Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
Probably not the first person to ask this, but what happens if Trump's puppet Judge is not removed and will not recuse herself?
I feel like there are a million ways she could tank this case and then he could not be tried for these crimes again.
Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
Well firstly, keep in mind that you are sort of making an ad hominem attack. You are attacking the person instead of the argument.
But to answer your question, the US has systems of appeals so that even if a particular judge does misbehave there are other levels to address such misbehavior.
Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
@volkris @Popehat @GottaLaff @TonyStark You are correct, but my presumption of her how she’ll act is based on her previous actions. The 11th circuit found she had clearly over stepped her role previously, rebuked her and removed her.
They could certainly remove her here as well.
My question is more related to what happens if they *don’t*. How likely is it she tanks the case?
Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
I don't think it really matters that much.
Personally I don't get behind this perspective that is demanding pounds of flesh, demanding that Trump be punished. I just don't really care about the guy.
And the case is not as solid as a lot of people think it is.
But even if it is a solid case and the judge acts inappropriately, well then there are appeals to address the judge messing things up. It'll be taken care of.
I just don't think we should be so obsessed with this in the first place.
Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
@volkris @Popehat @GottaLaff @TonyStark
I don't see this as Trump "being punished" or a "pound of flesh."
You break the law, you stand trial. Period. That's where we are. If it were anyone else I'd say the same thing.
If the case is weak and he is found innocent, so be it. If he is acquitted because of judicial favors - that's another thing entirely.
And I wouldn't call it obsessed - it's historical and we're part of it.
Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
Well that's pretty much my point.
A lot of people don't see this police action as being punished, but it absolutely is, and that is something that folks need to come to terms with as they look at the world.
This is police action punishing somebody. Maybe it's for the best, maybe it's entirely deserved, but it is police action punishing somebody, and even if it's for the best, that is part of the story to come to grips with.
If you don't see this punishment as punishment, well, that's the issue. It is punishment being handed down from authorities and that needs to be reckoned with as we look at the situation.
Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
@volkris @Popehat @GottaLaff @TonyStark I understand what you’re saying now.
What I meant was that it’s not like they targeted him or mistreated him.
He broke the law. He did it on audio and video. He left behind what seems to be a mile long evidence trail.
He is being brought to trial - I don’t see that has punishment. Sentenced is punishment. That’s where I was coming from.
Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
Well I do think they targeted him, again whether you think that targeting is good or bad is a separate question.
And part of the issue here is that by targeting him it plays into his rhetoric, jives with his constituency, that he was being targeted by some dark forces.
It's a tricky issue whether to go down this road or not.
On one side we have these kind of vague laws and prosecutorial discretion, and on the other side we have confirming Trump's whole argument that the government is out to get him.
Legally it is questionable and politically it is extra questionable because we are basically confirming the position of a guy who lives on drama.
Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
@volkris @Popehat @GottaLaff @TonyStark Maybe I’m getting caught up in semantics
“Targeted”, to me, implies that they were looking for a crime to “get him.” Like a cop stopping you for a busted tail light that he just busted.
In this case, he was very public about the laws he broke. They gave him ample opportunity to return the docs - when he refused they charged him.
Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
Those facts are contested, though.
Trump supporters make a big deal about how he did return documents, was happily working with the archives about returning more, and wasn't given time to address their additional demands.
It's another case where there are two completely separate sets of facts that different groups are working with.
I suspect reality is somewhere in the middle, but hopefully through the trial we might sort some of the conflict out.
Marking Sensitive because not everyone wants to see US political stuff
Yep, so that's exactly why I caution people not to rush to judgment here and be aware of that there are contested facts at the heart of this case.
I often do think of it in terms of a murder trial: people keep rushing forward with murder accusations before we even check to see if there's actually a dead victim involved.
By analogy, so many of these accusations over the last decade or so have involved murder accusations where the supposed victim is right there joining the chorus, jumping up and down very much alive, and pointing fingers. The world is just that absurd these days :-)