News flash, we interrupt the anti-Israel rant you are in the middle of writing (centered around the Hamas report of an Israeli attack on a hospital), to call attention to news that the rocket was fired by the Palestinian Islamic Jihad. Please update rant accordingly.

@jaymcor Seems neither of these stances have been confirmed yet, with both sides blaming the other.. Has there been any third party analysis to confirm this, both sides seem to make good arguments regarding the other.

I myself have held off on having an opinion until i can get some fact.

@freemo US govt has confirmed. This will devolve into an argument about who is a neutral third party. The evidence linking it to the Islamic Jihad group: video from multiple angles, eye-witness reports, an analysis from the IDF, and an intercepted phone call between two terrorists. The evidence saying it was Israel: as far as I know, an immediate and unsupported accusation from Hamas? which they apparently knew was incorrect, but it still worked, with the help of decades of propaganda.

@jaymcor why do you assume everything will devolve into an argument, when we have never had an argument?

Why so scared to have a mature respectful discussion where people may disagree.. thats not an argument, that is sharing views.

@jaymcor anyway, you say america has done this. Can you please point me to that analysis/report so i can review what the evidence is. Thanks

@freemo I hunted down references and wrote something up. Unfortunately, it will not fit in this !#$!% 500 character limited space. So I uploaded it as a LinkedIn article. You should be able to view it without logging in or creating an account. Let me know how it works for you, and if there any major issues.
linkedin.com/pulse/what-eviden

@jaymcor Excellent job at a write up. I read it but need to dig a bit further before I have any comments. Excellent detail though, thank you for that!

@freemo I think I'll link to it from my main feed, for better visibility, since it seems kind of important, given that people are rioting worldwide over essentially just this bad info. Ironically they wouldn't bother rioting if it they knew it was just the usual terrorists blowing up a hospital, because that's just accepted as normal life and nothing can be done as with floods and earthquakes... (obviously I don't agree with either idea)

@jaymcor Considering the effort you put in I agree, it makes sense to put it on your main feed.

Would you like me to share it from my main account for others (32K followers)?

@freemo That's a big crowd. I guess so. No doubt there will be heat. But again, it seems like there's a lot of rioting going on over something that appears to be a falsehood. If you are willing to first have another glance and provide quick reactions and feedback to improve it and make it as neutral as possible, I'd be interested. I doubt I can or even should completely shroud my bias, but for that large of an audience, I guess I owe it to them to improve the text as much as I'm able.

@freemo Wired has an article out on this, except that rather than addressing the big question everybody wants to know, they mostly just rebuke the spate of amateurs (like myself I suppose) trying to assemble summaries, often biased, rather than leaving it to the pros, and accusing them of just wanting clicks... Although some people are clearly doing that, and phoning in the analysis, none of the one-liner quick rage mongers are beholden to such rebuke, and the motive critique is hypocritical.

Follow

@jaymcor

As if the pros don't want clicks? :)

FWIW, over the past year, particularly with regard to the Ukraine war, I've been struck by amateurs doing a much better job at assembling and presenting news than the professionals.

Professional journalism has simply really seemed to go downhill over the last decade or so.

@freemo

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.