Show newer

re: New Instance Blocks 

@Ox

While i respect curators decision to fecderate however they wish the main issue I have is that it is inconsistent. They claim they will defederate from any instance taht federates with another instance that violates their CoC/ToS... that means any instance that federates with an instance they block would likewise have to be blocked.

There isnt a single instance, however, in the whole fediverse with a block list as expansive as matoart. That would mean if they really applied their rules fairly and didnt make exceptions they would literally have to defederate from the whole fediverse.

So clearly it is more an excuse to just discriminate freely it appears. Again, their choice, but not a good look IMO.

@Curator

A complete list of people who have blocked me. Because federating blocks was a great idea. 

@matrix

Wait, blocks can be federated now?

Ecological economics (with some key systems thinking CANSEE members) meets P2P on May 13 YouTube Live session twitter.com/Revkin/status/1259

@vnarek Im not sure performing an instrument in a school setting would really be any less enjoyable than doing it for profit.

But one way to address that is to require alls chools attended as part of this welfare program to have co-op structure (which many universities have).. This way working as you would in your chosen profession is part of the schooling itself.

At that point you wouldnt really be avoiding work by going to school anyway, youd still be doing work (along side school) but paid less for it.

@vnarek

Even a bachelor degree is a decent amount of work, especially at a university, at least if your going full time.. But then again i think it depends.

In the USA people getting a bachelor degree appear to be worked a lot harder than college in the Netherlands at least. My room mate only had to go to class one or two times a week, he seemed to have it easy by comparison of what I had to do at bachelor level.

@adi_k

@vnarek I think its undeniable that some people are going to attain a higher education than others.

A person with down syndrom could study their whole life and will likely never be an expert in nuclear physics. I think its safe to say there is some genetic middle ground. People who just arent naturally very inclined to learning certain intellectual persuits.

Thats one reason why I said skills rather than just university. For me the system I propose would also include, say going to school to learn an instrument, or art. There are many types of skills that take a life time to learn, are profitable, and accessable to people who may not be intellectually capable in other areas.

For people who have no potential to learn skills of any kind (lets say a non-speaking autistic person who may be completely non functional) then I do think exceptions should be made for them and welfare should take care of them should they have no family capable of doing so.

But these are rare exceptions.

@vnarek

Do you have expiernce with post-grad education?

Most people I know at the graduate level (and even those at a 4 year university) spend all their time studying they barely have time to sleep. I would hate to go back tot he level of workload I had at university, it was unsustainable IMO.

@adi_k

@vnarek

Agreed, and to be fair the educational system as a whole would really need to be reevaluated too.

These sorts of social/economic issues we are trying to solve really require us to fix a lot of problems at every level of society.

I mean hell discrimination alone, if allowed to run rampant in a society, will mean even a well educated minority might not get paid well, for example.. So there are more problems to consider here than just education too... but, one step at a time :)

@adi_k

@vnarek

But we really cant evaluate just the day to day effort...

How much effort does the doctorial profressor need to put in day to day learning new material to stay up to date in their field, how many years of effort did they have to put in studying to get to the point they are able to take the position in the first place.

If we compare effort of one job to the other i think we need to consider the overall effort, including training, not just the day to day effort, if we are going to evaluate what is fair.

@adi_k

@vnarek

Thats the idea, as long as you are aquiring marketable skills (for example going to university) then welfare would take care of all your living expenses for that time.

I'm not sure we would test their results, exactly.. thats one approach. The other could be just to ensure that it is accredited schools and make the stipulation that they need to pass (with some allowance for failing once or twice since mistakes do happen).

Perhaps if a person fails more than once they would need to get a letter from their teacher explaining that the teacher felt the student put in their best effort.

I generally feel that for people who are mentally incapable of higher education (say, someone with Down syndrom) then they should be given other types of training specifically suited for them.

@adi_k

@vnarek

No I dont think how hard the job is should directly effect what we pay them. If it is truly a harder job than doctorial work (which I dont think it is, not in terms of skill-difficulty anyway) then that would be reflected in the pay already.

I'd imagine that the vast majority of grade school teachers would be completely incapable of even doing a doctorial professor position at all. It is signfiicantly more difficult to the point it would not even be doable for most of them.

@adi_k

@vnarek

The other issue with a time limit is, what do you do when someone exceeds the limit and then needs welfare...

I'd much rather say "eh go back to school for another year then, here is some more money if you do"..

than "oh well you spent 28 years in school and still need help, here is some free money, you can get it now without school at all!"

With a good school system school is hard work, REALLY hard work. Most people should prefer to work than go to school, it would not just be good to educate the public but if structured properly should be a deterrent to being on welfare and incentive to get work with those skills.

@adi_k

...But, what's this hashtag anyways?

We had a discussion and development topic, for this, an idea that came from a local user suggestion, and is now part of our features here.

See Discourse Forum -- discourse.qoto.org/t/special-h

...or ask questions here if needed...

Show thread

@vnarek

The whole point of reward based welfare is that if you attend school or other skill training thent he welfare would be generous enough that you would have stable income and plenty of time and money to study harder.

In my eyes if you are currently persuing a PhD for example all your basic needs should be covered so stability is a non issue.

@adi_k

@vnarek

A doctorial professor makes, on average, 141K in the USA, I'd say thats pretty damn good.

Remember its not just about how important the position is, its also about how skilled. High skilled positions will pay more since it takes more effort to do it.

Compare the above figure to a public school teacher at a remedial level and they only make 30K not 141K, huge difference. Sure we still need remedial school teachers, but it doesnt take nearly as much skill to be one.

There are two ways to solve that, one is to ensure more people are highly skilled, thus more wealth is generated and less competition for lower paying jobs. thus you will see less disparity as demands balance out

Or two, increase the skill we demand from teachers in the first place, which would also drive higher pay

But that would also start to get into a huge tangent around restructuring the education system in the first place. Currently I think in all countries we set the bar so low on education at the lower levels that the vast majority of children never reach their potential. a lot of this has to do with teach techniques.. but again this is a tangent.

Most kids could be doing college level work by middle school if they had teachers who provided the right education IMO.. but as I said, we are way below our poential there.

@adi_k

@adi_k

Well considering that 1) school is hard work, more so than any job, especially at the PhD level and 2) welfare would make them far less money than a job with a PhD would get them (usually) this would mostly be a non issue. No one is going to milk welfare while at the same time doing more work and making less.

With that said if someone did decide to stay in school for 20 some years, presuming they are working hard, and getting good grades (welfare would only pay for years they pass presumably) I'd be ok with that. Someone who stays in school for a life time and just hovers at a PhD level is likely going to be doing research that is invaluable to the community and worth far more than the cost of the welfare in the first place.

@vnarek

@adi_k except for the fact that horses didnt build and own the cars, nor are they the ones driving it.. which is the key difference.

AI generates wealth FOR us. At least until some immaginary point where they overthrow their humans and make us slaves :)

@adi_k

Perhaps, thats fine by me. School is hard work and not really a cop out compared to work.. if they want to stay in school longer thats fine by me. Having a highly educated populace is good for all of us.

@vnarek

@adi_k

I am perfectly ok with someone who would be ablet o get a job immediately instead staying on welfare and persuing a greater set of skills while milking welfare.

In the end they come away with a greater skill set and once they enter the work force again will be a much more valuable member of society.. Getting them a job as quickly as possible is not and should not be the goal, we want them to get **good** jobs, highly skilled.

Hell I'd be ok with the free education and income reward be available to everyone at every level. If someone working in a factory actually quit and received free money to go get a PhD, I'd be ok with even that.

@vnarek

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.