Follow

OK, I upgraded to the latest Signal and it still works as an SMS client.

Kind of a twist of the knife that they are also prominently pushing "stories" in this update, which.... does not seem like it was any sort of user-requested feature.

Paul Ganssle  
#Signal users on #Android, anyone have a suggestion for a decent replacement SMS client? Looks like I am going to have to upgrade the app soon. 🙁

@pganssle
I'd rather keep sms than any 'features' developed.

There's an old passage somewhere that says something along the lines of 'The most efficient tools do only one thing- and one thing very well.'

I'm not using signal to post facebook status or to submit git patches via mms. All I want is simple, safe, secure communication. Emojis can be added after.

@lucifargundam Yeah. I understand where they are coming from — ironically, I'm complaining about this in between drafts of a blog post about how sometimes you should deliberately choose to *not* implement features that people want if a sufficiently high percentage of people will use those features wrong. That's basically the whole justification for removing SMS, so you'd think I'd be in support of it, except:

1. I think SMS support was actually a core feature of Signal and they should probably lean in to UX design to minimize any potential harm rather than give up on it

2. In the same blog post I suggest that when you have a feature that some people might use correctly but a larger fraction of people might use incorrectly, you should probably still include the feature, but just make it *more difficult*. In this case adding a setting like, "Enable SMS even though it's insecure" would really help.

@pganssle sms still disabled for me on 6.2.4 (latest on Android)

@hobs @pganssle
On a side note, once(if at all) getting sms to work- test out its integrity/consistency by trying to get SMS via many varying scenarios (eg. Generated sent via webserver, mobile to mobile, etc.)

@pganssle Luckily you can disable stories in the settings. First thing I did.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.