Being new to the Fediverse can be a scary place when it comes to the management of time.
New users of Mastodon ask me if that's enough. Should they also be on Pixelfed or micro.blog, too?
I ask if they ever used Facebook, Twitter and Instagram at the same time. If they do, or did, then the same proves true, here.
Be ubiquitous! Create in many spaces! Your micro.blog posts can be sent to Mastodon, as can your Pixelfed posts.
Be everywhere. Let your thoughts infect, and influence, everything.
@david I'd be more cautious -- each one of those platforms you mention is both a tech stack with its own features, as well as a specific circle of humans you expect to reach with your posts. Mastodon has the right mix of features to switch my Twitter peeps over, but the people connected to my FB and Insta are much less adventurous -- AND the #Fediverse tools to replace those are not quite at feature parity yet - #NSFNormals. Worst case: You post all over the Fedi and nobody's listening! #YMMV
FWIW, I hate to see people having to create multiple identities as a bit of a hurdle to engage with #Fediverse in those different ways.
If I want my Fediverse identity to post both a microblogging message and Pixelfed type content, it stinks to have to wrangle between split identities instead of having it all tied to one.
I BELIEVE #ActivityPub has the capability to support single identities across services, though I don't know if it's ever really been implemented.
But I really hope development of programs like #Mastodon go in that direction so that someday, sooner rather than later, a person can present a single identity that crosses between services.
There are various discussions going on about this subject at #SocialHub, the #ActivityPub developer community.
I highly recommend checking that out, and participating in the discussions.
SocialHub is the discussion forum for Fediverse Enhancement Proposals or #FEP's and this topic is ideal candidate.
@smallcircles @tedcurran @volkris
Thanks for the pointer! Sometimes a smaller conversation is a little more intimate.
Thanks for the pointer.
I wish I had free time to participate, but since it sounds like you are engaged with them, Can you say anything about how active Mastodon devs are in SocialHub discussions?
There are the occasional complaints that Mastodon is off doing its own thing, and I wonder how founded those accusations are.
@volkris there's one core team member of Mastodon and another active contributor participating. They only intervene in aspects that are directly related to their own project.
But I think that's alright. My opinion is opposite to most people. A FOSS project that cares first of all for its own app is logical and fine, and that can amount to full time work. There's no obligation to do more.
I feel that it is up to SocialHub community to provide enough incentives to make participation attractive.
I don't think singular identity services work very well because everyone has to play along, and once you're in you can't get out -- in the USA I think of the Social Security Number that was, for many years, used as an identifier for government services until it then became a "one stop shop" for identity theft.
I do like the idea that one account would link every service -- and in some way we have that with profiles here and "verification" on one level.
To clarify, it's completely up to the user as to how to use/project identities.
For example, a single human might choose to at least have one professional identity and one hobby identity. Or heaven forbid a trolling identity.
Heck, they could choose to start a new identity for each season of the year.
As it stands technological limitations require an identity to be split between different services. It sure would be nice if those barriers could come down, leaving it up to the user to decide how to represent each identity they wish to be.
A lot of people have multiple Mastodon accounts on different servers -- so that would have to be somehow stopped if this were ever to take effect.
I don't see that happening soon because the whole idea that is encouraged is that you can be multiple places on Mastodon at the same time -- using various identities -- and that's just fine from what I understand.
There's no reason the two couldn't coexist.
Have multiple disjointed accounts if you want. Register the same identity to multiple instances if you want.
You do you.
Doesn't that defeat the idea that you know the identity of the person you're dealing with -- don't we want the ID to go both ways?
We don't want one person claiming to be your friend, and then troll you on another account, right? There needs to be a unification of purpose, or the whole idea appears to fall apart.
@david@boles.xyz @volkris@qoto.org @tedcurran@indieweb.social IMHO the missing part is all about the (missing) Certification Authority
Good point, and that would also help with some of the revocation issues brought up in a thread I came across.
Maybe it's a bit complicated because Fediverse IS centralized, just centralized to each of the federated instances.
(We should reconsider calling it decentralized. Maybe federated instead of decentralized.)
I don't know how nicely the centralized instances would play with differently centralized CAs.
