Well it's about democracy.
You might not like these people, but they were elected by their constituents to be representatives in the democratic institution.
When you talk about a powerful nation being powerless in contrast to these democratic results, well it comes across as awfully authoritarian, maybe even fascist.
I'm sorry you don't like how the democratic process worked out, but to use rhetoric about the power of the state to oppose democracy? That's troubling.
It is about the democratic process because they were democratically elected to the democratic institution.
You are welcome to want to use the state to punish them. But let's be clear that you're talking about applying authority that would subvert the democratic process that elected them.
That happens from time to time in history.
The results tend to be less than ideal.
Your general argument seems to hinge on the idea that holding alleged criminals accountable is rooted in "want[ing] the state to punish them." Here, you've made the idea of justice seem perverse.
In addition, you insinuate these figures being democratically elected makes legal pursuits against them into a witch hunt. Again, justice is made perverse.
Voters can elect who they choose. But our justice system should hold people accountable regardless of whether they hold office.
Not at all. Prosecute away. There's nothing to stop prosecutors from prosecuting democratically elected representatives.
It's a completely separate issue.
But it just has nothing to do with their being democratically elected, and it is dangerous territory to talk about overriding voters or undermining the democratic process because one would rather authorities bring down a hammer.
@volkris My original post was intending to speak to the powerlessness of our justice system to bring alleged traitors to justice. But I can see, with your third paragraph, how the phrasing can get mixed up with the wrong message.
I'm going to amend the post here since we've got an edit feature.
@stopgopfox @volkris
As you give thought to your edits, there's also the question of what actions rise to the level of criminality.
Is it criminal to vote not to certify the electors?
Is it criminal to assist in the submission of fake electors?
Is it criminal to show people around the Capital knowing they are planning to storm the capital?
IMO, no, yes & yes, but are there criminal statutes that fit?
Is there evidence to convict?
One thing it's not is cut & dried.
Well the thing is, if it's criminal then there will be a specific statute to reference. It wouldn't just be eyeballing the situation and giving an opinion.
So, what specific statutes would criminalize these actions even assuming they happened?
@volkris @stopgopfox
Got me.
<snark>IANAL, but I know a DOJ with a few who might know. Perhaps we should defer to them? </snark>
FWIW, @Teri_Kanefield has both a lengthy FAQ post on her blog/website as well as a series of blog posts breaking down lots of 1/6 related judicial activity.
I've found her takes to be well reasoned, sober and based on the law and the facts that we actually know (vs. the vibes that seem to thrum around the "why haven't they..." rage posting).
@joeinwynnewood @stopgopfox @Teri_Kanefield
Still looking for that specific statute.
@volkris @stopgopfox @Teri_Kanefield For the people who sent fraudulent documents to the National Archives:
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/371
and
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1001 (subsection a, 2)
For the people who gave tours, IF they knew the reason and subsequent plans to storm the Capital with the intent of interfering with certification of the election:
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2384
and
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1515 (subsection a,1)
@joeinwynnewood @stopgopfox @Teri_Kanefield
Right but that stuff has been debunked as a kooky conspiracy theory.
@joeinwynnewood @volkris With the fake electors, an article about Michigan specifically mentions forgery of a public record and election law forgery.
I agree with you that not voting to certify electors is far trickier to prosecute.
Finally, with showing those around the capital? If an investigation reveals any knowledge of the rioters' intent, at the very least aim for conspiracy to commit a criminal offense. That can be up to 5 years in prison in DC.
One problem is that so many of these accusations are based on misunderstandings of laws or the processes of electing presidents.
I'm always amazed that in the US we have people who every four years stop and ask, wait, how do we elect elect presidents again? How does the electoral college work?
We have so many people who have no idea how government actually works voting on government. But that's democracy for you.
Frankly, I suspect that the reason Biden hasn't prosecuted these people is because the cases against them are seriously deficient, that they actually didn't do things violating federal law, regardless of the sensationalistic reports that biased outlets are putting out.
Sometimes a person is not prosecuted simply because they didn't break laws and articles attacking them are just stupid and wrong.
@volkris @joeinwynnewood I agree we have many gaps in knowledge about civics, but that's a topic that has lots of factors.
