my waves professor is so funny
someone asked him why the models we use only work for small amplitudes and he said
"well, i'll demonstrate!"

then he started slowy sliding a tub of water back and forth harder and harder until it spilled all over the desk and on his clothes

"uh oh!!!!
... does that answer your question"

Follow

@imyxh Eh, that's somewhat misleading. There are things that break way earlier than at such a discontinuous transition: things become nonlinear (e.g. the pendulum's period being independent of amplitude is only true in small amplitudes).

@robryk I believe you missed the joke, it's not "discontinuous transition", but "my clothes would get wet". :P @imyxh

@timorl Well, but that's a consequence of the discontinuity. I wanted to say that things break down way earlier than that (for waves in a container, when they're a nontrivial fraction of the water depth the things are way past breaking down). @imyxh

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.