Follow

Coming across another " vs " thread, I just have to ask, how is vscode at doing email? How about RSS feeds? Spreadsheets? Daily agendas? Because emacs is very, very good at those...

@worldsendless ...and the best bits wont be locked away behind a paywall as microsoft have done with .dotnet

@worldsendless Don't get me wrong here. I love #Emacs and I'm probably working in Emacs for the majority of my computer hours.

However, Emacs is NOT doing "very, very good" at #email - at all.

I can't accept meeting invitations, it doesn't link to any groupware server in an easy and reliable way, I can't compose invitations.

There may be hacks but so far, I didn't see anything I'd recommend to anybody.

For the average business usage, Emacs is a total failure with respect to email. 😔

@publicvoit @worldsendless I so wish you were wrong :). I happily use Mu4e for personal emails, but when trying to actually work with people, especially groups, it becomes, well, less useful.

@jackbaty @publicvoit @worldsendless I’ve only ever tried Gnus for email. Is Mu4e better?

(Incidentally, I’ve been toying around with @drewdevault‘s aerc for the last couple of days, and quite liking it so far, but that’s outside of the emacs realm)

@dekkzz76 @nathell @publicvoit @worldsendless I never understood Gnus. Mu4e works best for me for day-to-day email, but notmuch is very good at search and tagging. For CLI I was a longtime Mutt user. Never tried aerc but it looks interesting.

@jackbaty @nathell @publicvoit @worldsendless

IMO having used both over a period of time mu4e and notmuch are pretty equal.

@jackbaty @dekkzz76 @nathell @worldsendless In my personal life, I'm using #mutt (#slrn, #zsh, screen->#tmux) since decades on a server. Only my business #MUA (#evolution) is installed on my business host. See also karl-voit.at/apps-I-am-using/ #PIM #email

@dekkzz76 @nathell @jackbaty @worldsendless If I'd use Emacs as my MUA, I'd start with #notmuch as it is a very interestig concept, similar to the old GMail approach of not having folders at all. You get maximum flexibility for all sorts of #email management and workflows.

@publicvoit @worldsendless Do we regard "groupware" (i.e. Outlook) features as core elements of "email"?

@mhd @worldsendless I consider managing invitations as core elements of business email usage, yes. I don't want to switch from my MUA to a web interface to simply press the "acceppt"-button or to compose an invitation email notification.

@publicvoit @worldsendless Yeah, that's a prime case of embrace, extend, extinguish.

@publicvoit @mhd @worldsendless

I couldn't tell you how (but I think it's through gnu-icalendar) but I can click to accept invitations in Gnus.

@bthalpin @mhd @worldsendless Sounds like a "works on my machine" solution and not like a groupware integration. Please correct me if I'm wrong. I'd really like to read about Emacs workflows for business.

@publicvoit @mhd @worldsendless
It's an I-don't-quite-know-how-it-works reply, but gnus-icalendar (which I think is built-in) gives Gnus some iCal functionality (so integration, if limited).

I *think* this is what gives me the accept/decline buttons to click but I couldn't confirm without a bit of experimentation.

(require 'gnus-icalendar)
(gnus-icalendar-setup)

@bthalpin
mu4e hooks into the same functions so that you can at least reply to invitations quite easily: djcbsoftware.nl/code/mu/mu4e/i

I have written a package that imports events from CalDAV servers via vdirsyncer and khal (called khalel) and I am working on invitation creation. But there is a lot less existing tools to build upon so it might not go that far.. At least import from invitations works already.

So I feel your pain, Karl!
@publicvoit @mhd @worldsendless

@publicvoit @worldsendless trouble is those invitations are part of a proprietary mechanism

Evolution is quite Outlook like and says it works with Exchange

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.