The only thing I wonder about with your comment is whether it's fair to say "Biden hasn't prosecuted." Based on what we've seen in public, Merrick Garland is given a pretty wide berth.
If Biden were the one who is responsible for enforcing justice, then that certainly would be political and fascist. I'm personally frustrated with Garland and the DOJ, not Biden.
Never forget that the Department of Justice is 100% under the control of the president.
Under the design of the US government 100% of the executive branch is the responsibility of the president, and an enormous reason for that is so that we can hold the president accountable for everything that happens under his branch, and we can even impeach him for anything that happens under his branch of government. This is a critical element of the design of the US government.
Every single thing that Merrick Garland does is the responsibility of Biden. Again, that's just built into the design of the US government because if any underling misbehaves, including Merrick Garland, the president stands to be impeached over it.
Every time the press secretary talks about the independence of the DOJ she is doing a disservice to the design of the US government, and it is really really annoying to hear it because it is misleading the public.
The president is absolutely responsible for the Department of Justice. The president absolutely stands to be impeached if the DOJ does wrong. We absolutely need to hold him accountable, whether you happen to think they are doing a good job or a bad job, it is 100% up to the president to make sure it is a good job.
@volkris @stopgopfox There's quite a big distance between being ultimately responsible for what DOJ does and directing DOJ to do very specific (politically driven) things.
The former is both factually correct and near universally accepted. The latter is, if not universally as it used to be, still widely accepted as necessary both for justice to be administered fairly (very much not sufficient) and for maintenance of democracy.
Nixon mucked badly with the fair administration ...
@volkris @stopgopfox component (as had his predecessors with various unconstitutional domestic spying programs). Congress acted subsequently to restore it.
Trump mucked badly with the democracy component.
Biden and Garland are, with justification, going overboard to restore this critical norm.
No, I would say that the person responsible for the department is responsible for the department always and at any time.
And that is key to the design of the US government.
It is all on the head of the president. Intentionally, that is how we are supposed to hold those agencies accountable.
@volkris @stopgopfox Most if not all current & former DOJ employees and DOJ adjacent attorneys disagree, committed to the post-Nixon norm that DOJ (& FBI) must be independent of POTUS; POTUS' proper responsibility is to ensure this is true.
"The most important guarantees of DOJ/FBI come not from the Constitution or statutes, but from norms and practices that since Watergate have emerged within the Executive branch."
https://www.lawfareblog.com/independence-and-accountability-department-justice
@joeinwynnewood @stopgopfox So you're saying employees of the DOJ think the DOJ should be more powerful? :)
But no, they're wrong. The Constitution provides only three branches of the US government, and having the DoJ answerable to a president who can be held accountable for it is part of the bedrock principle of checks and balances of the US Government.
It's natural that they want more power. We should naturally be distrustful of giving more power to the police and letting them act so outside the law.
@volkris @stopgopfox No, it has nothing to do with allocation of power. It's about blunting highly problematic interference of existing power on legal outcomes.
They rightly believe that DOJ should be bound by the law without influence of the political calculations of the White House or any state house or any mayor's office.
It's also not giving more power to police. If anything it should reduce the power of police by ensuring that the rules apply to them and bound their actions.
By law the DOJ answers to the president, which is the way it is held accountable through checks and balances.
The very notion that the DOJ is independent of its own chain of command is necessarily and literally proposing that it act outside of law, which again, clearly puts it as answerable to the president.
The rules say the answer to the president. When you talk about them being independent you are flat out saying the rules don't apply to this law enforcement organization.
We are of course free to amend the Constitution to give the police their own branch of government, but that sounds pretty sketchy to me, but either way until that happens it is flat out putting them above the law to say they are not bound by the existing legal structure in the US.
@volkris @stopgopfox You are so not listening.
Independence in decision making on day to day operations is quite different than anything you are talking about.
Does the Chairman of the Board tell the plant manager how to run the plant? No. Does that remove their fiduciary responsibility? No. It would just be bad for the company to stick their nose into plant operations.
It is the same for DOJ and the country. It is bad for POTUS to stick his nose in proscecutorial decisions. Really bad.
