"The removals may have violated Jones’s and Pearson’s First Amendment rights...the rights of citizens of Memphis & Nashville to be represented by the legislators of their choice and rights the pair have...prohibiting discrimination on the basis of race."

Tennessee expulsions prompt Senate Democrats to call for DOJ inquiry (gift article, no paywall): wapo.st/3oasa03 #JustinPearson #JustinJones #TheTennesseeThree #TennesseeRepublicans #Racism #Fascism #USsenate #SenateDemocrats #DOJ

@GJGreenlea

Regarding potential DOJ cases against the TN GOP:
“I think those cases would be challenging to win and I don’t see any immediate payoff from those cases for these legislators given one’s been reinstated and the other one is likely to be reinstated,” said Aziz Huq, a constitutional law professor at the University of Chicago.

I disagree about the "no immediate payoff" part of Huq's quote. Both Pearson and Jones will be subject to special elections to keep their seats. The chances are small that they wouldn't win, but there are still chances. The full force of the DOJ should be brought to bear against this assault on representative democracy.

#TNLeg #GQP #Democracy #USPol #USPolitics #NoJustinsNoPeace #Fascism #TheTennesseeThree

@volkris @GJGreenlea
I'm not a lawyer, but the article identifies 3 potential charges:

"The senators argue that the removals may have violated Jones’s and Pearson’s First Amendment rights to free speech and assembly, the rights of citizens of Memphis and Nashville to be represented by the legislators of their choice, and rights the pair have under the 14th Amendment or civil rights statutes prohibiting discrimination on the basis of race."

Follow

@shansterable

Thanks for the suggestions, but all three of those clearly don't stand up to the lightest scrutiny here.

Nobody has a right to break the rules they agreed to and impede a democratic assembly, so there is no first amendment issue, and in breaking rules these representatives voluntarily stepped down, which is between them and their constituents. They effectively chose to stop representing their constituents. That is a big deal, IMO, but it's a problem that solves itself.

Meanwhile the legislative record shows that clearly it was not a racial issue, so there is no 14th Amendment issue to apply.

Those three charges are just so obviously baseless that it would be silly for the article even to bring them up.

@GJGreenlea

@volkris@qoto.org @shansterable @GJGreenlea No MAGA trolls in this space. No argument about it either.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.