@vnarek well thats fair. I'm not trying to argue that the conservative view is correct. I am only saying that they are at least trying to use their own moral framework to fight for the rights of a child they feel is under represented.
I'm glad we can agree on the motivation, it is an important step in understanding the other side in stuff like this.
I dont think that just because someone is working full time and contributes minimally to the community (does a job we dont really need them doing because we have too many people doing it already) should keep someone out of poverty.
If youw ant to stay out of poverty you should be expected to do jobs that society needs done to a great enough extent that society would pay well for it in the first place. If the job doesnt pay well then there is a low need in society for workers to do such a job.
No not really, that isnt a reward based welfare.. reward based would mean you get 100$ welfare default, but if you go to school and try to get a PhD then the education would be free and your welfare for personal expenses goes from 100$ to 2,000$ for example.
As far as I know there is no reward based system where the welfare you get increases while and if you are increasing your marketability.
Seeking jobs does nothing to increase ones marketability, that is not the sort of behavior i am suggesting welfare should be rewarding.
@adi_k Even intellectual automation is nothing new. It started with the abacus a long time ago.
what we generally find is that the tools that automate intellectual persuits largely act to enhance some human actor rather than replace it..
Google can be seen as replacing the intellectual labour of librarians, but in reality it just enhanced peoples ability to do research and improved humans intellectual persuits for the most part. Calculators arent much different.
But the idea that it somehow creates unemployment isnt really the reality of it. It doesnt increase unemployment int he least, only shifts it from one set of skills to another. We dont need librarians anymore but having good google skills is needed for a job all the same, and in many ways has created more jobs than it has destroyed.
The argument mostly relies on some imagined future that is on the horizon, but the fact is, its not the trend we are seeing. for all the talk of automation taking over jobs for years now the end result is more as I described, one sector disapears as other new sectors are created, the overall number of jobs is about the same, well technically it has gone up!
What we do see however is this increasing automation increases our ability to generate wealth, and the standard of living of even thelowest class of people in our society actually has continually increased as a result of this
In short I dont think the trends you describe are reflected onr eality. Its a narrative you hear based in fear but is historically not nearly as unique as people might think.
@vnarek well yes and no.. There are many republicans who admitidly want to unconditionally make abortion illegal.. then again on the flip side in america there are many democrats (even politicians) who want to see abortion be legal including late term abortion. Many democrats routinely argue that as long as the baby can not survive outside the womb that abortion should be legal. Which would effectively make it legal at every stage.
So both sides take their view of morality and individual rights to the extream.
I do agree that the proper solution is somewhere in between the two. But the underlying point is both groups here are pushing for a perspective focused on individual rights, just with very different views on what that means.
Ideally yes, ideally we would compare it to other government programs. But no program in the world uses the model of welfare I proposed (free education at all levels, and a reward based incetives to get people to educate themselves out of poverty)...
Since no such models exist in the real world based off my suggested approach there is no way to compare it to other government programs.
We can however comapre it to the "control" that is, see if it gets people closer or farther way from the goal of employability. As I stated UBi generally has either no impact on a persons employability or it decreases it.. Generally those on UBI do not show increased income compared to those not on UBI in countries where it is experimentally dont side by side.
If people are doing a job that is in demand, then they will be paid well.
If someone isnt paid well it means that fewer people need the job done than people want to do it.
Watching TV is occasionally a job (people get paid for reviewing TV shows is a thing).. but they get paid very little because, well, anyone is willing to do it. But if you want to be part of a focus group, they will pay you.
Its a good example because while there is a need for the job, and people do pay for it, far more people are willing to do it than people need it done for them.. so its low paid... just as it should be.
releiving distress while making someone forever depednent on government handouts is not an acceptable purpose for welfare.
The purpose of welfare should be viewed as a means to get people out of poverty.
If you are on welfare with no intention of ever getting off of it then you should be under distress.
It is the difference between enabling someone who doesnt have their life in order vs actually helping them.
Employabilty isnt going anyway.. The world is going to keep needing employees forever into the future. The difference is just that we will need high skill people, increasingly so into the future. There will certainly be little to no use for what we see as low skilled people in the near future. All the more reason we need to improve their skills and not just drop money in their lap.
