A decent article on why the US has only two major parties. However, it left out the People's Party of the 1890s. A left-wing party, its platform foreshadowed both Progressive-era reforms and FDR's New Deal. The People's Party was very successful in the West and South and, during the 1890s, elected 1 to 5 US senators; 7 to 22 House members; and controlled many state legislatures.

In the right conditions, 3rd parties can succeed.

#USPolitics #Parties #PeoplesParty

washingtonpost.com/news/the-fi

@sarahc The US needs to move to real proportional representation: one person, one vote that actually counts.

@shakespearenut

@sarahc the downside to that is a lack of representation of different groups with diverse interests, different communities with different needs, and lack of respect for regional differences around the large country.

Everything involving US election methods revolves around balancing competing and valid interests, even setting aside corrupt issues.

@volkris @shakespearenut I don't agree. Proportional representation in a house with several hundred members would make it far more likely that regional or interest-based parties would have representation, since seats would be allotted on the basis of % of the national vote.

@sarahc regions are more likely represented when seats are allocated on the basis of region :)

@volkris It really depends on how you define what a 'region' is. And how do you compensate for the fact that regions are not the same size in terms of population?

Follow

@sarahc

Yep! You put your finger on it.
The defining of regions is a very complex topic that has to weigh so many factors, so we end up spending a lot of time and energy doing our best to do it as well as we can.

It's very subjective, based on subjective valuations.

BUT we've decided that representing diverse regions, communities, and interest groups is important enough that we accept that cost.

There's room for people to disagree about the value of doing this, but for my taste I'm a big supporter of it, as I really like to have that national diversity represented in our legislative institutions.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.