@arstechnica send? No.

If folks want to participate in a big experiment in survival on Mars, let's go for it. It would be their choice, and there are plenty of people willing to do it.

Framing things like this as sending overlooks agency.

@volkris @arstechnica But there is also something like human dignity that people can't give away, even if they want to. That is why people can't sell their organs or why certain experiments on humans aren't allowed. This is such an experiment.

Follow

@kaffeeringe the problem is that people may disagree on what that dignity entails, and I would even say you risk undermining dignity by imposing your personal feelings of dignity onto others.

You quickly get into issues of bodily autonomy.
Would you let me tell you what you can and can't do with your body? I would hope not, especially since you don't know me 🙂

I can already tell that we have different ideas about what constitutes dignity, so it's pretty likely that you would not like for me to impose my own values on you.

And that's why this is tricky.

@arstechnica

@volkris @arstechnica I wouldn't let you decide on me, and I don't want to decide on you. But there are standards and what they are is part of public debate. This book seems to argue, that nobody should go to Mars, because [I didn't read the book].

@kaffeeringe but farming the imposition out to one social institution or another doesn't change that it is still imposing the decision on you or me

Regardless of who or what is deciding on you or me, it's still deciding on you or me, imposing some other standards, imposing others' ideas of what we should and can't do with our bodies.
@arstechnica

@kaffeeringe and that makes it okay?

It strikes me as being pretty blithe to tell me what I can't do with my own body in my own future merely because, well, every law imposes on me.

@arstechnica

@volkris @arstechnica That is not what I am saying. I am only saying that we are living in societies with an ethical basis and democratically decided rules. The first article of the German consitution is "Human dignity is inviolable." This protects me against the state but also against other people lowering that bar voluntarily. They can't sell their organs so I don't have to do the same.

@kaffeeringe and I'd say it's a violation of human dignity to tell people what they can and can't do with their organs *shrug*

I also don't see how undermining others' self ownership implies any protection for you.

@arstechnica

@kaffeeringe @volkris @arstechnica Highest dignity is not personal freedom, like Volkris seems to write. Like human rights, dignity is a value, not negotiable by free debate. I am very pro debate but I am not an advocate of endless freedom. Freedom counts as a theme for people without freedom. Not for decadent übermenschen willing to flee the mess they - them also - made of it.

@birdutterance I don't think that perspective is very defensible, but in the end, that's one reason to allow people to go their different directions with whatever conclusions they come to about the world, so long as they're not able to oppose their own on others :-)
@kaffeeringe @arstechnica

@volkris @kaffeeringe @arstechnica Well, like money, freedom is also something that needs to be present as a minimum but as soon as it starts to accumulate it bears trouble.

@volkris @kaffeeringe @arstechnica To force me into defence is not working.
I recently read Andrea Wulf ‘the magnificent rebels’, then, about 1800, freedom and individuality were rather new. But these are not the utmost highest standards, they are part of a whole and they should not kannibalise other parts of that whole. Community, when people make appointments, peoples limitations, so many things are playing a part.

@volkris @kaffeeringe @arstechnica I see people shielding there opinions off with: “freedom!!” - every thing goes when shouting this. So it is of empty content.

@birdutterance well it's about balance and compromise around educated consensus where lines should be drawn.

When you talk about freedom needing to be present as a minimum that doesn't sound like being open to respecting things like bodily autonomy. Rather, it sounds like a pretty open door to quashing of actions and ideas that the folks in power happen to dislike.

It's not about everything goes. It's about sitting down and saying, ok, are we really going to enforce this level of conformity? Or might we appreciate that when people have more freedom than the bare minimum, some actually great and important things can happen?

@kaffeeringe @arstechnica

@volkris @kaffeeringe @arstechnica

Thanks for your reaction, isn’t the case we agree on not having a colony on Mars?

You are interpretating my words on a level of society and I was writing freedom counts for people without freedom, as you write on actions these might be needed for groups of people in need.
Individuals calling it their freedom to leave everyone behind in a technical experiment with death (dying on Mars) is what I call decadent.

@birdutterance call it what you will, but regardless of your personal feelings on the matter, those feelings aren't informed if they overlook the agency of the people who choose to take the trip.

"Freedom to leave everyone behind" is not a factual description of what's being proposed. You're focusing on what those individuals DIDN'T do while skipping right past what they DID do.

Again, it's understandable that your personal values differ from others. That's part of living in a diverse society.

But if a bunch of people decide to go on a dangerous trip with full knowledge of the risks, well this one isn't for me, but I respect their agency to make those decisions for themselves.

@kaffeeringe @arstechnica

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.