Is it ethical for a service to charge extra for Spanish support?
#poll #polls #vote #spanish #appdesign #appdev #apps #saas #mobile #ux #uxdesign #productdesign

Follow

@benbloodworth Why not?

If it costs them extra to provide, but it gives some users additional value, it seems plenty reasonable to charge extra to the ones that derive that additional value for the additional cost to provide it.

@volkris @benbloodworth

Offering access to a service for one group of people based on their language at no additional cost, while charging more for access by another group of people based on their language, to the same services - seems discriminatory to me.

If a restaurant in Spain charged me more to order in English, I would not find that reasonable.

@ShaunBurch

It is absolutely discriminatory, but we generally accept discriminatory action throughout societies.

You go to a restaurant and pay more for a steak than for a side of fries. The discriminates based on what you order, but we say that's ok.

Same here. Why WOULD we expect everyone to pay the same price when one level of service is more costly AND more valuable than another?

The Spanish speaker gets a more valuable service as the establishment gives personalized service. It's reasonable to charge the one getting the more valuable service for the cost of the service.

Yes, that's discrimination. No, it's not unreasonable.

@benbloodworth

@volkris @benbloodworth

It sounds like we’ve agreed on discriminatory, and the poll asked whether that was ethical. So is it ethical to be discriminatory?

@ShaunBurch it depends on the circumstances, what the nature of the discrimination is, but very often--maybe even overwhelmingly often--it is absolutely ethical to be discriminatory.

Let the ambulance go first, discriminating in favor of medical care.

Let the starving person get first shot at the food aid, discriminating against the folks who are already fed.

And on and on.

Discrimination is only a tool, a way of treating different people differently, which is SO OFTEN entirely ethical and appropriate, even if in other cases it's not.

All too often people throw out the tool instead of looking at how it's being used.

@benbloodworth

@volkris @benbloodworth

So is it ethical to discriminate the cost of access to a service based on someone’s language?

@ShaunBurch it doesn't sound like this is discriminating based on someone's language.

Rather, this is based on the person receiving additional value, at a cost to the supplier, regardless of what languages they may or may not be able to speak.

If it costs more to supply the service the choices are to pass that cost over to everyone or to charge extra to the one who receives extra value from the additional service.

It has nothing to do with the someone's language since the other factors are the same regardless.

@benbloodworth

@volkris @benbloodworth

> additional value

If an English speaker in New York City is charged $9.99/mo to subscribe to Netflix while a Spanish speaker in New York City is charged $10.99/mo to subscribed to Netflix – is there an additional value? Is it ethical to charge the Spanish speaker more?

@ShaunBurch seems pretty clear to me that there is additional value!

If you value content in a particular language, then that is more value to you.

I honestly don't think this is a tricky question.

@benbloodworth

@volkris

hang on, if the English speaker is getting “service in their own language” and the Spanish speaker is getting “service in their own language” …this sounds like they’re getting the same value for different prices.

cc: @ShaunBurch @benbloodworth

@maco

The question was framed as charging extra for Spanish support, which I took to mean that Spanish support was an option, not the main language of the platform.

So with the framing of the question, one's getting a value-add option.

@ShaunBurch @benbloodworth

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.