Barred from public housing by law, discriminated against by private landlords, ineligible for food stamps, forced to check the box indicating a felony conviction on employment applications for nearly every job, and denied licenses for a wide range of professions, people whose only crime is drug addiction or possession of a small amount of drugs for recreational use find themselves locked out of the mainstream society and economy, permanently.

–The New Jim Crow

#Law #Crime #Drugs #Justice

@NanoBookReview I'm definitely against those laws, but let's not devalue Jim Crow by equating it to repercussions for behaviors like these.

Jim Crow laws attacked people for what they were. These laws, stupid as they may be, respond to choices people make.

@volkris The book goes into great detail about how the unequal enforcement, prosection, and sentencing of the drug laws have resulted in a defacto racist system, all while being color blind on paper. The system sustains itself even without very many actual racists working within the system. It's definitely worth a read. The author herself says that she would have argued against the very idea until she worked in law for a decade.

@NanoBookReview Oh I'm certain of it, and yet I would say as bad as those effects are, they're not really comparable to Jim Crow.

It's like the person who is asked to work late too often comparing themselves to slavery. Yeah, certainly an issue, but orders of magnitude matter.

@volkris I think that the hyperbole is meant to jolt the reader into considering just how bad the problem really is, but I can see it having the opposite effect on some people for sure

Follow

@NanoBookReview so this reminds me, when I talk to my professor friends, they often have philosophical disagreements about whether you should teach the material in a way that is a bit false, but easier to understand and more accessible, or absolutely correct, even if it's a little harder for the students to grasp.

Personally, I side with that second option, that a teacher should always teach true things, even if the student has to work a little harder to wrap their mind around it.

So same thing here. I want activists to stick to hard and legitimate comparison, and avoid exaggeration for the sake of impact.

Just my personal take, but I feel like in the larger picture that might even be healthier for the interest that the activist is pursuing.

@volkris I think that's fair.

Michelle does a good job on the history of slavery and the transition to Jim Crow, demonstrating the latter as an alternate form of social control when the former became unworkable. When J.C. fell, the drug war took its place.

The successor systems took time to figure out and entrench, and they both had to fit within contemporary norms. The drug war is analogous to Jim Crow in that they serve the same purpose within different societies, not that it's just as bad.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.