Show newer

@Oblivia

In that case you have a person defering to an expert. They dont understand the surgery or its technicals in any sense, they simply trust the risk assesment and details given to them by a professional. No different than with vaccines really, a person typically wont understand the subject, but they can defer to their doctors risk assesment and side effects and other details to make an informed decision despite not understanding the subject.

@Eris

@Eris

Yes it results in mass murder. No I am not ok with it. Not being ok with it does not mean I think it should be against the law though. The law should not reflect morality as far as I'm concerned.

@Oblivia

@Oblivia

Right, as I said I really couldnt care less if the people the meme calls out take me seriously or not. They arent really worth the effort. I prefer to debate with people who are capable of learning and changing views.

@Eris

@Eris

Agreed. I do not expect nor claim to have made any sort of argument to suggest I should be trusted here. I more than happy to just point out the stupidity and move on.

@Oblivia

@Eris

I didnt mean to suggest that spreading misinformation about vaccinations due to ignorance should or is illegal.

@swiley

@Oblivia

A person doesnt know how to do heart surgery, yet can give informed conscent to have surgery.

@Eris

@Eris

Nah, I've put in high effort responses dozens of times int he past. Some were with people it was a waste of time with. Some actually had enough knowledge and understanding for it to be worthwhile.

@Oblivia

@Eris

Only partly overthrown. The supereme courts comment on overthrowing the case was clear:

"the constitutional guarantees of free speech and free press do not permit a State to forbid or proscribe advocacy of the use of force or of law violation except where such advocacy is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action [e.g., a riot] and is likely to incite or produce such action."

@swiley

@Oblivia

You seem to be confusing "an open invitation" with.. "something likely to provoke responses".. not the same thing. I have no issue putting in the low effort of calling someone an idiot if they decide to respond anyway (which is expected).. takes no time out of my day.

@Eris

@Eris

No quite the opposite. The case which references screaming fire in a theater (which was actually about distributing flyers with misinformation on it) specifically stated that screaming fire in a theater would be against the law as an example of why the case being tried found the individual guilty.

Here is an exact quote from the Judge (Holmes) remarking on this very thing:

The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic.... The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent.

@swiley

@Eris

You dont need to understand a topic to discuss it, no. But you look like an idiot, and are an idiot, if you assert things as facts on a subject you dont understand.

@Oblivia

@Telvannichad

When did I ever say that. I have been vocal and against the government forcing vaccinations.

@Eris

@Oblivia

I didnt invite further discussion. Quite the opposite. The OP shows the basic level of knowledge a person needs to have before even approaching the subject, of which most anti-vaxers dont have. So it explicitly suggests people unable to pass the test DONT discuss it, the opposite of inviting it.

@Eris

@Eris

If you lie and scream fire in a theater and someone gets trampled and dies, you go to jail and/or get sued. No you dont have the right to say whatever you want.

@swiley

@Eris I've addressed this topic in detail dozens of times on my time line. Every time the anti-vax morons just spew nonsense and ignore or arent smart enough to comprehend the reality. So yes at this point I stopped putting int he effort because its a waste of my time.

@Eris Thanks for proving my point, that people too stupid to pass the above test will also be too stupid to assert actual facts correctly.

@Eris You dont. But you do need to understand a topic if you expect to state facts about said topic.

@Alex1488 Dont blame me you got called out for not even being able to pass the entry level exam needed to know the absolute basics of a subject you claim to be informed about.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.