Obviously watching TV isnt a job. My point was simply that what people want to do as a job doesnt matter, we arent, or at least should not, try to be giving people whatever job they want and then try to throw money at them to make it "fair"... If you arent paid enough for a certain job then the job is clearly either not very critical, or more people want to do the job than we need doing it.
@adi_k its individual based. In fact if you look at chargs of Gini coefficient across many countries at once you will notice some countries go up, many do in fact go down over long periods of time, and many stay about the same.
Any cursory look at the gini index over time would quickly show that your assertion that it always goes up except during catastrophe is patently false.
For example France, Norway, and Mexico have all had their Gini Index decreasing from the mid 1900's to today.. 70 years of consistently (mostly) going down.
@adi_k yes, as I said the geni coeffecient in the USA decreased significantly from 1930 - 1970
Automation has been going on for thousands of years. It is generally a myth that it hurts the economy in the way you describe when you really think about it. The thing is most of us are really poor at understanding or identifying automation historically, partly because we see it as so common place today.
For example one of the earlier forms of automation would be sewage and plumbing. It used to be that we dug holes and hired people to dig those holes and literally in some cases haul carts of poop from one place to another. But then plumbing was invented, basically a form of automation. Now instead of hole diggers or people with carts hauling human waste we had pipes that did it all automatically. Yet as always the economy kept chugging along and jobs just changing hand. Instead of people with carts now we have plumbers, and metal workers, and people in iron mines to make the pipes, some of them became city engineers, and othes just moved on to other jobs.
Automation at the level we see today (but in very different forms) have been going on for thousands of years, its not the issue people think it is, in the end jobs will always keep existing they will just move from low skill to high skill.
@vnarek I agree that my counter argument to abortion would break down int he case where the woman becomes pregnant due to no choice of her own, rape being an obvious case.
But most conservatives I think would agree that even if they feel abortion should be illegal in the case of rape an exception should be made. There are some extream conservatives who of course do feel abortion should be a no go under any circumstances, but I'd say they are likely the minority rather than the rule.
Regardless the point here is both sides are arguing for individual rights they just have very different views on where or how. I think we can at least agree the philosophical problem isnt that straight forward.
I dunno does europe really have more legalized drugs than the USA? In america cannabis is legalized in a bunch of states. In europe the only place I know it is really legal would be the Netherlands and even there it is "technically" still illegal.
Just to be clear lets look at the actual numbers from UBI around the world.
Finland is probably the best bet, its program was enacted randomly among 2000 people across the whole country (rather than isolated to a specific region as in other experiments). It is also one of the longer and earlier UBI experiments in europe.
So the main question here is, did UBI help people get out of poverty as you suggest it might (more efficiently) or did it just throw money at a problem and solve nothing...
Well compared to control groups the 2000$ on UBI actually had **decreased** income after the experiment compared to the general population on welfare. On average 21 euros less than control groups. The members of the expirement did not sick education or increasing their marketable skills.
In short, they took the money and did nothing to improve their situation, or at least, did less than people who were on traditional welfare.
So yea as I said, a step backwards.
I agree iut does cost more money then just handing someone a wad of cash and saying good luck.
I would not say that is a waste however. That beurocratic expense to ensure there is a reward model in place is not wasteful, it is in fact a good and neccesary use of money.
I am not interested in doing welfare as cheap as possible, I am happy to spend extra money on it if we are actually helping to ensure people get out of their situation rather than just have money to live another month.
The thing is, reward based welfare has never been tried.. we have never made PhDs and all other levels of education free to the poor, so we cant say its ineffective, it has never been done in the way I suggested.
But UBI has been tried countless times from countless countries. The results from those countries as far as I can tell is completely unacceptable. They have done little to nothing to actually getting the poor to be high-skilled. Largely their education/skill set remained mostly unchanged post-UBI
@adi_k btw int he USa the geni coeffecient decreased from 1930 to 1970.. So unless you are suggesting that there was a constant catastrophic economic collapse continually for 40 years in the USA I would say that alone disproves the assertion that it always goes up.
@adi_k Cant say i agree
The market is designed to ensure the people who continually invest in themselves to have the most marketable (needed) skills are the ones who generate the income.