Although with https already in the mix, I suppose they already are.
What a mess :)
It is a mess, and maybe unsolvable. People get on their "instances" and the Admin runs them like Little Elons if they wish -- banning, blocking, protecting -- and that's the beauty and danger of what's happening.
Right, and that sort of disconnects the idea of a Fediverse where there is no controlling authority to issue, or validate a cert.
Oh but there IS a controlling authority to issue a cert: each instance is a controlling authority issuing or presenting certs through the following process.
Fediverse is all based around centralized instances handling all of that for their users, and as such they have latitude to go about their processes as they see fit.
For better or worse.
Not really. Each Mastodon instance is an island with a sort of agreed upon idea of cooperation, but nothing is guaranteed.
Each instance can, at its worst, become its own Little Elon.
How would a Nazi federated instance prove their certified user identity when most of the Fediverse will have blocked them?
They're there offering the proof for anyone who wants it. They can prove it.
If nobody takes them up on that offer, that's on the ones declining to check.
So only some people would be verified? Doesn't it need to be everyone in the same pool to work?
Well it's up to each user. It's up to you. Do you want to see posts from people who aren't verified?
For some users they will say no, they only want to see content from verified people. Other people, myself included, will be interested in seeing even what unverified posters are posting.
One of the main benefits of this is empowering users, giving them more information and more control over their experiences on the platform.
You choose what you want to see. Not everyone has to be verified, and it's up to you whether you want to see only verified people or not.
"On the Internet, nobody knows you're a dog."
You DON'T know the identity of the *person* you're dealing with anyway. You only know the identity that you're dealing with.
This is all expression, to some level artistic. I don't want anybody trolling, the same way I don't want anybody making bad music, but when you empower people to express themselves, well ::shrug::
If a person wants two identities, one friendly and the other trolling, that's their expression and their choice.
Hope it works out for them.
Like I said, someone with a professional identity and a hobby identity seems pretty reasonable, right? Makes sense?
Well, once you empower users like that some are going to do things you or I might not approve of. That's how a user-centric platform goes.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Internet,_nobody_knows_you%27re_a_dog
But then there's no predictability in behavior. For this "single identity" to work, people can't have more than one.
I don't follow.
Just because I can have an identity that multiple platforms recognize doesn't mean I can't have more than one.
Heck, I have multiple email accounts for work and personal stuff, and both of them are recognized in multiple places around the web.
Same thing. Some people will have one identity that they use in one place, some people will have multiple identities that they use in multiple places, and people will also choose the other perturbations, just like they do with email accounts today.
I don't understand the concept of wanting to be more than one identity. You can associate a variety of instances to one identity, but shouldn't people always want to know exactly who they are talking with online?
Nope. For example, I have no idea who you are as a person, and that doesn't bother me.
Whoever you are, if you're interested in talking, cool.
Or more to the point, if you're interested in talking in the non-troll persona you've been speaking with, cool. :)
You might be the world's biggest troll as a person, but this identity of yours isn't, so I'm happy to keep exchanging, because it's not the person that we engage through here.
(I assume you're not actually trollish person, but the point is, it's the identity I'm talking to, regardless of whether you actually are a trollish person or not)
But as a person, I don't know if you're employed, but if you are, aren't there some things you wouldn't want your employer to see you talking about? Having that work-life separation? Being able to express yourself outside of any fear for how it might impact your career?
We all wear different masks in daily life. We talk to parents differently from how we talk to friends.
Really, those are all cases of having different identities.
Well, what you're saying confirms there's no need for Federated-approved certification for people, because you already trust me by default as is, so adding ID wouldn't make a difference to you in your scenario.
Say I wanted to follow your content and you are posting both micro blog posts through one program and videos through another. I could use your certificate to follow you and know that both the microblogs and the videos are actually coming from the same identity even if they are coming from different instances.
It's not about proving who you are as a person.
It's about your being able to brand your content across platforms, if you want to put it like that.
Oh, and my Boles.co micro.blog auto-posts to my Mastodon timeline and sort of "Federates" in a way that something like WordPress does.
