Show newer

@realcaseyrollins

Yes your tolerance and understanding is why I respect you.

Who is your sister exactly?

@adidal @Marbleturtle

@zleap

Yea if 100% of the excessive tax on alcohol went to treat alcoholism then I would absolutely support this.

@mathlover @iankenway

@zleap

To your other point about wealth concentration. I think thats a bit of a misnomer. The way you describe it seems to view wealth as a fixed quantity whereby if one person has too much there isnt enough for others. In fact wealth is not at all a fixed quantity and it is generate in large quantities, and tends to be generated whenever wealth itself moves around or even accumulates.

If a market is truely a healthy version of capitalism then having extremely rich people who own large amounts of wealth in fact would garuntee that large amounts of new wealth are created and owned by the masses, and ultimately this creates a healthy standard of living.

Now that said the USA is **not** a healthy capitalism, so having rich people int he USA doesnt always lead to the level of public wealth generation it ought to in a proper capitalism. But even int he USA this is generally true, the wealthy people generate massive quantities of new wealth for the general populace.

Its a simple concept to understand.. most rich people invest almost all their wealth. If you invest in things that are successful then you are generating new wealth for the businesses and share holders of these new companies. If you are rich you are probably very good at successfully investing. Ergo rich people having control over the majority of the money to invest insures we have new successful companies that represent newly generated wealth in large quantities. In turn that means every little old lady and worker with a 401K is making good money on a healthy economy with a lot of wealth growth.

@mathlover @iankenway

@Pat In technical terms we would call those public utilities or or simply "the commons". And yes a capitalism doesnt really address those in and of itself. Commons are a good example of why an ideological pure capitalism where there is no regulation of any meaningful kind doesnt work. Capitalism is a fine idea for 90% of the stuff we deal with but things like public commons are precisely where you need something more than capitalism to address it.

@vulgate No as covered already that is not the definition of capitalism, it is only part of it. Capitalism defines both the private ownership of wealth as well as the private control of the trade (as in the people engaging in trade are free to make their own terms)

In and of itself it neither leads to corruption or greed, or even exploitation. In fact, should you have exploitation then by definition it ceases to be a capitalism since that would mean the markets are no longer free.

@zleap

That one seems like a hairy one to me. On the one hand alcohol is a bit of a luxury so I get taxing it more than, say, a glass of club soda which is ultimately healthy and you need hydration.

At the same time i suspect the tax here is specifically intended to discourage people from drinking, a sort of punishment tax like we do with gasoline. I'm not so keen on that approach except where the tax is on something harmful. Like with gasoline I'm ok with it because gasoline causes harm and the tax money can be used to repair the damage (though sadly it rarely is but thats another issue)... but drinking alcohol, at least in moderation, is not something that strikes me as something that causes much harm (Again when not abused).

@mathlover @iankenway

@zleap

A company need not give the opportunity to move up if the world you live in is designed in such a way that you have good opportunity to start your own company that can compete with large companies well. In fact what youll find is that the easier it is for a worker to go off and start their own competing business the more it is in the best interest of large companies to provide career advancement opportunities in the first place, otherwise they loose their best workers and drive competition growth.

@mathlover @iankenway

@zleap

"its not about"... lets be careful here. There is what capitalism is about, and ther eis what the ideal form of government is about.

In a true capitalism you wouldnt have progressive taxes. A market isnt free if your penalized for using it successfully. So yes wealth tax is anti-capitalism.

That said a government should not be an ideologically pure capitalism either. While I do beleive capitalism should be a central tenant and most things operate with the intention of creating free markets, there are exceptions to this. A good government in my mind should be mostly capitalistic with a few exceptions.

For me I am a large promoter of a flat income tax (that means no wealth tax) and to shift most of our taxes to sales tax, particularly where luxury items have higher taxes than necessities. The sales tax therefore is still sort of a flat tax in that it isnt effected by your income, but it does mean that people who waste more money on luxuries rather than investments will pay more. Its not exactly capitalism since it discourages luxury purchases and thus not entierly free market. But does lean towards capitalism strongly and I think finds the proper balance.

@mathlover @iankenway

@mathlover

I would argue a wealth tax is directly contrary to healthy capitalism or capitalism at all. It penalizes anyone who makes money, thats the opposite of a free market where making or loosing money is considered natural and desirable for the population.

@iankenway

@raucao I wouldnt use that wording.. A pure form of capitalism has never been tried. just as a pure form of communism has never been tried. Pure forms of anything tend to not exist, nor would we want them to, ideological purity without situational awareness would be devastating.

That said communism as a central tenant of governments has been quite common just as capitalism as a central tenant has been common. If we want to pick apart why governments fail or succeed we would have to look far beyond simplifications of a single attribute like capitalism or communism.

@Pat depends. If it is enforced by a government then it clearly is an anti-capitalist property. If however it is more like a commune where private owners voluntarily pool their resources then that is perfectly within capitalism.

By the way, while I feel capitalism as a property serves the vast majority of use cases I do not feel a pure and absolute capitalism in every regard is necceseraly the ideal.

Capitalism is the existence of free markets. Free markets work great if and only if there is an inherent and reasonable equilibrium point which can be reached by supply and demand. While this works great for most things there are cases where supply-demand breaks down and capitalism doesnt work well. Healthcare I think is a good example of that. A person will pay every penny they have to live just one day longer in most cases. The demand is infinite and the supply finite. Capitalism fails under such a market.

@Marbleturtle

Since when is being weird a bad thing? Its being normal you should be worried about.

@realcaseyrollins @adidal

@raucao No thats not correct. Capitalism is not simply private property. Capitalism is where **trade**, industry **and** property are controlled by private ownership. The trade part is essential here and ultimately is why free market is baked into the definition of capitalism.

@noelle Most humans have a below average number of skulls inside their bodies at any given time.

@Palanix Without further detail all I can say is that if after robots it remains a capitalism then the above properties of capitalism must remain true. If they are not true then that simply means the introduction of robots, and how the governement responded to it, caused the society to cease being a capitalism.

@Palanix That would depend on countless circumstances. What government is controlling this scenario? What laws does it have in place? How easy is it to make a robot? Do the robots think? etc. There is a lot of detail I'd need to know about this scenario to speculate on how it might play out.

@raucao free markets (that is markets defined by private trade without price fixing) is effectively the definition of capitalism.

State capitalism does not lead to greed or any of the other negative effects... The **state** leads to that. generally because the state suggests centralized control and power and that is contrary to free markets which is where the state has little or no control, which states dont want. So when capitalism exists it is often erroded by the state. So state anything often leads to a lack of free market and thus a lack of capitalism.

@ScumbagDog Your dad sounds like a wise and brilliant man. Not to mention devilishly handsome.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.