The size of the US supreme court should be at least 20 justices, then choose nine by lottery for each trial.
For term limits; a maximum of two terms of 18 years seems like a good compromise.
The presidential election should include an up or down vote for every justice in their first term.
Any justices that aren't approved by a majority of the voters should not be allowed a second term, ever.
Add a new justice every year with a term set for 18 years, with only one more term permitted by a majority of voters approving that next term.
Stop appointments after 20 justices, until there are fewer by deaths or terms ending.
Prevent Congress from holding up nominations by limiting the "advise and consent" to 180 days.
No excuses! They either vote to block the nomination or it goes through with the President's choice automatically.
Every case should be in front of 9 justices selected by lottery from those available to serve.
This allows for a more efficient and reliable supreme court. Any recusal or other unavailability can be addressed by another drawing by lottery.
This means any particular bias won't be known before the selection and will only last as long as the case, not over the entire term of service.
All of that would really undermine judicial independence and grant more power to the president, really undermining the system of checks and balances that are there to make sure citizens' rights are respected by officials.
We have representation through the legislative branch. We should not be turning the expertise of the judicial branch into just another popularity contest, as its job to craft logically coherent law is to important for that.
We see the mess that elections cause in Congress and the presidency. We should go running from the idea of bringing that to the Supreme Court as well.
Please explain more.
The president doesn't gain any power from these changes.
Every justice is guaranteed a term longer than any other federal office, but just not lifetime anymore.
Currently, the president is obligated to find a nominee that the Senate is interested in having as a justice.
Those are serious constraints on his power: he can't legally NOT act, and his actions must reflect the preference of the Senate, even if those aren't his own.
Your proposal turns that on its head, allowing the president much more latitude to nominate the person he personally wants even without review from Congress AND it gives him a way to intrude into Legislative Branch business, prompting the Senate to interrupt its other work to take up this issue.
Imagine, for example, if the Senate is working on legislation the president doesn't like. He could start sending over nominees that he knows they'd find unacceptable, just to have them stop work on that legislation to debate his nominees endlessly.
So yeah, an awful lot of power for the president to exercise unilaterally.
Not at all, certainly the advice and consent is not removed, your argument would not work without it, it just isn't allowed to be deferred forever.
If the legislative branch can't find time once a year to come to a decision on a nomination, then I would argue that it is not functioning properly.
The allowed to be deferred forever is a key feature of the check on presidential power, though, both requiring him to find a nominee that the Senate finds compelling and preventing him from interfering in the business of the other branch of government.
Remember, by design to support the consent based approach of the chamber, procedures in there can take a lot of time. They literally do not have time to do everything all hundred members want to do.
Whether that approach is for better or worse, it is the approach that the Senate has adopted forever.
Really, if we don't like that the Senate isn't interested in an candidate, we should elect better senators, not bypass this protection built in to the system.
Do you have any evidence that "no action" was an intended outcome?
As I understand it, reject or approve were the options available and it was just a loophole that allowed this deferring your job forever to happen 10 times in the history of the USA.
https://www.senate.gov/legislative/nominations/SupremeCourtNominations1789present.htm
Why are you convinced that it's a "key feature" that was always intended or even a protection for the system?
To be clear, it is not the job of the Senate to consider presidential nominations. That would run counter to independence of the branches, and it would allow the president to have influence over the Senate's work, which raises conflicts of interest.
Instead, in the US system of government, it is the *president*'s job, not the Senate's job, to run the appointment process. It's an Article II responsibility laid on the executive branch, not an Article I responsibility on the Congress.
If the president fails to nominate someone the Senate is interested in, then he is given no authority over the Senate to interrupt legislative business to force consideration.
No action is the default for ANY business before the Senate that senators aren't interested in spending time on.
Since the appointments clause doesn't ask anything of the Senate, what leads you to believe inaction is not available?
Again, this is an Article II instruction to the president, but there is no parallel instruction telling the Senate to do anything, which I'd say leaves it up to them.
And that's setting aside the way this all fits naturally into the system of separation of powers, coequal branches and all of that.
It'd be strange to me to interpret the appointments clause as allowing the president to command the Senate to act, for many reasons, not the least because it doesn't say so.
Well, you quoted the text above and it doesn't call for action by the Senate.
"shall nominate" and "shall appoint" are the only calls for action, and the president is the subject for each of them.
No, my interpretation is based on the text first and foremost, with the location emphasizing its role in the structure of the government and separation of powers providing yet another confirmation that my interpretation is the correct one.
Not only does the text NOT call for action from the Senate, but it would be inconsistent with the rest of the design of the federal government if it did.
The text explicitly calls for action by the Senate, no matter which section it appears in.
Also, there is the example of how Washington and his Senate handled these actions in the first place.
Please read this link for more: https://law.marquette.edu/facultyblog/2016/02/the-senate-must-consider-supreme-court-nominations-in-due-course/
Your interpretation rests entirely on the location in the text and that there isn't a duplicate instruction in a document written by hand with a quill? That's a very weak foundation unless you have something more.
@volkris