Show newer

@hansw@mastodon.social It doesnt matter how many times you see it, eliminating minimum wage can fail 1000 times over but as long as every time it is without the other 2 components then you can not say it is due to minimum wage

Its a bit like trying to cure an alcoholic.. if all you ever see is the fact that when they stop drinking they get sick (and perhaps die) you might believe wholeheartedly the solution is to give them more alcohol.. but even if you see 1000 alcoholics die from abruptly stopping drinking that doesnt mean your observation is valid because it ignores the whole picture. there are other elements needed for an alcoholic to succeed and without those, then yes, an alcoholic will die or get sick, but that is not an argument to solve their problem with alcohol.

Same here, you are looking at minimum wage, which causes more damage, but by itself acts as a buffer to other problems.. so its making things worse over time but looks beneficial from the perspective of anecdotal evidence removed from consideration of the whole solution. But the second you introduce an actual solution, with free education and strong welfare, and then do away with minimum age safely, then the problems you saw so many times in the past are no longer there and you find actual solutions are the result.

@hansw@mastodon.social I know thats what you meant.

My point is you only seperated out minimum wage and evaluated it seperate from the whole. Yes eliminating minimum wage while not having the other two components in place I mentioned will have things go bad... the poor wont suffer as much, but others will suffer more (the middle class and marginally skilled suffer more without minimum wage alone).

As I said you can only consider minimum wage in relation to the whole, that is, welfare, and job training, talking about things going bad when you dont have one is self-defeating when you also dont have the other two.

so yes you saw things go bad without minimum wage, but that wasnt because minimum wage wasnt there, it is because you were missing the 2 other components i said were neccesary for the solution to be fixed, you must eliminate minimum wage AND enact strong welfare and free job training and education...

If you dont have all three then you will be in a bad situation, it wont make things better. so saying that you saw bad things happen when there was no minimum wage, no welfare AND no free education... well of course, you would, but to conclude that is due solely to the lack of minimum wage is incorrect.

On the flipside if you had seen no minimum wage, but with strong welfare and free education, and things still went badly, then youd be considering the whole, and youd have a good argument that minimum wage should be part of the solution.

@hansw@mastodon.social

> I tried to explain that I see things go bad when a minimum wage is not in place.

My point is that is separating parts... you saw things go bad when minimum wage was in place.. but was there free education and a welfare system that provided ample financial support in those situations too? No... so you were separating out the minimum wage from the other two components I said were necessary.

@hansw@mastodon.social

> You know I value these discussions, otherwise I would not participate in them 🙂

I am glad, and I of course feel the same

> My point is just that I have seen enough things going bad when a minimum wage is not mandatory.

You would, but you have to be careful of falling victim to logic where you look at components in isolation and then draw conclusions about the whole.

The truth is if **all** you did was eliminate minimum wage and nothing else then you are right, things would and do go bad. Notice my solution is very careful not to do that, it doesnt just propose minimum wage be done away with but is careful to point out that it must go hand-in-hand with 1) strong welfare to support those who can afford a reasonable living wage and 2) provide free education and training to people along with the support of #1 to help ensure they get out of a welfare situation

Without points #1 adn #2 then simply eliminating welfare would be a disaster, but with points #1 and #2 then we fix the problems with welfare and replace it with something that works.

It is always important to understand the whole and not separate it out into its fundamental parts and fall into a fallacy of composition.

@FailForward

There is sadly, always going to be different of opinion on political subjects, 99% of those will be on an extremist side of the political spectrum arguing for an absolutist solution.

But the individual facts there is little doubt. and the two key ones here are that 1) while moderate increases in minimum wage does not decrease the net unemployment 2) it does shift the unemployment burden to the least skilled and most poor portion of the population at the benfit of more skilled and least poor people.

Some often use trickledown economics in its liberal form to argue for it, that by making those whoa re already well to do richer they can use that money to boost the economy and somehow help the poor or ultimately got screwed in the decision...

Frankly I find that bs and the data doesnt bear it out and needs to be pretty manipulated to support that argument.

Likewise the right is just as rediculous wanting to abolish all welfare and minimum wage all together and figure somehow it will all fix itself.

You will find very few people actually looking for a real solution that isn't at the extreme ends of propaganda on the political spectrum. The lack of suck people is the very reason we dont and arelikely not to see a solution, not in the USA, not in the EU.

@hansw@mastodon.social

@hansw@mastodon.social I have no complaints about the conversation or us disagreeing. I look at all the sides too, which is why I am not proposing a solution that lines up with anyside.. if i were right-sided id be against free education, welfare, or any real investment in a solution.. if i were left-sided id be parroting pro-minimum wage or even UBI as a wonderful solution.. instead i find a solution that considers all the sides and input.

@hansw@mastodon.social Not in the least. i never said people who are underskilled should take the underpaid jobs... Obviously what they **should** do is take the offer of free education i mentioned, become highly skilled (and get enough welfare to live well why they do it) and then take a high paid job.. no one is requried in the system i described to take a low paid job, thats not accurate at all.

what it does mean, however, is that if someone **wants** to be lazy, do a minimal effort job that takes no skill, is perfectly capable of learning a skill and can learn one for free but simply refuses to do it out of laziness, then that person at least has an option to get a low paid job if thats what they WANT, but there are other options for them.

