@eeyam the one where we recognize the importance of lifesaving surgery and see a way of making it more accessible to those in need?

And decide that we should at least consider it?

@volkris @eeyam people can already donate. selling implies abject desperation. supporting it means “i’m ok with such a system.” i’d prefer to have a new system, thanks.

@iquaanyin selling implies associating with someone else for mutual benefit, implies being better off having found that way to help someone else.

We sell things all the time even in the absence of desperation.

Selling only implies that the seller has taken an opportunity to be better off in the world.

We should at least consider the problems in blocking people from such opportunities to come out ahead.

@eeyam

Follow

@iquaanyin *selling* implies it.

It doesn't matter what you're selling, the implication is that you find yourself better off having made that choice, or else you wouldn't have done it.

But I was thinking, you can look at it the other way around: if it does imply abject desperation, then outlawing this transaction doesn't outlaw the abject desperation. That person is in just as bad a place as before.

It's just that you've removed one option from that poor person for responding to their situation.

@eeyam

@volkris @eeyam well, sure. like how when someone buys some fentanyl, they feel like they are better off. or when a troubled teen ows down others with an ak47, he believes he got the better end of the trade off (his freedom, or life, for being able to do it). so what?

@volkris @eeyam i also would bet any amount that selling one’s organs (vs donating them) is *always* a desperate act. i can’t envision a situation where it would just be a preference, like, “oh shoot, i need more money today.” i don’t see it as a thing where “if” applies, other than in a sentence because yes, we can all string words together. but the importance of words is their meaning, and how that represents reality.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.