@icedquinn Then you have either poor sources or sources working in very unusual circumstances. My career has me working with quite a few in the medical community from doctors to nurses and when this topic has come up not a single of the dozens of different professionals have ever said anything that reflects what your saying now.
Already familiar with the book, thanks for recommending it. I prefer to discuss arguments made here rather than by someone who isnt here.
Being vulnerable or "duped" by some propaganda as you state it is your opinion, for many that isnt true from their perspective (and even as they become adults they will in many cases continue to disagree with your assesment). Regardless, that does not change their right to bodily autonomy or to have the right to judge for themselves what is propaganda and what is real. Certainly you have the opposite biases and are feeding into propaganda of an opposite nature, so you are no more above propaganda and bias than them, the difference is that it isnt your body, its theirs.
@mcduquesne @KellyS@noagendasocial.com @ThatDude
@icedquinn Except they dont, that is a complete fiction. The cause of death is listed with respect to if a doctor has reason to believe the disease contributed to the death, period.
Now you could always find some anomalies in the data (and this is why many studies will acquire their own data rather than rely on a third-party reporting). But by in large, no, this isn't in line with the reality.
What the patient thinks isnt where the statistics come from.. we dont figure out how many people with vaccines get infected anyway by going "hey buddy do you think you have covid". Moreover placebo effect (which can in fact cause real physiological protection and isnt just a mental state) is tested against, its the whole point of double-blind studies.
So no, that is completely nonsensical, we already adjust for placebo effect and measure actual infection rates compared against placebo to insure a vaccine is truely effective.
None of that of course requires a vaccine to be 100% effective either.
@yaksha @wa__em
> If we agree no drug is 100% safe & effective, then the vax is likely a short term placebo for most people w/unknown long term effects.
This statement makes no sense to me. Why would something that is <100% effective, for example something 99.9999% effective suddenly just be a placebo?
@yaksha @wa__em
"the fact that you aren't"
I'm not? I ask that question all the time, and work pretty heavily with that question.. It simply wasnt relevant to the point being made.
“Statistics isn't about discovering correlations, it's about eliminating coincidence."
Exactly, which is why all the science on this topic which has passed peer review does exactly that, not just look at correlation but have quite a bit of procedure designed to eliminate coincidence. In fact I elaborated on a small snippet of that already in the thread.
If you think im missing some points, by all means, feel free to explain it. But you seem to talk in sound bites and links so as to avoid any critical interpretation; not much I can do with that honestly.
@yaksha @wa__em
@js290 Yes they are. I am not against caution for either. But the level of absurdity coming from the anti--vaxxers is still laughable.
@freemo Mind = blown
@matrix Leave it to science to expand the limits of human knowledge... My understanding of the universe has changed in utterly profound ways thank to this new and unexpected information.
Fair points. But we have to admit, the US president is not and never will be as accessible and "just another citizen" as a dutch PM is... you'd hardly even recognize the dutch PM as being special if you saw him riding down the street :)
@freemo Well, of course there's a lot to say in response to your comment, but I guess it wouldn't add much to what we all know anyway.
But I just had an interesting thought. The guy actually lives in the house where his office is too, right? So technically he does not need to commute - at least not too far. Nevertheless, before becoming POTUS, Biden was known to start each day on his Peloton bike (the news of what security risks this poses is also fun: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/jan/21/joe-biden-peloton-fitness-bike-cybersecurity-risk). So assuming they sorted the security out and allowed him to ride his stationary Peloton device, does that now count for a commute (of 0m, but still strictly technically it "gets" him there)? If so, we should credit him for getting on par with Mark Rutte when it comes to commuting on a bike 😄 .
@lain I have been rather vocal that the vaccine is risky since it didnt pass long term safety trials. So I too agree that, for now, one should probably only get the vaccine if at high risk and wait another year or so to see how safe they turn out to be before jumping in.
That said everything ive seen till now clearly shows the vaccine is a much lower risk than the virus.. though some vaccines are safer than others (AZ has shown some nasty side effects so probably not a good first choice).
That said, I will review the study you posted when I get a chance and see if it changes my view on some of my statements.
This is true... which kinda says a lot on a bit of a tangent.. why can the PM of the netherlands safely ride to work every day while the USA president needs an army to follow him.... might have something to do with the fact that US presidents tend to be evil fuckers who are starting wars and killing people (indirectly) year after year
@lain Not exactly the same for an important reason though... quantity.
For anything that has any potential to kill anyone on any scale you will always find that the infirm will be the disperportionatly represented majority. It should be obvious why someone who is already sick is more likely to die of anything remotely possible of causing death than someone who is healthy.
It isnt about the fact that people with covid or people getting vaccines are more likely to die with pre-existing conditions. Its the fact that with COVID your hundreds of thousands of times more likely to die than from a vaccine.
In other words, throwing a fit because a very small number of people die with preexisting conditions is not equivalent to throwing a fit because huge numbers of people die, of whom a large proportion had preexisting conditions. Basically the odds of dying are so astronomically higher from covid than the vaccine that you cant compare the reactions to the two as being equivelant.
Well then I guess I pegged him wrong on that.
That said, I highly doubt he is cycling to work at the white house each day like the dutch PM :)
Your logic isnt too far off, the devil though is in the details.
For example, whats your sample size? How were the sampled from the population? Was it double blind randomly checking members from the population or inferred by just those who show up in a hospital? What about the people who got sick but were so minor they never went to the hospital? etc.
The simple numbers we can run on the back of a napkin is fine and all, but it isnt a replacement for a properly run study.
@wa__em @yaksha
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE