Interesting fact of the day: The first words spoken on the moon was "That's one small step for _A_ man, one giant leap for man kind". However due to a misinterpretation he has always been consistently misquoted as saying "..one small step for man..."

@freemo What misinterpretation? I feel like the quote has always been interpreted as meaning "one small step for A man", since if you leave out the "a" the whole phrase doesn't make sense (since "man" and "mankind" are synonyms).

I thought that the main controversy was whether he misspoke (i.e. forgot to say "a"), the "a" was lost in static or possibly that in his accent "for a man" runs together and the "a" gets elided.

Someone (Peter Ford Shannon) wrote a paper about it, arguing that he indeed say "a"; the PDF is here: web.archive.org/web/2006112307

I'm not terribly convinced by the waveforms he shows, but it definitely feels plausible that the "a" gets elided when you say that phrase; without explicitly trying to enunciate the syllables, "for man" and "for a man" come out as sounding very similar when I try it.

@valleyforge @freemo They did, and he did mean to say "a", but I don't think that was ever the question.

I think the question was always whether he accidentally said "for man", flubbing his line.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.