Sure business owners make a lot of money, but then we have the best programmers in the world (just workers) making 300K a year too.
I'd argue wealth distribution, will always follow the distribution of people who have those marketable skills. Meaning you will always see people who are simple labourers with little or no skills (skills that dont require a life time of study) will be low income, and those who do invest a lifetime of study into their skills will be high income. The latter being a small portion of the population is exactly why wealth disparity is very high. We are probably talking 1% of the population who are actually motivated enough to invest in their own skills to that extent.
The geni index doesnt "always go up" it just tends towards the distribution i mentioned and usually other artificial wealth distribution schemes are employed to slow it reaching that point. In other words, with no social programs of any kind eventually the geniindex would have settled but we just never get there.
My solution is to enact a form of welfare that tries to change that dynamic. To ensure people get the sort of assistance they need to more than 1% of the population are pursuing being highly skilled in the first place.
In my expiernce people arent very good at getting out of these situations on their own.
I have spent a huge portion of my life trying to help others.. Generally people who were homeless I took into my home and try get them on their feet many times, usually for years on end.
One thing has become clear to me. the vast majority of people are not very good at fixing their poverty on their own. Most of the people I took in, if i did nothing but just give them free food, shelter and spending money, would not change anything, in a year or ten most would (and were) in the same situation as when I took them in.
I quickly realized that the most effective way to help them is conditional help. I let them know my expectations for them (the end goal), I start by giving them free reign to become self sufficient, what they say they needed I supported financially, then as I see they arent moving towards their goals then i make conditions on them (for example I might demand they apply for at least 5 jobs every day if they want to continue living with me, or I might require they see a psychiatrist).
By making sure the help they got was conditional on the effort they invested in getting out of their situation this ultimately was what was needed to get most people out of their poverty.
Same for a UBI, dumping money in a persons lap is unlikely to get them out of poverty. They will just become dependent on that money and continue not to contribute marketable skills to society. Instead we need to make welfare dependent on the persons effort they put in to gain marketable skills. Then we may see some actual progress.
UBI will never solve these problems, its like a splash of water on a raging fire.
I dont think people wanting to do low-paid jobs is really a good argument. Most people would probably love to do a low-paid job that requires little skill im sure... hell most people would probably love a job where they watch TV all day too.. just because you want that sort of job doesnt mean society has an obligation to pay you for it.
As for us needing such jobs... somewhat, for now, but they are quickly being replaced by technology. but the fact is taht there are clearly more people who want to do those jobs than there is money to pay them well. thats exactly why their low paid. So we still need to get most people away from performing such jobs.
I feel most low-skill jobs should be focused on people who are handicapped and really cant do normal jobs. Those people need jobs within their means but we dont need people doing these jobs en masse.
@vnarek we arent talking about what is reasonable or not, thats is a different discussion. We are talking about what group takes personal freedom to a greater extream.
Regardless of how you feel about the law or if it is reasonable or not the fact remains that unreistricted access to guns is more of a personal freedom stance than reducing access to guns.
Again the discussion of abortion follows the same logic. Your argument for why you support abortion is all well and good, but it doesnt really successfully make the case that any one group is more focused on individual rights WRT abortion than the other. It is simply your reasoning for giving the mothers individual rights superior protection over the childs. Thats fine, but doesnt address the underlying issue.
As a side note though, just to address your view on abortion, though irrelevant to the point we are discussing. You can not compare a transplant to abortion in the way you did. In the vast majority of pregnancies the woman engages in sex willingly. So they knowingly put the child in the position that the child is in, unlike a transplant patient. One could argue when you engage in sex you are knowingly risking creating a child that will be biologically dependent on you and thus you have an obligation.
since the mother forced the child into needing them against the childs will by engaging in sex in the first place it would be more akin to causing the injury on someone else. Which normally would send you to jail. However if injured someone and put your own life at risk to save them the court may not send you to jail since you put in an effort to save the person.
Im not arguing for or against abortion, but I am saying that the analogy you gave really doesnt compare to the situation at all.
As to drug use, both liberals and conservatives seem to be mixed on that. Both sides seem to support keeping most drugs illegal and both sides seem to have made concessions to make cannabis legal or closer to legal.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE