#USPolitics

The most dangerous challenge republicans posed to Democracy has been struck down (surprisingly) by the #SCOTUS

State lawmakers will NOT have unlimited control over their local federal elections, ability to toss out votes etc. This was a huge push after 2020.

nytimes.com/2023/06/27/us/poli

Follow

@SirTapTap

I mean, it's not surprising to people who follow the Court more closely.

I honestly believe that very often any person who is surprised by a Supreme Court decision needs to reevaluate where they are getting their news, since apparently their news source is misleading them as to how the court is operating.

@volkris it shouldn't be surprising but no, the current court has largely cast off precedent as a thing and if we were playing by "obviously correct decision" it's still completely insane this was 6-3 and not 9-0.

@SirTapTap

Well that's not true.
If you read the current court's opinions they have precedents at the core of most of their arguments. It's precedent after precedent in their conclusions.

As for 6-3, the reason it wasn't 9-0 is because three justices pointed out that there wasn't a live controversy that could be addressed:

"In short, this case is over, and petitioners won. The trial court’s original final judgment in favor of petitioners, affirmed by the State Supreme Court in Harper III, represents “the final determination of the rights of the parties” in this case. [...] As a result, petitioners’ alternative Elections Clause defense to those claims no longer requires decision; the merits of that defense simply have no bearing on the judgment between the parties in this action. That is the definition of mootness for an issue."

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.