The synthesis doesn't go both ways, though. Boles.co just posts to Mastodon, not the other way around. Boles.co does also post to the Internet Archive and my GitHub, too.
I'm a confused about Pixelfed because I thought that service was also able to extended posts to other services, but I'm not yet seeing how or why. So, that's a silo.
On the topic of #Fediverse identity, I dipped my toe in for a second and came across an interesting thread.
#ActivityPub is the tip of a huge (and I'd say convoluted) iceberg, so it's hard for me to remember much of it at once.
Oversimplifying, identities are merely URIs, so a person could be credited for content across platforms by specifying the same URI on each post. Except...
I refreshed my memory on the protections against simply forging someone else's id by specifying their URI.
When a person is followed, their server/instance issues a certificate on their behalf, which causes other problems should the server lose the cert.
I suppose the next hoop to jump through, that I don't have time to dive into, is wondering whether the user could simply provide their person cert as they register on a new instance.
That is super confusing -- and not great for the newbie and the technically uninclined. They have no idea was a cert is or an SSL or even how to confirm an identity.
They don't know that they do, but they do :)
Users DO know what a cert is, they just don't know that they do. Every time they hear about a website being secure or see the little padlock in their web browser they're hearing about certs and SSL.
Every time they enter a password or see the "Authenticate with Google!" button they're looking at confirming an identity.
No, you should absolutely not use the technical terms for nontechnical users. You make it userfriendly for them, but it's not a problem at all to do it.
Yes, I think they passively know what security means, but if you ask them to explain it in detail, they can't -- and to have a "personal cert" they have to manage for ID would sort of require them to do things, manage, and protect their universal ID.
@tedcurran @volkris @david I NZ Govt has something like this implemented by multiple agencies, across range sites and apps. No idea what the tech stack is under the hood or license is or whatever but it's good. Perhaps different in terms of scenario, but agree it would be amazing have a similar digital passport across the fediverse. FediMe? Yeah way better than setting up and trying to manage multiple id's and accounts and shit all over the place.
That's super interesting and helpful, thanks!
I discussed this on today's Boles.tv live stream. It's a fascinating topic!
Is Mastodon the center decider of what happens in the Fediverse? If not, isn't that sort of what we want in decentralization? Not one central place that controls everything else?
Twitter, Facebook and Instagram are their own siloed "instances" and mainstream people don't seem to have a problem using multiple identities on those platforms.
Ha, I and people I know are quite annoyed at having multiple identities on those platforms! :)
Waddaya mean I have to have different usernames on different platforms because mine was taken?! It's bad enough to remember different passwords and post the same content multiple times to reach everyone; but I can't even have the same name with the same friends?
We kind of grumble and accept that because we know those are different companies who don't play well with each other, so we're caught in their corporate drama.
#Fediverse should be different, though, a grand paradise where different platforms work together to build something beautiful! Well, one can dream.
With #PixelFed and #Friendica working together to share content cooperatively over #ActivityPub, it sure would be nice if they'd also cooperate to recognize single identity handles to put users (or identities) finally at the center of the story.
You make excellent points! Managing identities can be a test of function for many people. I think that's sort of why so many older folks hooked on Facebook just stay there. It's easy, safe, and they know who they're dealing with on a policy basis.
Oh no, and it's really worth understanding what Facebook offers that other platforms kind of don't.
You know the idea of technical problems with technical solutions vs social problems with social solutions?
By emphasizing connections through friends of friends and other strongly personal indicators, Facebook offers social solutions to social problems of gauging trust for people, punishing misbehavior, etc.
You don't have to rely so much on bots or moderator whims if you can see that Bob is a friend of my best friend Mary, so Bob is likely a good guy.
It's the functionality other platforms, including Mastodon, would do well to consider if they aren't focused on growth growth growth.
Yes, one thing I like about Facebook is that they require you to use your identity and actual name. There are ways to get around that, but the idea is right.
@volkris @david Agreed it's not ideal. I feel like I've heard about efforts to develop decentralized personal identity keychains, where you can lend your identity to a service without that service OWNING your identity, you own it. I don't recall what it's called or if it's ready for prime time yet. Identity as a service? I imagine it's complicated, as identifying oneself inevitably is.