told him that Floyd's heart stopped stil tells me he intended the man dead. Even if he didnt kill him he sure as hell made sure he stayed dead and refused to let others help resuscitate him. So he is still guilty even if what you say is true, not is what you say in contrast to anything i said.

@buttered_poasties @Weedle @ChristiJunior @sickburnbro @realcaseyrollins@counter.fedi.live @coolboymew

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.