Well, they're politicians :)
Yep, they're engaged in politics, as politicians, so hopefully each of their constituencies feels well-represented through their actions.
But all of these politicians are engaging in politics. Don't forget the entire Democratic cohort there voting in the way that prevents getting things done as well.
They're all politicians, hopefully representing the wills of the people who elected them.
Think of it as efficiencies of scale.
Yes, they exist, but at some point along the curve the efficiencies tend to drop off.
Any large organization will be the same. For a while, getting bigger may become more efficient, but after a point the overhead of managing the beast means growing larger doesn't come with the same increase in efficiency.
The corporate lifecycle is often directly related to getting a fresh start on a company that's overshot that healthy part of the curve.
Keep in mind that it's not what we all think of those 20, but about what their own constituents think about them.
I don't have the polling on that, but if they're representing their people well, well that's their job.
Also, it's worth zooming out to ask how we all feel about all of our representatives, so many of whom are actively empowering that 20 by voting for the division they're taking advantage of.
I, for one, wish my rep would respond "present" so the 20 would have one fewer ally supporting their stunt.
I imagine the #Democrats have consulted their pollsters and come to a general agreement among themselves that this gridlock is for the best.
Whether they reached that agreement because they honestly fear #McCarthy or because they think this is a political cudgel they can use in cynical political rhetoric we can't really say.
Remember that at any moment the Democrats can resolve all of this by merely doing nothing. Should a couple of them just decline to actively vote, the matter is settled, and McCarthy wins.
It's not only that Democrats aren't crossing the aisle; it's that they are choosing to actively vote in a way that leads to this gridlock.
Keep in mind that once a Speaker is elected, the Rules of the House kick in and grant the Speaker very broad, discretionary powers through which he can promote his initiatives.
That's why everyone's fighting so hard against electing a Speaker they don't want to empower.
The negotiations are about how the Speaker will use his discretion, to see if they can find a compromise that will get things done later.
You're missing that democratic processes elected all of these representatives who are voting to keep the House deadlocked.
It's not pandering to anti-democratic forces on display here; it's democratic forces themselves representing voters who are very divided.
You've overlooking the political realities, though.
Without those pork barrel projects, it's not clear that NASA would have received even the funding that it got, as politicians weren't all that interested in diverting federal dollars away from their closer-to-home projects.
Democracy for the win!
If Mastodon is four times bigger than the rest of the Fediverse
combined, then that means to focus solely on Mastodon is to miss that other 20% of the universe.
So yep, it just goes to show that The #Fediverse is bigger than just #Mastodon!"
The unserious kooks will always have the same ability to vote against the next person the majority of their party might rally around.
Keep in mind that a lot of the reason Republicans support McCarthy is because the job of Speaker entails a whole lot of technical work behind the scenes, organizing schedules, understanding the rules, etc, that few representatives might possess.
If the unserious kooks might vote against anybody, then they might as well stick with the guy who they think has the skillset to do the job well.
That's not how the House of Representatives works, though.
The Rules of the House govern particularly what rank and file like these holdouts can do, which is part of why they're fighting so hard right now.
They know that once a Speaker is elected, they've lost a ton of their influence in the chamber, as the Rules kick in to restrain them.
Oh, in cases like these I don't spend too much time trying to track down the bug.
I just make the developers aware of the bug, and hopefully one of them will just know where the problem is without needing to look too hard.
The idea that Republicans like these don't want to see cuts in military spending often comes down to stereotype, though.
Many Republicans HAVE Been skeptical of military spending, calling for reexamination of where the money is going and criticizing lawmakers for spending too much on the military.
The holdouts here are annoyingly vague in what they're calling for, but they do seem to be echoing the Republicans who would like to see cuts.
Sounds like a bug. Report it?
ActivityPub requires that every actor have both an inbox and an outbox.
So yes, this would require a change to the AP standard.
That's a really ridiculous position seeing as these are representatives acting through the normal order and rules of the House.
Not to mention, acting with the complicity of the entire Democratic contingent which has voted in lockstep to maintain this gridlock rather than resolve it and begin the work of the House.
It's nothing like Jan 6th.
I mean, that's kind of the point, isn't it?
If the representatives of the people can't agree on how to spend enormous amounts of society's resources, then that really says something about whether it should be spent.
It's part of the checks and balances design of the system, making sure government remains accountable to the people.
@YourNeighbor57 @AmandaMarcotte
Fascism? What in the world?
The speaker fight is literally about democratic ideals of letting people vote for the direction they'd like their chamber to go, not top down imposition of will, with the headline holdouts insisting on even more checks on the authority of management, even more power for the people, so to speak.
Talk of Democrats "bailing them out" papers over the larger picture where they're choosing to keep the House shut down. Some Pyrrhic victory that is.
But at least they're sticking it to the meanies, right?
US Politics, Speaker of the House
*sigh* Insurrection? It really cheapens the word when it's thrown around so lightly like this.
No, this is not insurrection. This is how the system is SUPPOSED to work. When the people we elect disagree on the way forward we're supposed to stop and not proceed, as we'd be moving in a direction that doesn't represent a consensus of the people.
It's silly to describe this as chaos. This is nothing happening, neutrality, the opposite of chaos.
Anyway, at any point any of the vast majority of House members-elect can cross party lines and resolve this question. All the talk of "they" ignores that simple fact.
Ooof, this thread got long, but another use case came up, and I wonder what people might say about alternatives.
Someone asked about how to boost an image post but add alttext if the original posted didn't include it.
I was thinking, this is a great use for QT. Anyone have a solid workaround, though?
Since I guess everything is political these days, I'll identify as extremely liberal but without a home in US politics.
Mainly, there's so much misinformation out there that people in society have trouble even organizing into coherent political groupings. So I'd rather not talk about politics but instead focus on information and education. Nothing else matters until the bedrock of fact is buttressed.
So: Old man yells at clouds is a famous joke from The Simpsons, and it probably fairly describes what we do when venting on social media.