@timbray I think the key, and the drum I keep beating because more people need to realize it, is:
#Mastodon, #Fediverse, and #ActivityPub were built on the assumption that you have no #privacy here.
Anything you post is available to the world, no matter what settings you might choose for the post, no matter if you try to delete content, etc. That's just how the system is designed for better or worse.
(And I think for worse)
People should not post on such a fundamentally public place and expect privacy. That they do is a really big deal to me, that they're not informed about how the system works in this regard.
But since they are posting so publicly, well, public is public.
When I clicked I got an unauthorized error message.
But they're different user interfaces to the same content, to the same universe.
That's what I'm trying to emphasize.
So you DO go to PeerTube to consume everything on the Fediverse, including those 2,000 word essays, even though you might or might not skip over them because the interface isn't very good at displaying them.
It's all the same content, so no particularly different corners.
We have different interfaces to empower different users to consumer all of that content in the ways they each prefer.
It's like, a book vs a book on tape: same content, just different interface because one person prefers to read the physical paper while another listens while driving.
@LumiKlovstad your comment is really funny to me as it takes some poorly defined terms and throws in a few more just for the fun of it.
It's simultaneously a bit circular and insubstantial, except for the mud it slings.
@jayrosen_nyu
That's the opposite of my take.
Again, as I said, their strategy might be for the best.
They just can't pose as if the House shutdown is a terrible thing that the Republicans are doing when they're aligning with the hardcore Republicans to vote against the appointment that would open it.
If keeping it closed is a good thing, then great, they should own it.
Except it's not just Republicans' mess since until a Speaker is chosen Democrats don't get to work on legislation either.
The lack of a speaker impacts all aspects of the House of Representatives, and at this point Democrats are complicit in any mess caused by their disinterest in resolving the vote.
They could have easily voted for McCarthy and gotten their chamber to work yesterday, but instead they effectively voted with hardliner Republicans against resolving the House's issues.
They voted to maintain their own mess.
If Democrats were really sad as they say they are about the lack of a Speaker delaying procedures in the House, then they could have easily either voted for McCarthy or simply abstained in voting against him to allow the election and get things going.
For better or worse, Democrats' votes are complicit in the delay of getting to work.
Again, maybe that's even for the best, but let's not let them get away with pretending they're not part of this process.
There's an important detail to understand about #USPolitics : the Senate leaders don't have nearly the power we're told they do.
However, you can see the alignment of interests to promote that myth: the leader gets a feather in his cap while other senators get to duck responsibility for their (in)actions, blaming those pesky leaders.
Today's drama in the #House over #McCarthy strikes me as members of the lower chamber trying to glom onto their own version of that myth, just in a stupider way, as befitting a lower chamber.
Oh no, it would be a whole term with Republican dysfunction out front and center as a moderate Speaker is unable to wrangle the reps who both disagree with him AND are then personally insulted in how it went down.
Meanwhile, the House could get to work on a moderate course despite the ongoing Republican party dysfunction, which would only hurt the party in the next election cycle.
This is actually sounding like a better idea all the time...
What, he thinks elevating a moderate Republican above the wishes of ideologues in the party would solve party dysfunction?
Seems to me that would help them find that partner while leaving Republicans squabbling even harder. But it would at least reopen the House.
No.
See: checks and balances.
Intention to undermine other aspects/functions/pillars of government was a core part of the system.
I absolutely avoid those terms myself! :)
I try to use more concrete, more well-defined terms. For example, I might talk about people holding certain policy preferences that are relevant to the discussion, or I might use terms "Democrat" and "Republican" since at least I can refer to official party platforms.
Also, I absolutely hate when reporters frame Supreme Court justices as conservative or liberal especially since their approaches don't fit nicely into two categories like that, much less with connection to broader senses of those terms.
Yeah, the terms need to be retired in general conversation.
Well, we might actually be on the same page :) but just in case...
To illustrate, a Mastodon instance exchanges content with a PeerTube instance just as it would a different Mastodon instance, regardless of different design goals.
ActivityPub unifies them without concern for differences. Generally, anything participating in AP has to work with content from any other participants, as it thinks best for its readers.
Kind of different user interfaces to the same system.
I think you'll find that in American politics, terms like conservative and liberal have drifted so far over the generations as to have largely lost meaning.
Even just talking to self-described conservatives you'll hear vastly different political ideas.
That's just how the vernacular changes over time.
US Politics
Well, representative distribution is a big and complicated topic, but at the least we can simply say that the constituencies being represented are divided, even if we may have issues with the constituencies themselves.
CRS has a nice history of Speaker elections here. A member crossed the aisle in 2001, but generally members have always felt free to simply abstain, indirectly giving a hand to other candidates.
Either way, though, a stronger national consensus (of constituencies) would solve the drama. We don't have that, though.
I'd emphasize the authority part, not the consensus part.
It makes me want to allude to "consent of the governed."
The majority voting process is a test to make sure most of the House is really on board with the vision by which the Speaker aims his authority, and he will need their continued support over and over as he proceeds.
If the Speaker can't pass this test when being handed his authority, there's a good chance he will fail when he tries to implement the plan he's proposed, causing more trouble in short order.
Really, this is a vote on whether the House should proceed in a direction, and if the members of the House can't decide, then it probably shouldn't until they can.
US Politics
One way to put it is that if Americans were more on the same page, then the opinions of such a small minority wouldn't matter.
Such people exist in every Congress. They're just normally overshadowed by the general national consensus.
More importantly, though, the Speaker is chosen by consensus of our representatives to manage the House in the ways they want it conducted, and with so much division in the population, it's no surprise that disagreements are being represented.
We're all hostage to our own disagreements. It's no surprise that the representative body reflects that.
One reason is that they aren't voting for a mere representative but rather for an administrator who will have quite a lot of authority in the chamber. That's how the House is designed.
They need to come to active consensus about who is going to set the operations of the House, as they will all have to live under those actions.
Dropping candidates to force a winner doesn't make as much sense when the winner needs such buy-in from the members he oversees.
PLUS, there are legitimate and healthy negotiations tied to the election of a Speaker.
US Politics
It's really a matter of representatives reflecting a widely divided population.
After all, McCarthy is facing not only a few loudmouths in the minority but the entire other side of the aisle not coming to a consensus about the direction to go.
It's not the final voter that counts, after all, but every other vote in the room leading up to the last one.
Since I guess everything is political these days, I'll identify as extremely liberal but without a home in US politics.
Mainly, there's so much misinformation out there that people in society have trouble even organizing into coherent political groupings. So I'd rather not talk about politics but instead focus on information and education. Nothing else matters until the bedrock of fact is buttressed.
So: Old man yells at clouds is a famous joke from The Simpsons, and it probably fairly describes what we do when venting on social media.