The GOP is pursuing having the US default on its debt. This may crash the world economy, lower the value of the US dollar and likely weaken the US for decades if not the next century. Not. Good.

Not good for anyone in the US.

reuters.com/world/us/mccarthys #uspol #economy #DebtCeiling

Follow

@davidaugust

The Treasury has plenty of revenue incoming to pay its debts, so defaulting is not on the table unless the president decides to default.

The GOP isn't pursuing default, and doesn't even have the ability to pursue it since Democrats hold the White House.

Whether or not the debt ceiling is raised, the Treasury can pay its debts. The rest is up to the Democrat in charge of the executive branch.

@volkris if the debt ceiling is not raised, then the US legally cannot pay for more. That’s definitionally that is what the debt ceiling is.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_S

@davidaugust

Right, but the US has enough income to pay the debts it has already incurred, which the president is constitutionally required to pay.

Right, he won't be able to borrow more, but he will be able, and he will be required to, service the debt that has already been entered into.

@volkris no.

First, the US President does not control the purse strings, the finances, of the US Government. The Congress does, specifically the House of Representatives.

Second, the US cannot borrow money needed to pay for anything without the debt ceiling being high enough to permit it. That is the nature of what the sovereign debt of the country is and functions as.

@davidaugust

OF COURSE the president controls the purse strings.
The Treasury, the purse, is part of the president's executive branch. To say the president doesn't control the purse strings is to miss the fundamental design of the US government, and the separation of powers between the branches.

Yes, Congress has to authorize access to the purse, but once that authority is given, the control is in the hand of the president, as he is head of the executive branch.

But the US doesn't need to borrow more money to service its debt. The Treasury will bring in enough money in tax revenues to service the outstanding debt. That's why all of this talk of default is mathematically silly. The Treasury has more than enough money to avoid default regardless of the debt ceiling.

Legally the president cannot order default, but technically it's up to him. If the president chooses not to service the debt, that would be an impeachable offense in my opinion.

But because the president controls those purse strings we need to hold him accountable for it, and call him out for it.

@volkris “the fundamental design of the US government“ would be the Constitution of the United States, Article I, Section 9, Clause 7 (the Appropriations Clause): “ No Money shall be drawn from the Treasury, but in Consequence of Appropriations made by Law; and a regular Statement and Account of the Receipts and Expenditures of all public Money shall be published from time to time.”

constitution.congress.gov/brow.

@davidaugust

Exactly!

And as you can see, the language recognizes the position of the Treasury within the executive branch so that it may constrain the president's hand, requiring him to have permission to spend.

If it was Congress doing the spending then that phrase wouldn't make any sense. There would be no consequence of appropriation requirement, it would simply be saying that Congress spends.

So yes, the Constitution is clear as it defines the interaction between the executive and legislative branch, recognizing that the president must have permission to spend, as he spends.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.