With great reluctance, I'm forced to the conclusion that affirmative action as implemented over these many years in the U.S. has become increasingly stretched and distorted, like a ball of Silly Putty that began as a perfect sphere and over time became unrecognizable tatters with pieces breaking off at random. A valiant effort, however.

@lauren

Justice Jackson summarized what many see as the problem with SCOTUS' ruling in herdissent in the UNC case (independent of how deformed the silly putty might be):

“With let-them-eat-cake obliviousness, today, the majority pulls the ripcord and announces "colorblindness for all' by legal fiat. But deeming race irrelevant in law does not make it so in life.”

Follow

@dmm

If that really is a good summary of the counterargument, then it shows how weak it is, and why it didn't carry the day.

I did find Jackson's perspective to be pretty naive, misunderstanding the role of a court in the legal system, and in the country, overestimating the power it might have to dictate things to the whole society.

But let-them-eat-cake really underscored it: this isn't about eating cake, that's not the question, this is about ending the taking of cake from people.

After all, and this might be news to Jackson, SCOTUS can only rule in the face of actual harm. It has no authority to distribute cake.

@lauren

@volkris @lauren I understood her comments to be more serious than you make them out to be.

@dmm

I'm sure she is serious!

But her perspective is naive. It comes across as unserious to people who take the role of the Court seriously.

This is the sort of thing that many of us criticized her for when she was first nominated to the chair.
@lauren

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.