@sacha thats a pretty good place to be IMO.. anywhere near the middle is a good sign
> Even though I get your point on that the cost aspect is moot, I still, perhaps stubbornly and in ignorance, think it plays a factor when comparing health care between Europe and US.
Yes of course it does, but the point here is we are **not** comparing healthcare between USA and europe. I never argued "USA is better than europe".. so any effort to compare the two, while valid if that were the argument, doesnt apply here.
what I argued is that the USA system **and** the european system have both failed and neither should be emulated. So any effort to compare the two has no relevance to that discussion. Why compare them at all when we arent discussing which is better but rather why both failed?
It is clear to me both systems are an abject failure and they fail in very different ways. the USA system is a failure because of costs, and a broken welfare system that leaves many without access, this is totally value.
The european system fails because quality of care goes into the shitter when you remove competitive pressures, you get excessive wait times that result in people suffering or dying, you get violations in privacy as I mentioned, and a host of other issues.
Neither system works but if all we do is keep arguing why one failed system failed a little less than another failed system we wont get anyway. The point I am making and the point of this discussion is to point out that since both systems are failures we could and should be looking to other systems not like either of the two we are discussing here (and I already pointed out what that should be, a co-op system).
They werent out of the blue. They were from my research notes a year ago, I can find the data again if needed.
and yea the data you just linked looks pretty horrible to me, it largely agrees with the numbers I stated, surgery wait times are in many cases over a **year** thats absolutely abysmal. Having someone suffering in pain and dealing with a disease for a year longer than they need to is absolutely unacceptable.
When i look at those numbers I dont see anything that comes even close to acceptable.
> Ok. Sorry to hear that. However, that is one isolated (albeit very specific) case.
No, its not. As I pointed out aside from this being my expiernce across most of europe I am a data scientist and it is reflected strongly in the data as well.
For example Germany has the lowest wait times in europe and it is 4.8x more common to have a wait time of 2 months or more in Germany than it is in the USA. This is hardly an isolated incident.
> I would say the trend, covering health care systems at large, for larger amounts of cases, shows that the health care in the US is by FAR more costly in the US compared to most other countries
This is an entierly moot point given the scope of the discussion. My assertion was that both the USA and Europe systems suck but in different ways and that neither system is an appropriate solution overall. Therefore arguing ways that the USA sucks does not negate my argument that the european system is horrific and not to be emulated either.
The costs and other concerns about the USA system (there are plenty) are entirely valid in their own right but are not a valid argument to claim the european system is effectual. One system sucking is not an excuse for the other system sucking. The fact that both systems are horrendous is my very point, neither work and we shouldnt be adopting **either** system (remember I recommended an entirely different third option that doesnt resemble either system).
> A thing I’m missing completely in this (very interesting btw) discussion is that there seem to be a perceived binary option between either fully centralised health care, or a fully privatised one.
This is almost my point.. not only is the system not binary (centralized vs private), but its not even a spectrum or a dichotomy. There are literally more than 2 types of systems and more options than a public centralized system, or a privatized system or anything that is inbetween these two.. there are systems that have no qualities of centralization of any kind, and yet are not privatized in any way, these are the systems I promote, and they dont resemble anything in the USA or europe honestly.
@Faket interesting to hear at least some of these auto antonyms carry across linguistic lines.
Its not any one place, I've been all around the world and had health insurance in several different countries, Italy, the Netherlands, Germany, Canada, you name it.
The problems are manifold, there are the obvious things that dont need much proving like effects it has on privacy that is inherent to a centralized system. In canada for example your complete medication history is in a central database which makes it impossible to keep your medical history truly private and secure, particularly if you take meds that are either controlled substances (like for ADHD) or for things like schizofrenia.
But the more damning stuff is the stuff that requires a real analysis of the data to see.I think the prime example, and one that is very obvious in the data but also something I personally expiernced is the delays you see in time to get care which are horrendous throughout the whole of europe.
The Netherlands has some of the shortest wait times of any country in europe and you are still talking on the order of months on average, even for debilitating conditions where immediate care is critical to patient health, the USA (particularly before ObamaCare, but even after) is a fraction of that time on average. This is also what effected me personally when i had a spinal cord injury while living in the Netherlands. I had a non-surgical solution that was working quite well for me that was essentially a 5 minute procedure about one a month where they inject steroids into my spine. But because they can only schedulet he procedure once the pain starts coming back, and because the procedure took about 2 months in advance to schedule (despite taking all of 5 minutes to do) it means I'd be 1 month where I was perfectly fine and 2 months where i was crippled and in agonizing pain. So I was forced to get a surgical procedure that was far riskier that I didnt really need simply because the system was too broken to give me my treatment on time and in a timely fashion.
@Faket no
@Faket it is slightly varied from the one I took it looks like.
@freemo We are a tad different, you and I 😜
What test did you use for the other pictures? I would like to take a look at those.
@Faket the "left values" one looks like an interesting new twist!
@mur2501 Nah, people thing that because I give liberals shit for how they act... thing is in terms of policy and principles I agree with the liberal stance a bit more than the conservative stance. I just happen to despise the way the liberals **behave** (exaggerations, lieing, manipulating , arguing complete fantasies).
The spectrum doesnt account for how much you like the people on one side or the other, it only measures your values.
@realcaseyrollins About where I'd expect you, maybe a smidge more right but not much.
Didnt find the video (only spent about 2 minutes looking thought before work).. but here you can hear them talk about the leak in some detail and reference the video i mentioned in detail:
keep in mind co-ops are neither privatized or public, not in the typical sense... they are customer owned entities, so the people being insured by any particular co-op are the owners of that co-op. So you get supply demand pressures but eliminate the greed aspect
@herag i took these a year ago, i dont recall the specific test
if you have a public option that means people are forced to pay for it if they use it or not, so no, there should not be a public option of any kind.. there **should** be welfare that provides the welfare recpients with a budget they can use to buy the health insurance of their choosing to ensure those who cant afford it can still get health insurance. But no public health insurane is a utter failure by its very nature and should not be an option. If i dont want to use the public option istill have to pay taxes on it, so your basically telling people "you have to buy our insurance, but your free to not use it", that doesnt work.
As someone who lived in the USA, as well as many other countries with public health care, as well as a data scientist who spent a lot of time researching it I can say pretty confidently that the last thing you should want is public health care.. not that what we have is ideal either, it needs to be fixed too, but the healthcare they have in canada and europe is pretty horrific and not really a step forward
The thing is, once you create a state run monopoly and eliminate choice and flexibility, quality goes down as there is no market pressure. healthcare doesnt work as a completely public system, but it also doesnt work as a completely free market privatized system either.. IMO the solutions for healthcare lie in co-op healthcare.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE