Two polls about federating with Threads (1/2)

Threads (a fairly new social network from Facebook's parent company Meta) is testing integration with the fediverse.

Opinions differ on whether or not this is a good thing.

Some people think this is great: if all goes well, it's an opportunity for people on Mastodon, Pixelfed, Misskey, and other fediverse platfirms to follow (and eventually communicate with) friends and public figures on Threads.

Others see it as a threat -- because of Meta's long history of exploiting people's data without consent, hosting hate groups and harassers, discriminating against LGBTQ+ people, Black activists, and Palestinians, and contributing to genocides.

When the prospect of Threads federating was first discussed last summer, most polls showed that opinions were roughly split.

What do people think now that it's getting real?

This poll asks about what you personally plan to do; the followon poll asks about what you want your instance to do.

#threads #fediverse #meta @fediversenews

@thenexusofprivacy @fediversenews I think integrating with threads overcomes the greatest weakness of the #Fediverse: not having one central "town square" where things like breaking news, current events, and political discourse can be visibly debated. Since #Twitter X'd out, it's harder to engage with public figures and follow major news releases. I bet that stuff will live on #Threads, and we can tune in or out as much as is healthy/ non-toxic from over here in #Mastodon.

@tedcurran
Sadly though, it may ruin the one great strength of the Fediverse, which is that (at least up to now) there isn't a ruthless monopolistic corporation with two decades of experience in not only enabling some of the most ghastly atrocities worldwide, but also algorithmically manipulating what their millions or billions of users see, while mining their data in order to further corner advertising markets, starving news organizations of revenue, resulting in closures, buyouts and mergers in that sector globally, further consolidating political and informational power firmly in the hands of ultrawealthy news tycoons - who, let's recall, are part of the same multi-billionaire class as the folks who run these "town squares", which are totally furthering the common good, wink wink, which is why folks like Zuckerberg are also happy to drop a quarter of a billion dollars to build personal apocalypse bunkers just in case all that rage-engagement they're monetizing fully boils over and they need to get out of Dodge

journa.host/@w7voa/11157868291

@thenexusofprivacy @fediversenews

Follow

@smallpatatas but this wouldn't be giving Meta control over Fediverse.

Fediverse instances would still be in charge of user experiences.

I think @tedcurran puts his finger on something important, that this would be the best of both worlds, Threads basically offering more content to Fediverse for free while not having control over the system.

@thenexusofprivacy @fediversenews

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.