Follow

@coctaanatis

I mean, if the law is dangerously in need of reform then reform the law. That's the democratic process that the US system is based around.

It's a bit foolish to complain that a judge isn't maintaining an illegal system, kicking the can down the road until the next time it comes in front of a judge, instead of just fixing the law so that the result is durable.

@volkris The Court is reinterpreting the Constitution, not just ordinary law. And it's doing so in a novel way that essentially overrules Constitutional and historical precedent. It's using its authority to essentially create new "rights" that didn't previously exist. Passing new laws doesn't fix the problem.

If you'd read the dissent you'd understand that.

@coctaanatis

Right, when I say law I mean all law, not just statutes but also the Constitution, and my statement stands: if we need to change the law, including the Constitution, then we can.

Nothing in recent rulings has been particularly novel to anyone who's been following legal arguments over the last decade or two or longer. Many of these decisions had been telegraphed for quite a while, as the Court cited plenty of background for each.

I don't know why you keep referring to the failed argument as if it's authoritative. Of course I did read the dissents, and I saw that they were wrong. ::shrug::

I mean, if you'd read the winning argument you'd understand that :)

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.