CW Religion, discussion of souls, questions for Christians from an atheist
I had a thought about the soul when I was out on my walk this morning and now I have some serious questions for #Christians.
There seem to be a lot of contradictions floating around in descriptions of what a soul is, who/what has one, when they get it, and why abortion is bad. I don't mean this as ridicule - this is a challenge to those who would force religious-based policy on the general population to offer a strong justification for their doctrine.
To keep it simple, this is directed *only* at those who believe all human beings have a soul.
• *What* is a soul? I have my own idea, and I looked at Wikipedia to get another perspective, now I'm coming to you for your interpretation. A decent definition is essential before considering the following questions.
• If a soul is instilled at conception, do identical twins share a soul? Or does God stick two in there, because he already knows the fertilized egg will become twins?
• Does God put a soul into every fertilized egg, including those that will only last for a few cell divisions before miscarriage? Do frozen embryos have a soul? (A *lot* of IVF clinics in states where abortion has been criminalized are really interested in knowing the legal view on this)
(I’m going for edge-case scenarios, as the regular situation of a person being conceived and then born without complications seems pretty clear-cut... for now)
A few hashtags for the discussion: #Religion #Soul #Abortion #ProLife #ProChoice
CW Religion, discussion of souls, questions for Christians from an atheist
@MichaelPorter A corollary to your question about twins would be whether someone who is a (genetic) chimera has two souls.
CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.
CW Religion, discussion of souls, questions for Christians from an atheist
@internic Ah yes - If a zygote has a soul, then two zygotes merging should have two.
My initial reaction was to object because a chimeric liver wouldn’t be conscious (“Or would it?” chime in the panpsychists…), but then if the soul is instilled at conception, neither is a fertilized egg.
Maybe that’s why so many prayers go unanswered… God is too busy with edge case soul scenarios 😄