Show newer

@meowski

Well I already have some data points to answer that based on how you conduct yourself in this and other threads. I also get some insight by the way you answered my question about if you did a write up.

Obviously i wont waste my time on your whole timeline but if you have specific posts you've made where you show yourself changing your mind and incorporating new opposing ideas into your own then please, by all means, share it, I will read.

@icedquinn @thatbrickster @allison

@meowski

Its not about convincing people like me.. Its a question of your own character.. Are you dogmatic and stuborn and just make shit up with little rigor, dont seek out counter-opinions and integrate them... and thus never really develop a meaningful opinion on things... or... are you constantly improving your opinions and integrating new information without reliance on confirmation bias and ego...

Which of those two characters you happen to have makes all the difference.

@icedquinn @thatbrickster @allison

@coyote

Ok.. funny its almost as if I dont care about the opinion of a emotionally constantly triggered sewer rat... who woulda thunk.

@thatbrickster @allison @icedquinn @meowski

@meowski

Exactly. you never made a clear well written case, nor did you make it public so anyone could critique it... you basically made some spitballed uneducated back of a napkin numbers that were wrong and called it a day... sorry but that has very little value if your trying to convince anyone to think you have a leg to stand on. Even if you are right you have to articulate to convince people.

@icedquinn @thatbrickster @allison

@coyote

I didnt ignore his first points, I did misunderstand them. It only took a few messages before he pointed out what he meant and I apologized and said he was right.

Just gonna ignore that part huh? And you wonder why i devalued your contribution to discussions.

@thatbrickster @allison @icedquinn @meowski

@meowski

Like i said, the value is an approximate so you will see higher and lower numbers, so I dont doubt youll find some 30% figures. But even as you point out, thats on the fringe high end of estimates.

And yea your perfectly find in saying that coronavirus class viruses (unrelated to THE coronavirus however) causes a minority of cold cases. Though as I pointed out the Rhinovirus class is the most common cause of colds at 30% - 80%.

@icedquinn

@meowski

No I asked for nothing of the kind, and specifically chose my words to make that clear... I asked for a written paper, one that is open to criticism. I do not care if its published in a journal or a blog.

@icedquinn @thatbrickster @allison

@IAmAWarCrime

No worries, I didnt take it as an attack. I side with your sentiments, just pointing out studies cost money to make so someone has to pay for it somehow.

@icedquinn @meowski @allison @thatbrickster

@meowski

You might be able to find some studies out there that would estimate closer to 30%, there is certainly some variability in the numbers.. But no, 15% is the most commonly cited figure.

Here are two different sources bot of which confirm the 15% figure I cited:

Pelczar MJ, Chan EC, Noel RK (2010). Microbiology: Application Based Approach. p. 656. ISBN 978-0-07-015147-5. Archived from the original on 16 May 2016.

La Fayette Cecil R, Goldman L, Schafer AI (2012). Goldman's Cecil Medicine, Expert Consult Premium Edition (24 ed.). Elsevier Health Sciences. p. 2103. ISBN 978-1-4377-1604-7. Archived from the original on 4 May 2016.

@icedquinn

@coyote

Not ignoring your attempts at discussion. Though i do know from past discussion you are incapable of being level headed and mature. So I put less value in engaging you to some degree for sure.

@allison @thatbrickster @icedquinn @meowski

@IAmAWarCrime

The aggregator isnt the one getting 100% of that money. They have to pay back to the journal, which has to pay its peer-reviewers, editors, and authors.

@icedquinn @meowski @allison @thatbrickster

@meowski

"appeals to authority".. nothing i just said implies any authority.. you should really learn what that means.

@icedquinn @thatbrickster @allison

@meowski

Can you show me the paper you wrote that demonstrates those numbers and what criticisms it has drawn from others who had a chance to review your theories?

@icedquinn @thatbrickster @allison

@coyote

Which goal posts did I set exactly? I dont recall ever stating anything about eradication.

@allison @thatbrickster @icedquinn @meowski

@meowski

its not meaningless, it just serves a different purpose that transmissibility.

Being effective against symptoms means you probably wont die and getting the virus will be non consequential. If the vast majority of people are all vaccinated that means having the vaccine will significantly reduce death rates even if it doesn't reduce transmissibility.

If you want to study the vaccines ability to reduce transmissibility that is a different measure and useful in different ways. Namely, if measuring the likelihood of eradication, which would be nice, but not entirely necessary to see some level of success.

@icedquinn @thatbrickster @allison

@IAmAWarCrime

True but they have to pay for their overhead costs somehow. Want to see more open-access papers, push for more tax-payer funded research (which often means open-access).

Usually the people complaining about paywalls are the same people who think scientific studies should be privately funded.

@icedquinn @meowski @allison @thatbrickster

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.