Show newer

@lightclaws

I would say your initial posit that most of wealth today is through theft rather than generation isnt really true. Not to say it isnt a significant factor, but I'd say there is a mix of both and much of the wealth that is moved rather than generated is not always the fault of the wealthy person either, it is nuanced.

generally speaking if two people involved in a trade are both acting within their best interests, and are responsible, then wealth is generated through that trasaction. For example if I buy a shovel off a shovel conglomerate, and I use that shovel to go build things with it, then the person who sold me the shovel helped me facilitate the generation of wealth. so the big company selling shovels is helping the world generate wealth more so than stealing it.

On the other hand if I go buy a video game and spend all day playing that video game, and pretty much waste my life away buying and selling video games, then no wealth will be generated by the big company trying to sell video games. But is that the fault of the video game salesman or the person buying it and using it to waste their own time? After all if you just play video games occasionally, as a way to relax, they may ultimately cause you to work harder and better when you are on the clock as you are well rested and energized.

Long story short, as long as people are making responsible choices in their purchases and invest, mostly, in buying things that enable them to generate wealth, then the big companies selling the goods that enable that are themselves generating significant wealth in their communities.

As for the "wealth is not money" argument, you seemed to mis the point... Money is wealth, wealth is not money. Money is a small subset of wealth.

I do agree that as you generate wealth it becomes easier to generate more wealth as well. but thats a good thing because as I stated above the wealth large companies generate is not solely their own, when people are buying responsibly they are also enabling that wealth generation for others. that says nothing of the share holders, of which any one can be one with only a few dollars to their name. So that wealth generation is something we all benefit from and have access to usually.

@gioypi

@penny I'm not ignoring your point. I am simply saying it is arguing against a case that I am not asserting either way.

But to address your point, it depends on the country. In the USA for example the majority of the top 500 richest people in the USA started as middle class or below. So clearly its not nearly as much of a closed club as people may think. With that said its hardly perfect. We absolutely need to make that easier for people, for example free education at all levels would go a long way to help leveling the playing field.

@penny Again your arguing a topic that is not what I am asserting..

You can have evil billionaires who steal from people and generate no wealth or money. You can also have billionaires who generate significant wealth and steal from no one.

The point is only that someone having more money doesn't mean you have less. It is not a pie, when one person has more it doesn't mean some had to be taken from someone else, it could be generated wealth (and thus money).

On the topic of if the billionaire we have are generating wealth or stealing it is a valuable topic to discuss, but not something I made any assertion on.

@penny

I never claimed wealth inequality doesnt exist. Your arguing against something I never said now.

@penny Yes, but again the point your missing is that money follows wealth. Wealth can be generated, and when it is money is generated as well.

Ergo the amount of money is not fixed. People can generate wealth, and thus money.

by not finite I basically meant "it grows without bounds"

@penny being finite isnt the point, so no it isnt based on that. It is based on the fact that money and wealth are generated. The amount is finite, but it is not **fixed**, it is constantly created and destroyed.

@penny That misses the whole point.. money like wealth is generated, and as such one does not need to take from someone else to be wealthy or have money, if they generate wealth over long term the end result is generating money

@penny No money isnt finite either. Money is printed all the time and supply goes up as well as down. It tends to be on lab behind the wealth generation. As wealth is generated the value of the dollar increases, this is offset by printing more dollars. If you over print you get inflation, if you underprint you get deflation. But in the end money is no more a fixed quantity than wealth.

@gioypi Well I wouldnt say its less common as you move up the wealth scale. Its just hard to see as things become more complex. Some wealthy of course steal from others, but there is a great deal of wealth generation from large companies as well. It really just depends on the details as always.

@penny Its hardly something I accept at face value. The examples and arguments made are easily understood and it becomes common sense with even a little bit of time and understanding.

I gave specific examples in this thread already, feel free to add where you see holes in those examples.

@gioypi The number of dollars you have is not an indication of wealth. think of wealth as "how well can I live" not "how many dollars do I have in my bank".

Lets think of another example to illustrate that. this time I use an axe I own to go chop down trees and mix some concrete and I use my own man power over 20 years to build a luxury house on a mountain top. All of the wealth here is also generated. It has significantly improved my quality of living, beautiful views, luxury home, I am now "wealthy" where before I had nothing. However in doing so I have not made anyone elses home any less appealing or luxurious. Everyone quality of life other than me is exactly the same as it was before I built my home off in the woods.

So again this is an example of me generating significant wealth for myself without needing to take that wealth from anyone else. Even though having one more home in the world may have reduced the money value of everyone elses home by a few pennies they dont actually have any less wealth than they did before, because wealth is not dictated by the money value over time.

@gioypi

I am not.

I think it is best understood with an example. You have to understand going in that money is not wealth, and that money is only a small portion of what determines wealth. a person can have no money (a room full of gold bars) and still be extremely wealthy.

With that understanding in mind it is important to realize that wealth is constantly being generated and destroyed. If I buy a shovel for 5$ and go dig up 10,000$ worth of gold in my back yard with it, I have just generated 9,995$ in wealth that didnt exist before. I did not need to take wealth from anyone else to do it.

This is a simple counter example but the idea of wealth generation is in every venture we do, sometimes it is more obvious than others however.

@baschi29

No because you are operating under the assumption that wealth is like a pie, with a fixed amount and if one person has more than another has less.

Thats not how wealth works. Wealth is constantly being generated and destroyed in huge portions. One person can generate more wealth for themselves without, necessarily, taking it from anyone else.

@rholb

@georgia

Nope, not what I said. But your response is a perfect example of why I wont engage with you. You arent even capable of understand the basics of what I'm saying now, why would I want to get any deeper?

@tuxcrafting @realcaseyrollins @khird

@georgia

I have, and will continue, to explain my stance to most people. but I have no real motivation to engage rationally with a toddler in throws of a tantrum.

@tuxcrafting @realcaseyrollins @khird

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.