Show newer

@koherecoWatchdog

Its not about "a company must not refuse any business"... my claim is that people shipping packages have a right to privacy as to what they are shipping. In my view it is unethical for a shipping company to feel they have a right to snoop through my packages in the first place unless they suspect there is something dangerous.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

Your welcome to use as much power as you'd like. But by the looks of it (by pushing for a ban on FedEx on those grounds) your causing more ethical issues than your solving from my PoV.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

I'm not saying its a good way to boycott, but i am showing the failure in your assertion that you cant effect laws in countries you have no voting power, which isnt true.

The other point is, boycotting fedex wont do a damn thing to prevent shark fin import anyway. They arent hurt in anyway to have to use different companies for their shipping, or even to need to provide their own distribution as is quite common. Its wasted energy that wont get you any closer to solving the problem anyway.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

How so? I am still saying they are in the wrong if they didnt ship shark fins (assuming they were legal to ship).

"in the wrong" = unethical, and I stand by that..

They have a **right** (they legally can do so) not to ship them, but they are **in the wrong** (it is unethical) not to do so

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

I disagree.. it is not their place for many reasons..

When something is made illegal by law there are proper provisions put in place. For example sharks that are butchered for all their meat, including their fins would be perfectly legal to ship the fins. Similarly farm raised sharks one would expect to be legal even if wild shark fin hunting were illegal.

Therefore if made illegal the government would go through many steps to prosecute someone, they would have to verify the finning was done unethical (as opposed to the ethical sources above) among other things.

FedEx does not have the resources nor should be expected to go off investigating the source of the fins, deciding if they were sustainably harvested, or even what is or is not considered sustainable and ok.

So no, that is not where the solution lies, nor should it, and its absurd to think they should play the role of a police officer and investigate the supply chain and ethics of the things they ship, it is not their place nor should it be.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

Of course they have a right to do it. But as you already pointed out simply having the right to do a thing doesnt make it ethical to do it. It is, in my view, unethical for fedex to play that role regardless of if they have the legal right to do so or not.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

I found a little kitten, please Fediverse guide me on how to handle him, what to feed him, etc :ablobcatcry:

@mur2501 feed him cat food, if you lack that some unspiced ground meat, chicken, beef, whatever works great in a pinch. Remember cats dont do well with veggies and carbs so unlike with dogs (where youd add some rice) I wouldnt do that for a cat.

@thenewoil

I'm not sure i see it as a paradox because in both cases I am encouraging people to place ethics first, and customer demand second.

@koherecoWatchdog @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

You can effect laws without voting rights.. refuse to buy anything from the country until they ban shark finning, if enough people do that it would put pressure on them changing their laws.

You can also seek to ban the import of shark fins in your local country, which will go a long way to reducing it.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

> this presumes complete alignment with law and ethics

No it doesnt. What it does presume (as I already pointed out) is that when the law and ethics are not in alignment the correct way to address that is by putting pressure on governments to change their laws, not by requiring FedEx to take the roll of a government and legal system by determining for themselves what they will deem appropriate or not.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@thenewoil

Depends, much as with the other issue there is the ethical side, and there is the popular demand side.

In my view it would be unethical for fedex to inspect contents of packages outside of legal obligations.

On the other hand the general population might demand Fedex inspect such packages and reject shark fin packages, therefore showing demand for them to do something unethical.

In the other case we were talking about providing a service of overnight shipping, which I wouldnt say is a huge ethical issue.

@koherecoWatchdog @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

Sure, I agree. But FedEx are not the ones doing wrong in my view. In fact to ban shipping items that are otherwise legal to ship would be fedex engaging in wrong doing in my view...

So yea by all means boycott shark fins, ill support you, but do it where you should be, at the consumer level and at the government level. Its not the place of a package shipper to do that sort of level of investigation or enforcement.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

No I am implying that it **should** be illegal, and enforced. It is not FedEx's place to create their own set of "laws" they enforce seperate from the countries being shipped from. If its legal to hunt shark fins in a country then fedex should be ok shipping it.. if we feel sharkfins should be protected (and I would support that) you should be fighting for that at the governement level not fedex.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

The onus in that case is on the 3rd world country to step up and make it illegal, not on FedEx, thats not their purview nor should it be.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

No, I envision that any enforcement would come down to the local government. Yes they will fail to enforce it sometime and stuff will get through, but that is no excuse to violate what I view as privacy rights.

That said a blanked ban on all trophy hunting is itself counter productive. While we obviously want to eliminate poaching of animals illegally there is legal trophy hunting which is ultimately beneficial to the species. Distinguishing between the two would not be practical for any shipping company and indeed that is what we see where companies that have banned shipping of animals as the result of a trophy hunt do so blindly to the nuance (whether it was actual poaching or not).

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

While I am against trophy hunting I also dont feel that is the place or the right of the shipping company to get involved in. In fact in my view there should be legal protection and privacy over the content of my package.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@thenewoil

Well when we talk about things negatively impacting my life, at least things I am made aware of, amazon has generally done a better job than many mom and pop stores. At least when it comes to online shopping (the in person expiernce i think is where mom and pop stores can shine sometimes).

I cant tell you how many times i ordered something from a mom and pop sized store and they didnt check their emails for a week before i even found out they had to cancel my order. A lot of times this has caused some serious repercussions for me as delays in my orders often result in delays in my projects.

So if we are really going to talk about fallout from my decision to use Amazon I'd say the fallout i expiernced from dealing with smaller shops over the years is pretty much which drove me to amazon in the first place. Way less hassle, I get my stuff quick and on time, and very rarely do things just fall between the cracks.

@koherecoWatchdog @realcaseyrollins

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.