Kevin McCarthy and the GOP's plan to raise taxes on the elderly Americans who put them into office is one of the greatest political betrayals in this nation's history. (Oh, and a 30% freakin' sales tax also screws the rest of us too.)

#goptaxbomb #republicantaxbomb #republicans #gop #gqp #kevinmccarthy #mccarthy #house #shutdown #governmentshutdown #biden #joebiden #democrats #politics #uspol #uspolitics #news

@stopgopfox

If this is a reference to the FairTax, since I see that popping up today, the plan would write the poor checks to offset the tax burdens.

The FairTax was specifically designed to be progressive, to make sure it this payment prevents it from hitting the economically vulnerable.

@volkris Below is a sampling of what's being said about the FairTax. Let me know any places from the article where you disagree, as it seems the tax will still target working class and middle class families (and the elderly) while aiding the rich:

" 'It is regressive, more complex than its sponsors claim, and likely would reduce federal revenues,' the Tax Policy Center wrote."

ajc.com/politics/opinion-biden

Follow

@stopgopfox

I'd reference this website.

They literally wrote the book outlining the plan. I have a copy of the actual book around here somewhere. I probably picked it up decades ago.

For example:
> "In contrast, the FairTax dramatically improves economic growth and wage rates for all, but especially for lower-income families and individuals. In addition to receiving the monthly FairTax prebate, these taxpayers are freed from regressive payroll taxes, the federal income tax, and the compliance burdens associated with each. They pay no more business taxes hidden in the price of goods and services, and used goods are tax free."

fairtax.org/faq

@volkris Thanks for the link. It seems fair to take quotes from there as well from those analyzing the plan. My biggest question about this dramatic shift though, is who ultimately pays *more* to make up the difference for lower-income families paying less? This money has to come from somewhere, even if there are some cuts to programs nationally.

@stopgopfox @volkris

Sales taxes catastrophically drop consumer spending & trigger recessions.

It will eradicate conservatives in elections for over a decade. It's a tax grab.

It taxes services, the one bright spot in the US trade balance & makes it less globally competitive .

Implementation increases costs (software, paperwork).

It's *always* regressive no matter how the tax credits/rebates are finagled.

The main purpose of a VAT (Value Added Tax) is to allow the 1% to evade taxation.

@Npars01 @stopgopfox You know what else drops consumer spending and increases costs? Not having money in the first place, compliance with income taxes.

Taxes in any form have the effect you're talking about. There's no way around that. So long as government is needing to be funded it will take a bite out of private sector activity.

The FairTax has advantages over income taxes, and that's what it should be compared against. Not no taxes at all, because that's not an optional on the table.

@volkris @stopgopfox

The tax grab proposed by the GOP is *not* better than an income tax.

The wealthiest simply don't want to pay taxes at all and devise ways to orchestrate things so they don't have to pay.

If the wealthiest 1% hadn't gotten the Trump tax cuts, there wouldn't be a massive hole in revenue

The wealthiest aren't taxed on their income. Why is $1000 in income from dividends treated differently than $1000 from paid employment?

The government can be funded by taxing the rich

@stopgopfox

Everything I've heard from FairTax proponents is that they do not propose any cuts to programs nationally. They aren't getting into the issue of spending restraint. They want to raise the same amount of money, just to do it a more effective, efficient, and fair way.

Today we have a ton of elements of the income tax that try to tax wealthy people more and poor people less. Poor people get everything from the standard deduction through earned income tax credit. So the FairTax plan wants to echo that sort of progressive policy, but just do it in a more effective way.

So the rich guy buying a Ferrari will pay more so that the poor person doesn't have to pay taxes on their food for the week.

@volkris @stopgopfox
From the front page:
"The IRS is being weaponized ...
And their target is YOU."

The only target of the better resourced IRS is millionaire & billionaire tax cheats.
The tax code certainly needs changes to restore it as a truly progressive method for funding the US government.
Eliminating the IRS & expecting state governments to collect & remit a national 30% sales tax, which IS the GOP proposal is a massive redistribution of wealth to the oligarchs.

@joeinwynnewood @stopgopfox

It comes across as rather naive to say that the IRS only goes after tax cheats, akin to saying the cops only arrest guilty people.

No, it's no secret that the IRS audits people from all walks of life, and heck, it's easier for them to go after folks who aren't so well off because their finances are easier to audit AND they have less resources with which to fight even erroneous claims against them.

As for redistribution, the FairTax proposal is built around regular payments covering the cost of taxation on necessities, which is the opposite, a redistribution of wealth away from the wealthy to the poor.

Too often I see people failing to mention that core pillar of the plan.

@volkris @stopgopfox

It's disingenuous to argue against what I didn't say, underlining the bottom line fact, FairTax is a massive wealth transfer to the richest of the rich. No amount of buffer for the bottom of the pile will change that.

Eliminating the IRS doesn't fix problems with tax enforcement. More resources so the IRS can go after wealthy tax cheats, as recently done, fixes problems with tax enforcement.

Fairtax.org shouts a great big lie on its home page obliterating everything else.

@joeinwynnewood @stopgopfox

How exactly do you see a program that actively transfers wealth from rich to poor as being a massive wealth transfer to the richest of the rich?

I really don't understand how you can get to your conclusion from what's in front of us.

@volkris @stopgopfox The math isn't overly hard. A middle class person spends a very significant portion of their income on goods and services. They will therefore pay a 30% tax on 90% of their income, give or take, a 27% effective federal tax rate.
The top marginal rate for a married couple with taxable income up to $178k (gross income over $200k) is 22% with an effective rate well below that.
Add in payroll taxes of 7.65%, and at best about the same, though 6.2% of that is only on the /1

@volkris @stopgopfox first $147k of income.
How about someone making several $M? What % of of their income will they spend on goods and services? 10%? 20%? 30%? Let's go with 30%. 30% on 30% of their income is a 9% effective tax rate; current top marginal income tax rate? 37% on everything over $648K.
Sure, they'll hide what they can, but only the wealthiest of the wealthy can cut their effective rate below 15%.
It's VERY clear that the top 1% will reap a huge windfall /2

@volkris @stopgopfox while everyone else will either pay to make up the difference or go without the services the missing tax $ pay for, like Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid.
And that doesn't even take into account corporate taxes. No IRS, no corporate taxes either... /e

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.