Wow, I don't know what kinds of companies you're familiar with, but yeah companies do tend to stick their noses into plant operations to make sure the plants aren't going way off track and doing bad things.
And by analogy, I would say it's REALLY REALLY IMPORTANT to keep law enforcement from going off track and doing bad things.
I don't know why you seem so trusting in law enforcement agencies, but history tells us bad things happen when they're allowed to operate without such oversight.
@volkris @stopgopfox You keep pretending my words mean completely different things than what they actually say which is, to say the least, aggravating. It's also rude.
My words and the facts don't apply to "law enforcement agencies". They apply to DOJ prosecutorial decisions.
No Board Chairman sticks his nose into plant operations no matter what the performance. If things are off the rails they fire the executive(s) in charge and hire someone new.
We are done here.
@stopgopfox @volkris
I know of 1 MOC who was involved in some way with the fake electors scheme in PA, but the document had conditional language, unlike MI, so likely no crime. I'm not aware of any other MOCs who participated in the scheme.
Knowing someone else intends to commit a crime does not make you a conspirator, nor does witnessing others committing a crime, even if you cheer them on.
There seems very little basis for removal of the great majority of GOP MOCs.
The whole "fake electors" conspiracy theory is based on missing that the US legal system requires token gestures to stand up and present somebody who has been harmed for the sake of standing.
It's not some weird conspiracy theory; it's just a standard legal fiction.
People getting all upset over this particular element just really don't understand how legal system works in the US. And that's a shame because they are all too often falling for a conspiracy theory based on lack of understanding of how the legal system works.
@volkris @stopgopfox I don't think that's the basis for the potential criminality in this instance. IANAL, but I read/listen to the musings of a few good ones, and the crux is conspiracy to defraud and having defrauding the US Government by having sent fraudulent elector certificates to the National Archives.
What to know about the Trump ‘fake electors’ scheme
https://www.cnn.com/2022/01/27/politics/fake-electors-explainer/index.html
@volkris @stopgopfox
It's not a democratic system when huge amounts of money from unknown sources are funneled into campaigns. When big money effectively owns elected members. When voters are disenfranchised and personal integrity is completely gone.
Of course it is, because people are still voting those members into office.
You can talk around that all you want but at the end of the day, unless you are saying the voting system is itself reporting inaccurate results, it's still democratic.
@volkris @stopgopfox
I say it's undemocratic because huge sums of money are being used to mislead voters and buy politicians once they've been elected. Kyrstin Sinema is a case in point.
@volkris @Oldfartrant @stopgopfox you are the one talking around the actual point here. The post is more about the failures of our judicial process than about the democratic process. Though their precense in our Congress speaks volumes of the latter.
@KingDetrick @Oldfartrant @stopgopfox
When the OP highlighted people being on the floor of Congress to debate anything, it seems to me that was focusing on disagreement with the election of these people by their voters.
If the point was just about the judicial process then I would not have mentioned Congress at all since it really has nothing to do with their election.
If somebody should be rounded up by the authorities and thrown in jail or whatever, that's a completely separate issue from voters voting for their representatives.
@volkris @Oldfartrant @stopgopfox So you didn’t read the post in full? Got it.
@KingDetrick @Oldfartrant @stopgopfox
Some kind of breakdown in the fediverse? The post was nothing but talking about the people on the floor of Congress, at least as it showed up on my instance here.
@volkris @Oldfartrant @stopgopfox Confirming the definition of “insurrectionists” would go a long way with assisting you across the finish line here.
@KingDetrick @Oldfartrant @stopgopfox
Oh, in my experience the definition of "insurrectionist" these days means "person I disagree with."
We live in stupid times.
@volkris @Oldfartrant @stopgopfox I think I’m fine disagreeing with a person that pays for sex, with underaged girls, via cash apps. But guess that’s just based on my experience. Stupid times indeed.
@volkris This isn't about the democratic process. These individuals subverted our laws to try to steal an election and organized a coup attempt. Those individuals should be held accountable in the courts but have largely subverted consequences.
Having no accountability for seditious acts is what I find troubling. If organized violence and fake electors are part of the democratic process, I don't know what to say.
Having laws enforced to protect democracy shouldn't be considered undemocratic.