@pschwede Im not sure i understand the question. We are able of reconstructing historically both temperature and CO2 yea.
@pschwede Im a bit confused why you are unclear how that could be related to the earths greenhouse effect. Are you unaware of how the effect works? I'd be happy to explain the effect if it helps, not trying to be condescending.
@pschwede Yea that was #2, but the saw tooth pattern doesnt debunk the statement we never saw a pattern like this before... The saw tooth int he chart is over the course of millions of years. The saw tooth spike we are currently int he middle of is over the course of a 100. so no that pattern was never seen historically (a spike that fast, just never happened)
@pschwede There are many. The ones we do at the lower level usually involves a chamber filled with gases where we test heat retention in various ways by measuring the rate of heat loss and IR radiative heat specifically (as the chamber itself is inside a vacuum to simulate space).
@pschwede Huh? How does a saw tooth pattern in any way contradict point 3? I lost ya on that claim.
@pschwede Actually green house effects are rather trivial to confirm in the lab. Did the experiment myself when i was a kid. It is far from a theory.
@pschwede Sure, but i just proved in the last statement why we know that isnt the case. So your point has become moot. Unless you can explain the obvious contradiction.
@pschwede Well we dont have to, not exactly, because of #3... think about it like this...
So if we accept there is strong correlation between temperature and CO2 that means either changes in temperature effect the world in a way that causes CO2 levels to change. Or CO2 levels cause the temperature to change, or perhaps even both, where changing one always changes the other.
Whichever of these it is all we need to do is ask ourselves a few simple questions:
How much has the CO2 changed in recent years?
How much CO2 have humans put into the atmosphere in that time?
Is the portion of CO2 increased in the atmosphere mostly accounted for by human processes such as pollution or is the volume much greater than the known human contribution?
Well earlier you said you conceded point 3 which was that humans contributed the bulk of the change int he CO2. So if you recognize this fact, then the fact that we can observe the temperature changing exactly the same as the correlation shown historically, we can therefore conclude that a change in CO2 is the causative agent resulting in the change in temperature. After all if it was the other way around then we wouldnt see any change in temperature from all the CO2 we are dumping, yet the correlation continues to track just as perfectly as it did historically.
@pschwede Thats a fine theory to put forth and all and im sure people made such theories int he early days when they didnt know about climate change and the topic hasnt been investigated.
So why not go and investigate yoru theory. Go look at the fossil record around plants and see where their relative biomass high and low periods are and plant extinction events and see if they line up with the chart and validate your theory.
Obviously you will find that your theory is easily debunked but int he name of science if you feel it is a valid explanation i do encourage you to research it rather than just assume it to be valid.
@pschwede Ahh yes, you are right, it does appear that way. Though in reality at those time scales they are really happening simultaniously. Even though it does appear one preceeds the other.
@pschwede Temp is red, CO2 is blue, the red curve seems to change after a change int he blue curve, as expected.
@pschwede Yup, teh correlation is extremely tight. Not surprisingly just as we are seeing now as co2 rises the temperature responds very quickly. I mean after all, setup a greenhouse and it will be hot that same day. Really doesnt take long for the effects to happen.
But back to the original 3 points. This and experiments like it clearly show points number 1 and 2 to be true. It is pretty trivial to prove point #3 that humans are producing most of the CO2 change.
So I hope given this evidence, and the body of other evidence like it, we can agree that human caused climate change is pretty easy to confirm.
I want to thank everyone for your patience. As many of you know we have been redoing the entire QOTO architecture. This included many new services for our users (all free!) but also some very big changes.
It took us some time to move over to the new infrastructure plus our founder, Jeff, was in the hospital for about 9 months and that seriously slowed us down.
However the latest version of QOTO's variant of mastodon has been beta tested and is ready to go. We will begin the upgrade of the official server tomorrow evening.
As always the QOTO server will include all our usual additions to the code base and MathJax support will be reenabled on this upgrade as well.
We will update the community with the exact time of the upgrade sometime tomorrow once we know. But expect it to be in the middle of the night for both Europe and USA time zones.
@pschwede So i know you cant get throught he paywall so here is a chart fromt he Ice Core paper I tried to share. Here it is important to see how CO2 correlates to temperature. If you dont line these two up all youll see is noise. Notice how it follows it almost perfectly?
@pschwede Actually ive seen this chart many times. So what about this chart do you feel debunks climate change? TIt shows pretty clearly to me the huge spike that only developed after the industrial revolution. You can see rather clearly around 1900 the spike sky rockets which is around the same time CO2 emissions sky rocketed... Where can you show me a natural spike that did NOT coincide with CO2 emissions though. That is the point your trying to debunk isnt it? Not seeing that here.
@pschwede Sadly you will find that is true of most research. I do recommend everyone buys a subscription to access scientific papers (there are many services). It is next to impossible to be educated about the modern world without it when news media fails so horrifically to convey objective facts. You really should get access.
@pschwede No it hasnt. I've seen many detailed charts of time and temp relationships and have never seen as large and as fast a change. Now if you are going to say otherwise, I ust ask you back that up with a cited source. You'll have to prove to me that has some validity.
@mngrif SWEET! so vagrant **finally** came up (i was working on this all day).. my code edits in beta are working afterall. I will begin the system upgrade!
@mngrif OH OHOH.. i think i literally JUST got vagrant to work!
@mngrif Man you have no idea, ive been trying all day now to get vagrant up so i can beta test this damn thing and i get an error!
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE