@JamesBazan I’m sure you’re right. It’s not the only exchange- there are at least 5 more. One I just blocked outright claiming Dems could have stopped Trump via the GOP primary. Not how it works. We (obviously) don’t control that process.
Lots of my mutuals are following that one, too. I simply worry this stuff might work on some people.
I'm seeing increasing activity from Pro-GOP Left accounts too. They're not brand-new accounts, so I suppose this is due to changes in how I'm interacting with the Fediverse, or how they are.
Immediately after Dobbs, Pro-GOP Left messaging was extremely effective in converting pro-choice sentiment into anti-choice action. It was all over national TV news and talk shows, not just on social media.
@barney I've seen that too.
It's almost like 'sleeper cell' activity. Like they've all got pre-2020 join dates but were mostly dormant or innocuous until a few months ago.
it's anecdotal, I haven't really dug into the info, but yeah... there is something there.
I have no idea *why* they're suddenly visible or active, it might just be I'm noticing them but I don't think so.
@mentallyalex @TonyStark @JamesBazan
On Twitter, I had a better sense of inauthentic or coordinated propaganda campaigns. Often, nonstandard language revealed ostensibly US accounts to be foreign-based.
The Fediverse is changing so rapidly, I don't as confident making similar assessments here.
I think it's clear that protracted exposure to disinformation and defective journalism has both instilled false factual beliefs, and destroyed rational thinking ability, across all voter segments.
@mentallyalex @TonyStark @JamesBazan
My conclusion is that supplying evidence that corrects false factual beliefs, and/or pointing out invalid reasoning, has potential value in helping voters to realign their behavior to match their own values.
In general I think that change is likely to occur not in the Pro-GOP Left accounts that post false information or magical thinking arguments, but in others who may be following them, or following relevant hashtags.
@barney @JamesBazan @mentallyalex Barney- first I really, really like what you have to say. Glad we met.
How do you suggest dealing with an account who, no matter how many facts (with good, agreed upon sources) you supply, just say “you’re wrong.”
Say for example, the one I hear often that Democrats could have simply codified Roe during Obama, or that Biden can throw Clarence Thomas off the court. (Seriously suggested to me more than once recently.)
@TonyStark @JamesBazan @mentallyalex
Another falsehood I often see is "Biden could expand SCOTUS right now if he wanted to."
I think there is potential value in responding to such false posts with factual information, and including or adding any hashtags that might enhance the ability of one's post to reach other users who may have been induced to believe falsehoods.
Again, the target of such a reply is probably not the account to which one is replying, but others who may see the reply.
@TonyStark @JamesBazan @mentallyalex
Sometimes, a Pro-GOP Left account will reply back to me, restating the same falsehood. I think there's potential value in replying to that reply, again supplying disconfirming evidence.
This is in case someone happens to "tune in" to the conversation late, such that their exposure to the thread stared with the false reply.
@TonyStark @JamesBazan @mentallyalex
However, posting correct information and valid reasoning process only has the potential for positive effect if it reaches someone who believes a falsehood or isn't thinking properly.
If you reply to a low-follower account, and your reply contains no hashtags, then you're really only reaching your own followers, and that is not helpful.
@barney equal challenge of providing bad faith accounts with a platform. Someone like Tony responds to someone with single or double digit followers and now everyone who hangs on Tony's account looking for people to bully can now drill into his response for new targets and potentially new members of their campaign.
I know it seems fantastical, but like Necromancers they raise soldiers from the bodies of those they attack.
@mentallyalex @TonyStark @JamesBazan
Good point. Replying to a disinfo account gives that account a second chance to target your own followers. That problem is larger for a big account like Tony's.
The relative effectiveness of that follower-targeting tactic is smaller in the Fediverse than it was on Twitter, because people follow hashtags here. Disinfo trolls can target a hashtag's followers just as easily as they can attack a person's followers.
@barney
I agree in part, but I would think that hashtags make weaker targets.
If someone is following a hashtag I have to either target the person using the hashtag directly, or hope for someone to also use the hashtag that I can 'twist' for my purposes, right?
By attaching to Tony, I can reply to him, heat him up with something minor. I don't want him to reject me I just want *his* followers to engage. Similar to the old joke about the secret to finding out something on Stack Overflow is to make two accounts.
1 - Ask the question.
2 - Answer yourself wrong.
3 - collect the 40,000 right answers from people wanting to correct you.
You can use that on someone like Tony as well. "trip" or make a subtle misstep and see who shares his responses and who responds to me. Those people are likely targets for "high impressions".
With disinformation, subtle is going to play a lot harder than direct. Not everyone has the mentality to loudly disagree so they'll just consume without question.
@mentallyalex @TonyStark @JamesBazan
Excellent point. One that I shall ponder more deeply offline.
Follower-triggering often allows trolls to change the subject of a thread and effectively instill false info. E.g.:
Me: Actually, Biden can't expand SCOTUS. That requires an act of Congress, and the Dems don't have enough votes.
Troll: Whatabout how the Dems could have codified Roe, but they refused to, because they are secretly anti-abortion? [this is false]
My follower: You suck, troll.
@mentallyalex @TonyStark @JamesBazan
That kind of "follower-targeting whatabouting" allows trolls to attack my followers with disinformation. The absence of a directed reply tends to imply that the disinfo is true. My follower is unwittingly helping the troll attack themself and all my other followers too.
@mentallyalex @TonyStark @JamesBazan
Sometimes I'll jump back into such a thread, even if I previously deemed it unworthy of further engagement, with something like this: "That's false, but the topic of this conversation is expanding SCOTUS. Biden does not have the ability to do that. You said he does have that power, but that is false. Expanding SCOTUS requires an act of Congress."
@barney @mentallyalex @TonyStark @JamesBazan
The pushing of false narratives about what it is possible for Biden or Congress to do contributes a lot to the voter apathy which is what makes progress so much more difficult.
@JamesBazan @barney @mentallyalex @GreenFire Hoping everyone who follows me takes this in, although the last person I explained this too in a very sincere way told me to fuck off, which in turn affects my motivation and negatively affects turnout.
Suppose I’ll just block those people from here forward.
The explosion of anti-Dem disinformation in the immediate wake of Dobbs was, IMO, probably the clearest-yet demonstration of how our faulty information environment causes would-be progressive voters to act in direct opposition to their own deeply held values.
1/n
One day post-Dobbs, MSNBC interviewed an attractive young woman who used her national platform to unleash a litany of anti-Dem lies. MSNBC didn't push back to correct her.
MSNBC identified Zoe Warren only as a "protester." In fact, she's a member of Rise Up 4 Abortion Rights, a phony front for a cult that is well known to real abortion rights groups (https://www.instagram.com/p/CfPGy-Vub-u/?img_index=1).
2/n
A Pro-Republican Left activist with a large Twitter following amplified those lies, and took them a step further: In a Twitter video that I think is still up now, he asked his pro-choice followers to sign a petition, in which they promised NOT to support the pro-choice party.
A petition is a powerful "foot in the door." Inducing someone to take an action like that helps to cement their commitment to a cause, and ensure their later loyalty.
3/n
@barney @TonyStark @JamesBazan @mentallyalex @GreenFire To Tizzy's credit, he removed the tweet and the TikTok. But I can find no record of what he actually said.
If he did delete only that Tweet (and not, say, all of his tweets), then I agree, that is to his credit.
He replayed MSNBC's video of the anti-Dem cult telling anti-Dem lies, and then he mirrored their anger, demanding that the Dems "do your job." He asked his followers to sign an online petition, pledging to stop donating to Dem candidates, and not vote for them, until they did things that were not actually possible to do.
@edwardchampion @TonyStark @JamesBazan @mentallyalex @GreenFire
@barney @TonyStark @JamesBazan @mentallyalex @GreenFire I don't see any tweet or TikTok to this effect. It would be helpful when making claims about someone to archive the tweets and the videos.
Well, you're in luck. Turns out Tizzy never deleted the tweet. It's still up:
https://twitter.com/TizzyEnt/status/1541203023984197634
@edwardchampion @TonyStark @JamesBazan @mentallyalex @GreenFire
@barney @TonyStark @JamesBazan @mentallyalex @GreenFire Thanks. I watched his TikTok and it is not so much about her and more about the general problem of Democrats begging for money when they refuse to do anything to codify Roe. A criticism that you probably don't want to hear, but given how many pledges for money I get in my inbox, often from Democrats who have done fuck all, it isn't invalidated by this "activist" being a possible plant.
The topic of this discussion is how the messaging of the Pro-Republican Left causes even people who care deeply about abortion rights to act in direct opposition to their own values.
This video is an example. He asked his pro-abortion-rights followers to stop donating to or voting for the party whose work protects abortion rights for millions of American women.
@edwardchampion @TonyStark @JamesBazan @mentallyalex @GreenFire
@edwardchampion @barney @GreenFire @JamesBazan @mentallyalex We also need to keep in mind that we’ve never given Democrats big enough majorities in the national level to accomplish codifying Roe although we can’t actually codify it now, Roe itself. Ship sailed. On the local level where the majorities are sufficient, Democrats are doing quite a lot.
@TonyStark @edwardchampion @barney @GreenFire @JamesBazan @mentallyalex
It’s worth noting that there has not been a filibuster-proof senate since th 1970s.
I think the Democrats briefly had a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate, for a period of 72 working days in 2009. They used that majority to pass the Affordable Care Act, one of the most monumentally important pieces of legislation in history. They never had enough votes to pass an abortion protection bill, because a few of the Dems at that time were anti-choice.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/111th_United_States_Congress
@Tengrain @TonyStark @edwardchampion @GreenFire @JamesBazan @mentallyalex
The problem is that those clear majorities of voters don't actually exist when it comes down to specifics.
For example, you may get a ton of people to agree that some abortion should be available, but once you start asking about particular methods, specific limitations on length into pregnancy, and other guidelines, disagreements show up, and the apparent consensus breaks down.
All that has happened around abortion reflects that political reality, that people have honest disagreements over abortion, and the only way to resolve the issue is to work to build actual agreement, which is unlikely to be possible.
@barney @Tengrain @TonyStark @edwardchampion @GreenFire @JamesBazan @mentallyalex
@barney @mentallyalex @Tengrain @GreenFire @JamesBazan @edwardchampion @AnneTheWriter1 Additionally, as we all know, Republicans don’t intend for this issue to be left to the states. See the mifepristone ban we all know about. We can’t even pretend we will have alleged “differing opinions.”
The recent mifepristone issue is a matter of FDA compliance with general federal regulation of drug approvals, nothing about abortion in particular, and not even about anything involving politics.
The FDA stood in violation of general statute that wasn't focused on abortion. The executive branch didn't address the complaint. A legal mess ensued.
@barney @mentallyalex @Tengrain @GreenFire @JamesBazan @edwardchampion @AnneTheWriter1
The downside risk to calling for a national standard is that the standard might be a bad one :)
It's the all the eggs in one basket issue.
But to this point, it's easier to find strong consensus on a state by state basis considering the diversity between regions and communities in the US.
It will be hard to build a good national consensus here. It's much easier to build that at the state level. And maybe, the state experiences can help shape a national consensus over time, but only if the states do start out with the job.
@barney @Tengrain @TonyStark @edwardchampion @GreenFire @JamesBazan @mentallyalex
@volkris @barney @Tengrain @TonyStark @edwardchampion @GreenFire @JamesBazan @mentallyalex
Very good point about when differing opinions hold #abortion to be acceptable. But as long as we have it on a "crazy quilt" state-by-state basis, health care will be impossible for women to plan, and doctors will be dangerously hesitant to provide needed care.
We need a national standard, even if it's a minimal national standard.