Moreover, as we covered, when most of the people gain skills and move to high-skilled work that means there is a much smaller pool of people willing to do menial labor, that means supply demand curve **raises** their wage (as there is now higher competition to hire them) and in turn they dont make a menial wage.

Effectively my solution allows for the lowest wage to increase naturally and fairly without the consequence of everyone loosing their job.. the minimum wage solution just artificially attempts to inflate the minimum wage without effecting the supply-demand curve and the consequence of which is all the people who need jobs the most loose them.

@hansw@mastodon.social no, but minimum wage increase sures they loose BOTH jobs (thus the increase in umemployment)... thats the problem.. with low minimum wage there are enough jobs for people with no or little skills to get one, two, three jobs if they want.. raise minimum wage and now they have 0. Not helping anyone by doing that.

@hansw@mastodon.social anecdotal example.. what about the 10 people with no skills sweeping up hair that had to loose their jobs so that one hair dresser (who presumably actually has a profitable skill) can get a raise? How does that anecdote of a single hair dresser help the multiple people who are now homeless to get her that raise?

@hansw@mastodon.social But I never suggested they should take 2 jobs.I suggested the government should give them free education and help them out with welfare so they dont have to take 2 jobs and so it doesnt add pressure on them or society.

I also suggested that raising the minimum wage wouldnt do that, it would just cause them to loose both jobs (presuming they are under skilled) and be replaced with a worker of higher skill (if people were just going from 2 jobs to 1 then the chart i showed would not indicate the unemployment increase that it does).

@szopen sounds like a great use, and good luck! You are certainly welcome here. Let me know if you need anything.

@hansw@mastodon.social See the problem is your argument is just as economical as mine, except yours is based on economics that is contrary to the reality, and mine is based on the observed data...

You are arguing that minimum wage improves the economic situation and thus allows people to stay at home and care for their kids and community, thats an economic argument. But it ignores the fact that the economics directly disagree with this and that instead those people who are the poorest and the least capable of doing this are now out of a job, so it makes the reality you envision less possible, not more possible.

Mine to is based on economics and a similar vision, but based on the actual observed data. I recognize people loose their jobs that need it most when minimum wage increases, and since i want people to be happy and to be able to be at home more and take care of the family and community I do not want to see minimum wage increases that are shown to jeopardize that possibility.

@hansw@mastodon.social Again, not purely economical, but it does use the economics as a atter of fact.

We already established that minimum wage increase causes the poorest and least skilled member of a society to loose their job and be unemployed... therefore how does loosing your job and have no sense of income equate to the scenario you describe where a person is able to spend time at home educating their kids and being stress free?

You seem to be ignoring the economics, and acting like it doesnt exist and then fabricating a "human" element that is dependent on those very economics yet contrary to the facts of it.

@szopen It is permitted, though we do requre you be able to speak english or atleast willing to use a translator should a moderator need to talk to you.. If someone breaks the rules and can not understand a moderators warning that wont generally be accepted as an excuse. Otherwise, use whatever language you'd like.

@hansw@mastodon.social No its not, you are missing the point... if the person cant get a job in his current state, what in the world makes you think a higher minimum wage will get him a job? Your arguing about something that isnt related to my position or the topic.

What you are trying to do is argue that people like this should be looked after, but I never suggested they shouldnt. I merely pointed out minimum wage has no effect on accomplishing that for them.

@hansw@mastodon.social No, and you are saying this man is capable of working? by the way you describe his condition he falls into the category of people I mentioned who have a medical condition and are unable to work, is that not correct? Sounds like this example agrees with what I said doesnt disagree with it.

@hansw@mastodon.social

> but I think you underestimated the group of people who are disabled or having a health problems that does not allow them to work.

In what way either they have a health problem and cant work, or they have a health problem but can work anyway, and i therefore can learn a skill. is there some situation you can envision where someone can have a health issue, be perfectly capable of working and doing the job, but otherwise be incapable of learning a skill? I cant think of one.

@hansw@mastodon.social Yes but that isnt due to inability in most cases but unwillingness... Almost everyone, short of having some disease or medical condition is capable of learning some profitable skill, whether it is intellectual or a non-intellectual skill.

The people who remain are either disabled and cant work, have a mental illness and dont work because it overwhelms them, or are just lazy.

The first two people arent helped my minimum wage anyway, since they cant or wont work due to their illness so its a moot point.. As for the people who are explicitly lazy, thats on them and not an excuse to give them a free ride. The oppertunity is there for them when their situation causes them to be ready for it. In the meantime welfare will at least keep them in poor conditions but alive.

@Demon Oh you mean ally and friendly towards liberals.. that makes some sense.

Is the expection that they act as an ally work in both ways, you also expect your users to be an ally to the right? Again just asking not judging.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.