Show newer

@Npars01 @csgordon@zirk.us @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @Mastopoet @GreenFire

And the FairTax folks are extremely critical of the Canadian tax as they emphasize the substantial differences between their tax and the Canadian policy.

The FairTax folks agree with your characterization of Canada's plan, which is why they emphatically don't go that direction!

@dkbgeek @csgordon@zirk.us @Npars01 @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @Mastopoet @GreenFire

And that's the exact reason why the FairTax proposes to mail people checks to make sure the middle/lower class isn't screwed by sales taxes.

That's a core part of the proposal.

Folks who talk about the idea without mentioning the parts that make it progressive are being dishonest.

@Mastopoet @Npars01 @csgordon@zirk.us @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @GreenFire

There is this unchallenged mythology out there that spending time in classrooms is necessarily beneficial to the student.

It's not.

But educational institutions do enjoy selling that story, even as students may find themselves unable to gain employment based on their certificates, and find themselves having wasted all that time, at least.

@Npars01 @Mastopoet @csgordon@zirk.us @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @GreenFire

The FairTax proposal would directly send checks to the poor.

@TransitBiker @Npars01 @Mastopoet @csgordon@zirk.us @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @GreenFire

It's a 30% sales tax that applies to the wealthy (who buy expensive things, mind) instead of taxing the working class, leaving the working class with more money to buy things.

The global economy will be fine.

volkris boosted

If you don’t have classified documents at your home, are you really living?

#mikepence #DonaldTrump #JoeBiden #uspolitics

@DanielEsq @DemFromCT

Well it's significant that we know Trump's people were in contact with officials in the current administration to discuss the proper way to handle these documents, that he was working with them to sort out issues of what was and wasn't classified.

@csgordon@zirk.us

But that is my point exactly: there is an enormous difference between foregoing revenue versus giving away revenue.

Politicians love to conflate those, but it is not realistically coherent to say they are the same.

Like, my not handing you some money is not the same as you losing money. It's just not factually reasonable to say they are the same thing.

@Mastopoet @csgordon@zirk.us @Npars01 @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @GreenFire

Well great! The FairTax proposes to exempt ALL wages from taxation!

So far the Biden administration has proposed a number of extremely regressive taxes, ones that would hit the poorer the hardest.

I'm no Republican, but I will call that guy out for either his regressive taxation or his complete ignorance as to what he is actually calling for as he mumbles out vague proposals that make no sense.

@Npars01 @csgordon@zirk.us @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @Mastopoet @GreenFire

That is factually incorrect.

By law payroll taxes are required, and have always been required, to be deposited in the Treasury just like any other taxes. So by law payroll taxes pay for everything from congressional toilet paper through Ukrainian armaments.

Seriously, it's written right into the law that established Social Security in the first place.

Eliminating income tax just means that workers keep more of what they earn, more of what they trade their labor for.

Heaven forbid!

@Mastopoet @Npars01 @csgordon@zirk.us @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @GreenFire

What in the world?

The FairTax is specifically designed to take from the rich and give to the less well off! It's specifically has elements of the plan to make sure what you describe doesn't happen!

@Npars01 @Mastopoet @csgordon@zirk.us @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @GreenFire

Yeah, but we make the mistake of electing stupid officials who build that infrastructure without charging for it.

We should not blame corporations for that. We elected them. That's really on us.

@Mastopoet @Npars01 @csgordon@zirk.us @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @GreenFire

Wow, I just want to point out in response to this one is that no cost student higher education is highly, highly regressive, ending up asking the poorest to help fund educations that help the best off make a lot more money.

Any economically progressive stance would completely reject that sort of strategy.

@dkbgeek @csgordon@zirk.us @Npars01 @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @Mastopoet @GreenFire

You would have a point except that proponents of the FairTax acknowledge and then address that issue very very very emphatically by transferring money to those people to make sure this is not impact them!

This is a core element of the proposal.

@klardotsh @fuzzychef

They're both!

Tech companies were overpaying for underperforming employees AND this financial reality is shown by the lack of competition for talent as different industry outfits are coming to that realization, looking at their output over the last couple of years.

@tmruppert

This is focusing on the wrong branch of government, though.

The question of whether or not to issue debt is, as per the Constitution, up to the Congress, not the president.

We really need reporting to be more clear about the different roles of the different branches of government in the US.

@wdlindsy

But Robert Reich is the one obscuring what's going on, as he's been flat out misleading his readers about how the US government finances actually operate.

The US Treasury is bringing in plenty of money to service its debts. It reports its balances continuously and publicly, so we can verify that for ourselves.

Robert Reich tries to say otherwise because it's convenient for him to push his politics.

There is no hostage holding here.

Democrats in the last Congress passed spending bills without passing any way to actually pay for them, and the debt limit is kicking in exactly as it's supposed to when things get so out of balanced.

@Npars01

How do you mean that with sales tax every citizen becomes a tax collector?

I really don't see how sales taxes are any different from income taxes in terms of people wanting to pay them or not.

Well, it does remind me of people wanting cash payment for work to avoid income taxes, though.

There's no difference there.

@csgordon@zirk.us

Oh no, there is no appeal to morality required to say that if you have a thing and I don't take the thing away, so that you still have the thing, I have not given you the thing.

That's math, not morality.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.